- js reader version
- email this article
- view hidden posts
- tags and related articles
by Federica Lorca
Tuesday, Oct. 11, 2011 at 9:12 PM
--where the illusion meets the road
img-20111009-00033sm.jpg8s8owl.jpg, image/jpeg, 400x300
What happens when a bunch of mostly white 20-somethings and a union dude hook up in movietown to get solid with a New York protest? You get OccupyLA.
This is an occupation by permission. Really. A couple hundred people camped out on the lawn of Los Angeles's City Hall after they got the permission of the Los Angeles police. It took the union dude about 24 hours to do it. In the better areas of LA, this counts as occupying something. In the rest of town, you actually have to claim some space in the name of the people and defy LAPD. But not for us. This is a LaLa Land occupation: an illusion wrapped up in a metaphor. A light image where something material and real is supposed to be.
No, not that LAPD. Not the guys who swarmed MacArthur Park a few years ago on May Day in full SWAT gear (we know SWAT, it started here) to drive out the picnicking families. They knocked over some journalists on their way to shoot beanbags at the kids. Not the same LAPD that routinely confiscates cars from people who don't have documentation in a towing fees/overtime scam that the victims have no power to defy. Not the LAPD that beat Rodney King and got away with it. This movie-version LAPD gave the LA occupiers permission to pitch our tents on the lawn.
Of course, the whole Occupy thing across the country is a metaphor that only sometimes touches reality, like in New York on the Brooklyn Bridge or now, as I write this, in Boston. Nowhere in the U.S. is this real like in, say, Tunisia or Bahrain. But the whole, entire message, the demands the media are demanding, are in the title: Occupy. We will take the discursive space back. Make this whole, screwed up system about natural people, not the Supreme Court created Frankenstein monster super people called corporations. Corporations eat people for lunch. Corporations also eat justice, and education, and futures—people's futures, not the Wall Street kind—for snacks.
But in L.A., the metaphor reaches a whole other level of disconnect. How this came to be is as mysterious as the job of an assistant director. From the earliest clusters of a couple hundred people imitating New York's General Assembly in the nighttime glow of Pershing Square, there was never an unscripted choice. People wanted to sleep in the Square. People wanted to occupy the Los Angeles Financial District (yes, we have one). But the self-determined leaders of this leaderless movement (the people who set the agenda before the others arrived and had the answers as soon as the questions were asked) brushed off alternatives: for reasons that were never made clear, it had to be City Hall.
It bothered a few people that City Hall is, well, not really the focus of the Occupy movement. It bothered a few more people that City Hall is right across the street from LAPD headquarters. Massive reflecting windows in Parker Center frame a full-sized image of City Hall, and our local cops can lob tear gas on the campers without leaving home. Los Angeles City Hall is, no doubt, one of the most secure buildings in the world. Very few people at OccupyLA seem much concerned with privacy, though. They make us move our gear from one side of City Hall to another every few day. And LAPD can turn on the sprinkler system whenever they want a giggle.
LA City Hall is occupied by people who've been screwed by the system. For the most part we are young adults, under thirty, over twenty. We grew up with Reagan's philosophy of trickle, the twentieth-century permutation of noblesse oblige, the delusion that the wealthy will take care of the rest of us. We're waiting for our trickle down jobs while they were shipped overseas. Once we get those, we'll trickle back into houses. We got our trickling education and discovered we can't compete. We depended on the legal system for a trickle of justice and got state-sanctioned executions of untried citizens and innocents. We trusted our money to trickle down bailouts that stalled with bankers' bonuses. We're holding our breath for a trickle health care from the insurance companies. We wage trickling wars for no apparent reason, in what we've been promised is a world of endless, trickling wars. If we wait(/survive) long enough somebody will figure out how to save a trickle of a habitable environment.
So here on the set in LA, we are camped on the City Hall lawn, and the scriptwriters tell us that if we're nice to the police, they'll be nice to us. When this started, we knew there would be affinity groups and splinter groups, variations on the theme, but we are, well, the 99%. What we weren't told was that a people's Committee on Police Brutality would be summarily shut down in the GA and their personal contact information spread around on a flyer and on the web. Nobody mentioned that the guy who spoke out against the police would be run off. He isn't part of the 1%, but for sure he's not part of the 99%, as we're told to call ourselves. He's not anywhere, really, not anyone.
Race isn't in our script either. Not Black or Brown or Native American or white or Asian. We're the 99%. Not the bottom 40% or the middle 55% or the nearly-the-1% remainder. You had a bad experience with the cops, or your family did, or your school did, or your neighborhood did? Shhh... If we're not nice to the police...
We are nonviolent. There's talk about signing some sort of nonviolent pledge (with the suggestion it would please the police). Nonviolence here means avoiding violence at all costs, to challenge nothing, to concede to everything. No confrontation, we will run from physical force with all our soul force. Expect no daisies in gun barrels here. No, there's no plan if the cops swarm. That wouldn't be nice. A plan for bail? Not cool. Definitely not. Civil disobedience training? So not happening here.
Our Livestream chat is censored, people are banned, if the mod decides we aren't “nice” enough. The star of this streaming self-referential fantasy within our pomo illusion is some guy who'll happily tell you what a wonderful communicator he is, a skill he learned in the Marines or the Eagle Scouts, one or the other.
Being pleasant is a rule for the high point of our day, the General Assembly, with a rotation of facilitators. Not leaders, just, well, the people who decide what will be decided. They say they're the ones who've been around from the beginning, or the ones who spent the most nights, or the ones who do things. But it doesn't matter much: if you're not a committee chair, you can talk in the last fifteen minutes before the cops make us move the tents onto the sidewalk. The rest of the time we're twinkling to decisions that are reported out of committees, or playing follow the leader and making pyramids over our heads when it's time to shut someone down. Wanna stop the whole operation? Bring half a dozen friends and cross your arms in front of your face to block whatever's being decided. If they can't convince you, you win. Honest.
We have an absolute rule against drugs and alcohol. Our self-appointed security team, more concerned with protecting us from each other than from any outside threat, will bust you. You can trust security to stop you from getting too loud during a march, too.
We're told all this is real democracy, and if you're sitting comfortably watching the screen, it looks for all the world like it is. The grand illusion is nearly perfect.
But if you look close enough, its the props that don't quite work. How did the finance committee get a business checking account? How are they handing out not just blankets, but tents to everyone who asks? Where did the matching notebooks in the media tent come from, or the media tent, or the fully equipped medical tent? How, in just a week, is this occupation feeding everyone, not just occupiers, but everyone who comes by? One answer snuck out today: LAPD is sending in supplies, including food and sunscreen to protect the Occupiers from the California sun. Some people are refusing to eat the food. No lie.
The storyline is that this is a horizontal structure, without leaders, left to us the people to control. To create the story, we are controlled, our set, who our characters are, what we do and what we say. We are free agents only within the script. We have busted out of lives determined by corporations, of corporations, and for corporations, and escaped into a made-for-TV illusion of freedom. Such is the start of the new world, the post-corporate people's democracy. How did that happen?
Ask Mayor Bloomberg in New York, who just decided the OccupyWallStreet protesters could camp in the park until they get tired and go home.
Report this post as:
LATEST COMMENTS ABOUT THIS ARTICLE
Listed below are the 10 latest comments of 10 posted about this article.
These comments are anonymously submitted by the website visitors.
|Why is this hidden?
||Wednesday, Oct. 12, 2011 at 9:21 PM
|Hidden by mistake
||Thursday, Oct. 13, 2011 at 7:29 AM
||one or the other
||Thursday, Oct. 13, 2011 at 7:40 AM
|IMC should have a freedom of speech policy on OLA
||Friday, Oct. 14, 2011 at 5:23 AM
|oct 15 - go
||Saturday, Oct. 15, 2011 at 7:32 PM
||Saturday, Oct. 22, 2011 at 2:34 PM
|Half this article is missing
||Monday, Oct. 24, 2011 at 7:06 AM
|Sorry about that
||Sunday, Oct. 30, 2011 at 8:21 PM
||Sunday, Oct. 30, 2011 at 8:23 PM
Foreclosure Victims Occupy Senate Stump Speech of Kamala Harris
LA Nakba Anniversary protest at the Israel Consulate
Long Beach Police Execute Unarmed Teen Hector Morejon on Suspicion Of Trespassing
Eagle-Con 2015 at Cal State L.A.
Brendon Glenn Dies and Venice S/Weeps
JOIN CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT AGAINST RONALD L. HAVNER JR's PREDATORY BUSINESS, PUBLIC STORAGE
Councilmember Bonin Calls People of Venice Outraged by Police Murder “Outside Agitators"
May Day March, LA 2015
LA Progressive: Ref Rodriguez—What the PUC Is Going on Here?
L.A. Stands in Solidarity with Australian Aborigines
KPFK'S rep to Pacific Bd Whitleblower -being kicked out ...plse sign petiton here
Families Protest Abusive Foreclosure Practices of Wells Fargo Bank
How is CCSA's Ref Rodriguez hiding his billionaire and ideologue contributors?
What drives charter profiteer Ref Rodriguez?
Los Angeles Artist Threatens 40 Million Dollar Law Suit for Public Storage Illegal Auction
RAC-LA Community Center Grand Opening
KPFK and Pacifica- woes unrelenting...
RAC-LA Community Center Badly Needs Your Support
More Local News...
Palestinian Bid To Expel Israel from FIFA Dropped
Ukraine: Gangster State
72 Links: McDonald's & Unionbusting, Animal Agony, Human Disease, Environmental Devastatio
CBS Shills For War, Violence, Toxic Drugs, Animal Flesh, Lower Broadcast Standards
Israel's War on Palestinian Fishermen, Farmers and Children
Scoundrel Media FIFA Bashing
The Shortwave Report 05/29/15 Listen Globally!
Ukraine Threatens Total Blockade on Donbass
The lowest common denominator rules the uSA
Racist Wendy Sherman Leaving State Department
Western Long Knives Out for FIFA's Sepp Blatter?
Washington Wages War on International Soccer
ATTO INQUISIZIONE REGNANS IN EXCELSIS
Four Winds of March Against Monsanto Los Angeles Take The Streets of Hollywood
Reinvented War Criminal Tony Blair Resigns As Middle East Envoy
Obama Memorial Day Big Lies
World Be Advised
19 Ways the USDA Kills People, Animals, Birds, And/Or Trees
Bernie Sanders: Populist or Opportunist?
G7 Finance Ministers Focus on Growth in Face of High Debt
Israel Wants 50% Increase in US Provided Military Aid
Abduction, Torture and Summary Killings of Palestinians by Hamas
Risks and Opportunities for Consumer Welfare, 56 pp
Mission Creep in Syria
Netanyahu's Sham Settlement Bloc Boundaries Proposal
China's Military Strategy
The Battle for Jobs
More Breaking News...