|
|
printable version
- email this article
- view hidden posts
Not Another Post Election Analysis!
by Charlotte Laws, Ph.D.
Sunday, Nov. 07, 2004 at 6:45 PM
Some pundits wave election, exit poll results and argue that America is a "red" country immersed in conservative "red values." But there are several factors they seem to overlook: 1) Nader voters statistically trumped Bush voters on the "moral values" question, 2) "personal financial situation" seemed to be a decisive factor in the presidential election, and 3) exit polls are notoriously flawed.
The truly faithful have faith in exit polls, and disbelievers, well, they will have to take No Doze, eat fistfuls of Oreos into the night, and drag their sleepy heads to work the next morning. The unfaithful usually give up around 3 am. If the concession speech has not been made by then, the conceder is probably asleep. He is dreaming, of course, of his future: the million dollar lecture tour and his role as a highly paid advisor for one of the corporations who owes him a favor. Wink, wink. The exit poll, an appendage of the American election process, is rarely questioned. It could be called the greatest invention since the wearable dog house, the hijacker ejector seat, knee skates, and the arm mitten—all real inventions, by the way.
After all, it was an exit poll that reported Gore had won the election in 2000 and that Kerry would defeat Bush in 2004. Could the exit poll be the Democrat's retaliation against the Fox News Network? After all, both purport themselves to be "fair and balanced" in a delusional sort of way.
The exit poll's most recent finding was that a predominant number of people cast their votes based on the issue of "moral values" and most of them were Bush supporters. Many journalists have argued that the original question was flawed, detailing how "moral values" is not a real issue and how the coupling of "Iraq" with "Terrorism"—two other options on the questionnaire—garners a much higher percentage of votes. Namely 34%, rather than the meager 22% that "moral values" draws in the CNN poll.
This is a reasonable conclusion since a large number of Americans think Iraq and terrorism are intimately connected and that the missing weapons of mass destruction are their truant offspring. Perhaps the WMDs are thumbing rides through Syria, knocking over Zam Zam Cola stores in Iran, or making sleazy video tapes in Pakistan with you-know-who.
If you closely analyze the results of the exit polls, you will learn two things that the experts have missed: 1) It could be the economy, Stupid, and 2) Nader beat Bush in the "moral values" department, even though Nader voters don't necessarily scramble into church every week, cringe at notion of gay marriage, or preach about the evils of pot smoking.
I say it "could be" the economy because I am toppling all confidence in exit polls while simultaneously using their data to make this point. A bit schizophrenic, but I never argued I was fair or balanced.
Both the CNN and CBS exit polls found that those who said their financial situation was worse than four years ago tended to choose Kerry (79% in CNN), while those with a perception of an improved situation largely cast their votes for Bush (80% in CNN). Those who felt their finances were the same tended to pick Nader (the bulk of voters in CNN and 60% in CBS). This data is much more convincing than anything related to moral values.
On the controversial topic of values, the CBS News exit poll—the only one to tally the statistical responses of Nader voters--asked, "Which ONE issue mattered most in deciding how you voted for president?"
The result? For the "moral values" respondents, 8% were Kerry voters, 35% were Bush voters and a full 57% were Nader voters. Since Nader voters are not disproportionately social conservatives—both according to the same survey and common sense--the theory about the Reign of Middle American Values is flawed.
Millions of Blue subjects are not being pushed into the two oceans by their relativism; they simply live in their own kingdoms, ruled by their own belief systems. Nader voters probably place importance on things like protecting the environment, curtailing the gap between the rich and poor, and not waging war unilaterally in the Middle East. Although some may call these trivial issues as compared with protecting heterosexual marriage, they are indisputably values, too.
So the next time someone asks you, "What's black and white and Red all over?" Don't answer, "America" or "a newspaper."
Tell them, "A flawed exit poll." It is not really Red all over. Certain people just want you to think it is.
Report this post as:
LATEST COMMENTS ABOUT THIS ARTICLE
Listed below are the 10 latest comments of 2 posted about this article.
These comments are anonymously submitted by the website visitors.
|
|
|
Local News
Atenco PRESENTE!! en California
N22 7:50PM
Thirteen new photos from inside occupied Carter-Huggins Hall (UCLA/Campbell Hall)
N22 3:43PM
A few pictures from inside occupied Campbell-Huggins Hall
N22 1:39PM
Report Back From Inside the Occupation of Campbell Hall, UCLA
N21 3:29PM
Dedication of Transgender Memorial Ends Years of Struggle
N21 2:48PM
PFP Gubernatorial Candidate Alexander Condemns UC Tuition Hikes
N21 5:56AM
UC Strike - UCLA Nov.19th
N21 3:34AM
Anti-war protests expected next week
N20 4:16PM
Campbell Hall de-occupied last night at 6pm
N20 12:21PM
UC Police break up UCLA protest
N20 12:18PM
Students and Workers Resist Privatization at UCLA Regents Meeting
N20 10:47AM
VIDEO: Students Pepper Sprayed at UCLA protest
N20 8:09AM
UC Students Fight Tuition Hike, Occupy Campus
N19 1:58PM
STOP STUPAK Rally
N19 12:56PM
Eye-witness report back of UCLA protests
N19 10:43AM
Students occupy Campbell Hall at UCLA
N19 3:07AM
SIgnage from UCLA Protest
N18 10:09PM
MP3 AUDIO – Interview with UCLA Student on Protesting the Regents
N18 9:42PM
KPFK's LSB meeting to attend and be part of the vocal community too
N18 12:48PM
BREAKING: Protests on UCLA Campus at Regent Meeting, Reports of arrests
N18 10:31AM
LA Eastside: Street Food Vendor Situation
N18 9:56AM
Transgender Memorial Dedication - Nov. 20
N18 9:37AM
Southern California: First Cop on Trial for Murder in History of State Is Headed Your Way
N18 8:48AM
The war on public-sector unions
N17 5:02PM
Horowitz's hate speech at USC
N17 4:30PM
UCLA CRISIS FEST: Protest for education
N17 6:14AM
Checkpoints this weekend / Retenes este fin de semana (12-14/Nov)
N12 12:33PM
Campaign Demands NBA Discipline Clippers Owner and Condemn Racist Housing Discrimination
N12 10:54AM
More Local News...
Other/Breaking News
Googlemap of Student Occupations
N23 9:22PM
Health Bill Ignores Industrial Health Harms
N23 9:15PM
Injunction Hearing Set in WBAI Election Suit
N23 7:37PM
The End of Poverty? in theatres and FREE TICKETS
N23 6:29PM
Two Anniversaries: Berlin and Seattle
N23 6:07PM
The Neolbieral Restructuring of California State Government
N23 5:58PM
AF3IRM/GABNet/Mariposa Alliance Statement: 16 DAYS OF RAGE; 365 OF ACTIVISM
N23 5:42PM
Dahr Jamail Celebrates U.S. Military’s “Will to Resist” in Iraq, Afghanistan
N23 5:41PM
Queer Democrats Endorse Saldańa, Take No Position on County Term Limits
N23 5:29PM
Steve Hadley: Council Candidate's Odyssey from Pulpit to Politics
N23 5:08PM
AJLPP CONDEMNS MAGUINDANAO MASSACRE
N23 3:35PM
Solidarity with the UC Student Protests; Education is our right!
N23 1:50PM
Targeting Muslim Charities in America
N23 12:58PM
CUBANUESTRA. LA KAKISTOCRACIA DE FERNANDO LUGO
N23 10:53AM
Conscious Forces Will Bring Us Certain Victory
N23 10:52AM
CALIFORNIA STUDENTS FIGHT BACK
N23 9:31AM
The whitewash in the British Iraq war inquiry is already in place.
N23 9:09AM
Powerful Weekend Resisting Violence & Oppression
N23 8:58AM
VIDEO and transcript: Nomi Prins' "It Takes a Pillage"
N23 5:59AM
Editorial Cartoon: "2012: They Were Warned"
N23 4:32AM
A day in the Castro
N23 4:16AM
MESSAGE TO NEW YORK TIMES
N23 3:16AM
AYpearl.com lead the Stone jewelry is becoming the fashion
N23 12:50AM
Enough is Enough
N22 2:55PM
DE RODE JAREN - Radikaal links in Nederland 60-70
N22 3:58AM
Peres goes to Cairo
N22 2:57AM
Honduran President Zelaya earns high marks for governance
N21 5:40PM
MIDDLE~CLASS & WORKING POOR AMERICANS TAXES ARE BEING USED TO SUPPORT U.S. BILLIONAIRES
N21 4:48PM
More Breaking News...
|