|
How British Charity Was Silenced On Iraq
by Silence of the Lambs
Friday, Nov. 28, 2003 at 3:06 AM
One of Britain's most high-profile charities was ordered to end criticism of military action in Iraq by its powerful US wing to avoid jeopardising financial support from Washington and corporate donors, a Guardian investigation has discovered.
Internal emails reveal how Save the Children UK came under enormous pressure after it accused coalition forces of breaching the Geneva convention by blocking humanitarian aid.
How British Charity Was Silenced On Iraq By Kevin Maguire The Guardian - UK 11-28-3
One of Britain's most high-profile charities was ordered to end criticism of military action in Iraq by its powerful US wing to avoid jeopardising financial support from Washington and corporate donors, a Guardian investigation has discovered. Internal emails reveal how Save the Children UK came under enormous pressure after it accused coalition forces of breaching the Geneva convention by blocking humanitarian aid. Senior figures at Save the Children US, based in Westport, Connecticut, demanded the withdrawal of the criticism and an effective veto on any future statements blaming the invasion for the plight of Iraqi civilians suffering malnourishment and shortages of medical supplies. Uncovered documents expose tensions within an alliance that describes itself as "the world's largest independent global organisation for children" but which is heavily reliant on governments and big business for cash. Save the Children UK, which had an income of £122m in 2002-03, boasts the Queen as patron and Princess Anne as president, plus a phalanx of the great and the good lending their titles and time. The row over Iraq erupted in April when the London statement said coalition forces had gone back on an earlier agreement to allow a relief plane, packed with emergency food and medical supplies for 40,000 people, to land in northern Iraq. Rob MacGillivray, the UK wing's emergency programme manager, released a statement which stated that the "lack of cooperation from the coalition forces is a breach of the Geneva conventions and its protocols, but more importantly the time now being wasted is costing children their lives". Within hours of the statement appearing, the US wing was demanding its withdrawal. Emails sent to staff in Britain by Dianne Sherman, associate vice-president for public affairs and communications in Connecticut, headed "Save/UK criticises US military", expressed dismay and censured the UK operation. Ms Sherman said the Americans were "really astonished at today's release, which went out without our prior knowledge, that attacks the US military". Her email went on: "This is undermining all the great work we've done, much of it in collaboration with you. We'll have to see the consequences of how this plays out - including affecting our future funding from the government." A number of less controversial "joint messages" were proposed by Ms Sherman, none of which criticised any aspect of the invasion or occupation. She instead wanted the UK and US groups to point out that humanitarian organisations were still not permitted access to most of Iraq, that delays harmed children and, on a positive note, that relief work was under way in Umm Qasr, Masul and northern Iraq. "Safe, secure conditions must be created immediately to allow humanitarians to bring in essential supplies and expertise to the people of Iraq," was her alternative version. Accounts published by Save the Children US highlight its vulnerability to political pressure from a Republican White House with "government grants and contracts" generating some 60%, nearly £71m, of its £119m operating support and revenue. The proportion is also high in the UK, where £60.1m - 49% - of the organisation's income is "grants and gifts in kind from institutional donors", including the government. Ms Sherman copied her broadside to US executives including Ann van Dusen, the executive vice-president, Rudy von Bernuth, vice-president and managing director of its children in emergencies section, and Andrea Williamson-Hughes, corporate secretary. When she discovered the London statement had been posted on the UK organisation's website, Ms Sherman also demanded the deletion of US press officer Nicole Amoroso's name as a contact, adding in a second email: "I would also strongly suggest that the press release be removed until we have agreed upon language of the release." A well-placed source in the UK operation said "all hell let loose" over the US intervention, with telephone calls "flying across the Atlantic" and a series of high-level meetings called to discuss the crisis. The removal of the US press officer's name was agreed to placate Connecticut but the source confirmed the Americans were also assured they would be sent all future UK statements on Iraq before they were issued. According to the source, the UK wing toned down later statements to avoid offending the US side of the operation. A statement issued in London on April 25, for example, was cleared in advance with the US, the source said. Headed "The war is not over for the children of Iraq", it made no mention let alone criticism of coalition forces. The looting of some hospitals was highlighted but not the widespread criticism at the time that troops were standing by and doing nothing. Save the Children US concentrates on fundraising and is said by London insiders to be anxious to curb campaigning by the UK arm. Ms Sherman was unavailable for comment until next week, her office said. But in a statement to the Guardian, Save the Children UK said it had not retracted the release at the heart of the row but had removed the name of Ms Amoroso, saying it had been an error not to consult her. Subsequent statements, it added, reflected the fact that the situation "had moved on" as medical supplies had landed in Jordan to be moved to Baghdad. "We do not agree news releases issued in Save the Children UK's name with Save the Children US or any other member of the International Save the Children Alliance," the London statement said. "Wherever possible we do share Save the Children UK news releases before they are issued with other alliance members working in the same area. If any changes are suggested by other alliance members to Save the Children releases, they are made or not at our discretion." The tensions over potential donor influence are not limited to the Iraq crisis. Other internal emails and documents disclose how Save the Children UK was nervous about the reaction of a major donor company, Serco, which makes huge profits from outsourcing, when the charity prepared to criticise the impact of privatisation on children. A number of staff were aghast in the summer of 2002 when a chapter critical of private finance initiatives, written for a report published ahead of the Johannesburg sustainable development summit, was deleted by senior figures in the charity just before it was printed. There is nothing in the documents to suggest that Serco exerted any pressure, but according to the emails, the charity's staff were anxious not to upset it. One email copied widely in the organisation admitted "underlying tensions" existed between the corporate fundraising unit and campaigners arguing that PFIs in basic services did not benefit children. Another warned that criticism of PFIs by the charity was "naturally making some of our corporate sponsors edgy", and the director general, Mike Aaronson, wanted a full briefing ahead of a meeting with a big private donor. As the internal debate raged, fundraiser Helen Barnes warned she was in a "tricky position" with Serco, which ran hospitals, prisons and schools for the government. Although about to cease being a corporate member, the firm, she said, "is still keen to support us" as she argued against portraying it as a company operating solely for profit. "Serco takes its social responsibilities very seriously and invests in the communities in which it operates," Ms Barnes said. Serco, which is heavily involved in the defence sector, raised a total of £626,500 for the charity, as well as naming its yacht Save the Children in the BT Global Challenge race three years ago. The charity's statement yesterday said: "At no point [in] the relationship did Serco attempt to influence Save the Children UK policy on any issue." It continued: "We were able to edit most of the report to meet the required standard but one chapter required further work before it could be approved for publication. Because time was short we decided to drop this chapter to allow the rest of the report to be published in time for the conference." Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2003 http://www.guardian.co.uk/Iraq/Story/0,2763,1095116,00.html
|
|
Local News
ALEX SÁNCHEZ DENIED BAIL!
J30 10:02PM
Décimo día del ayuno de Judith / Day 10 of Judith's hunger strike
J30 2:36AM
Demonstration at the Honduran consulate/Manifestación en el consulado hondureño
J30 2:14AM
CONDEMNATION OF HONDURAS COUP BY PEACE AND FREEDOM PARTY CHAIR
J30 1:33AM
Statement from 17 year old arrested and deported on public RTA bus in Rubidoux
J30 12:54AM
COMMUNITY MEETS TO SHOW SUPPORT FOR ALEX SÁNCHEZ
J29 7:45AM
Union Del Barrio In Support of Alex Sanchez & Nativo Lopez
J28 11:49AM
Jose Compean to appear in Temecula parade
J27 3:12PM
ICE and Border Patrol raids continue
J27 10:14AM
EPCC letter of Solidarity with Alex Sanchez and Homies Unidos
J26 6:45PM
BORDER PATROL REAKS HAVOC IN INLAND EMPIRE
J26 6:13PM
Border Patrol hits day labor corner in Rancho Cucamonga Cae la migra en Rancho Cucamonga
J26 11:42AM
IWW Forum This Sunday!
J25 10:36PM
CISPES letter of solidarity with Alex Sanchez and Homies Unidos
J25 7:57PM
Homies Unidos Statement on Arrest of Executive Director Alex Sanchez
J25 7:54PM
Homies Unidos activist Alex Sanchez arrested
J25 7:50PM
PETA vs. Ringling
J25 3:00PM
UCSB terminates case against Professor
J25 2:49PM
Day 28 of LAUSD Protest:LAUSD Board Votes 5 to 2 for School Cuts - Photo Essay Pt. 2
J24 10:11PM
Day 28 of LAUSD Protest:LAUSD Board Votes 5 to 2 for School Cuts
J24 8:26PM
SAME Meeting Challenges Queer Establishment, Democratic Party
J24 8:14PM
Pomona Police Vs U.S. Marine Vet 9/11 Truther, Friday 6/26/09 9AM
J24 2:36PM
Judith de las danzas aztecas Cuauhtemoc se puso en huelga de hambre
J24 2:25AM
ICE raid nets 12 day laborers in Ontario / Redada de 12 jornaleros en Ontario
J23 11:20AM
RaisetheFist EMERGENCY RESPONSE NETWORK
J23 6:05AM
Los Angeles Hunger Striking Teachers Stop Action.
J21 8:38PM
Los Angeles Teacher Marco Flores Outlines Hungry For Educations Continuing Campaign
J21 7:15PM
Santee Students Walk Out and March in Support of Hunger Strikers Part 3
J21 6:04PM
More Local News...
Other/Breaking News
The LemonFast & Fresh Organic Foods
J05 12:07PM
Zelaya Doesn't Blink: Two Airplanes Heading South Today
J05 10:04AM
Zelaya Doesn't Blink: Two Airplanes Heading South Today
J05 9:52AM
BTL:Advocates for Single-Payer Fight to be Heard in U.S. Healthcare Debate
J05 9:45AM
Torrico says "No more sequels, Arnold," as the Terminator holds a gun to Califor
J05 1:11AM
Zhibin Gu: behind China's corruption: philosophy, religion, politics, law
J04 10:51PM
JAPAN OFFICIALLY RELEASES CAR THAT RUNS ONLY ON WATER
J04 7:36PM
People's Assembly for Popular Education & Liberation: Summer School Program Update
J04 7:31PM
OC Education Not Incarceration Community Forum
J04 5:48PM
JULY FALSE FLAG New York Nuke?
J04 12:20PM
On Krauthammer, Obama and even Bush
J04 10:40AM
BTL:Ship Carrying Humanitarian Aid for Gaza Seized by Israel
J04 9:57AM
9/11: Scientific Evidence Flight 77 Did Not Strike The Pentagon
J04 8:50AM
This is the story of creation.
J04 8:08AM
BTL:Though Suppressed, Iran Election Protesters Not Defeated
J03 10:29PM
JFAV and Critics Laud Withdrawal of SF Presidio Art Museum Proposal
J03 6:07PM
Marriages and Funerals in Afghanistan and Pakistan
J03 1:41PM
"The War is a Breeding Program for Terorists"
J03 11:06AM
Reviewing Marjorie Cohn and Kathleen Gilberd's "Rules of Disengagement"
J03 10:52AM
VIDEO: US sent Taliban into Iraq
J03 5:51AM
Support revolutionary radio - july 8th
J02 9:31PM
South Side Alderman Decides Not To Pursue Eminent Domain
J02 8:31PM
Bush's 4th of July Visit to Oklahoma
J02 6:58PM
The Shortwave Report 07/03 Listen Globally!
J02 5:21PM
The Zeitgeist Movement
J02 5:02PM
Holocaust-denial events in SoCal, July 25 & 26
J02 3:42PM
The Significance of Washington's Coup Attempt in Honduras
J02 10:33AM
Capitalism as Religion
J02 6:04AM
More Breaking News...
| |