Dear Editor:

I thought you might be interested in publishing the following piece. I could modify it a bit, if necessary.

Thank you, and I hope to hear from you soon.

Sincerely,

Johnny Sarraf
Dept. of English & Comparative Literature
American University in Cairo
113 Sharia Kasr El Aini
P.O. Box 2511
11511 Cairo, Egypt


Pickin’ a Fight with Christmas

Not since American children’s story writer Dr. Seuss’s “How the Grinch Stole Christmas,” in which the antagonist initially denied the holiday from the unsuspecting citizens of Whooville, has something quite like this happened, at least in my experience.

Exactly a week before Christmas, I received a call from one of my friends from the choir of which I’m a part. The reason for the call was that all the Christmas carols concerts at the three hotels where we were set to sing beginning on the very next night were cancelled, and ours wasn’t the only choir to be affected. In an unprecedented move, the Egyptian government had ordered all Christmas carols concerts by all choirs at all hotels in Cairo to be cancelled due officially to security concerns.

There is nothing confirmed besides the cancellation itself, and it is doubtful that there will be any official confirmation in Cairo, but one thing heard was that some Muslim extremists had threatened the use of violence if the Christmas carols at hotels would be allowed to go on as planned.

Whatever the reason, the news came as a shock to all of us involved and to relatives and friends, on the eve of our Friday night performance at the Semiramis Hotel in the downtown area. The initial disbelief that something like this could happen, all at the last minute, and the numbness felt have since given way to anger complemented by frustration, the latter resulting from an inability to change the situation and to celebrate publicly the event as usual.

What is always interesting to me is the reaction to threats like these. Does the government, for instance, in canceling the events, not end up achieving the fundamentalists’ main goal? By denying people the tradition of hearing Christmas songs openly, the government is preventing a significant part of the community from celebrating publicly what it believes and what is important to it. The concerts have also always been special in that they have brought many people together comfortably, among them Christians and Muslims, many of them singing along with the choir at the shows. Are stopping such things not among the aims of extremists?

To its credit, the Egyptian government has, in recent years, made efforts to bridge the gap and ease some tensions that have existed between Egyptians who practice different religions. Recognizing officially the Orthodox Christmas recently is one such gesture. The most recent move, however, even if done in the name of security, is a sharp step in the wrong direction. As a considerable part of the community here has been denied open celebration of a religious holiday, what would be really nice to express now is how many of us feel about it, even if it would not be nice for the Egyptian government to hear.

What were still heard in Cairo were Christmas carols, as there was a last minute arrangement by our choir’s director to present a concert in the church itself, something not done before by the choir. Arranged just the day before, the concert resulted in a church packed with people who had come together in an inspiring act of solidarity. As the Grinch’s efforts to steal Christmas had failed because he did not recognize that the holiday goes much deeper than Christmas gifts and decorations, the recent attempt to disrupt Christmas in Cairo was foiled because of the resilience of the community and the spirit of Christmas.

Those nasty Egyptian infidels. On the other hand, it is not too difficult to imagine what would have happened if Muslim groups had scheduled three mass events at New York hotels about a week after 9/11/01. You don't suppose they would have been cancelled because of "security concerns," do you?Even if the celebrants were US citizens? Nah, not a chance.
Then there is the little matter of the total curfew which was placed on Palestinians on the West Bank during the first US-Iraq war. People couldn't even leave their homes. Of course, this is nothing compared to cancelling the singing of Christmas carols.
Hypocrisy ever thrives.

Pop quiz, Skippy:

1 .Christians or Muslims killed 3,000 people on 9/11.

2. Christians or Muslims killed 300 people in a Bali nightclub.

3. Christians or Muslims routinely amputate limbs for minor infractions of the law.

3. Christians or Muslims treat women as property, and mutilate their genitals.

4. Christians or Muslims stone victims of rape.

5. Christians or Muslims indoctrinate their children that their religion's most noble form of death is killing unbelievers by suicide bombs.

Yes, hypocrisy ever thrives. Yours.

You can keep your moral relativism and defense of the indefensible. Both are repugnant

nonanarchist.

*** This comment was posted from an IP associated with a disruptive poster. The MD5 hash of their IP is dcbfebfbdce. This value is the same even if the user uses another name. Only posters deemed disruptive by the editorial collective will have this text appended to their posts. We apologize for any erroneous misidentifications.

This sounds like they have their own Office of Homeland Security. Egypt is a progressive country, but that doesn't mean that they won't curtail civil rights in the name of the personal safety of those silenced. "It's for their own good."

I'm sure they learned a bit of rhetoric from America. "We're locking up the Japanese (or Arabs, or Mexicans) in this area for their own protection. There are too many people who hate them." Sure. I guess the government also dislikes them just a little too. Just enough to force them to live behind walls or barb wire.

The problem isn't individual incidents of popular violence against the state. The problem is state violence against the people. A bomb might kill a dozen people, but a law can injure millions, each just a little, over and over, and a week, month, or year later, someone dies from a police bullet that should not have found another victim.

PS - Fresca, you're a racist.

I met an Egyptian couple once when I visited Bahrain. They were Christian, and left their homeland due to the persecution they received. There was nothing "official", if you will, but plenty of behind-the-scenes persecution. Job promotions late or nonexistent to Christians; that sort of thing.

I dunno if the caroling cancellations were due to security concerns or not. It wouldn't surprise me if some Muslim extremist had threatened violence.

"The problem is state violence against the people. A bomb might kill a dozen people, but a law can injure millions..."

Indeed. Read the Palestinian Authority Charter sometime.

nonanarchist

*** This comment was posted from an IP associated with a disruptive poster. The MD5 hash of their IP is dcbfebfbdce. This value is the same even if the user uses another name. Only posters deemed disruptive by the editorial collective will have this text appended to their posts. We apologize for any erroneous misidentifications.