|
|
printable version
- email this article
- view hidden posts
CIA Got Uranium Reference Cut in Oct. Why Bush Cited It In Jan. Is Unclear
by C/O Diogenes
Saturday, Jul. 12, 2003 at 9:53 PM
CIA Director George J. Tenet successfully intervened with White House officials to have a reference to Iraq seeking uranium from Niger removed from a presidential speech last October, three months before a less specific reference to the same intelligence appeared in the State of the Union address, according to senior administration officials.
washingtonpost.com
CIA Got Uranium Reference Cut in Oct. Why Bush Cited It In Jan. Is Unclear
By Walter Pincus and Mike Allen Washington Post Staff Writers Sunday, July 13, 2003; Page A01
CIA Director George J. Tenet successfully intervened with White House officials to have a reference to Iraq seeking uranium from Niger removed from a presidential speech last October, three months before a less specific reference to the same intelligence appeared in the State of the Union address, according to senior administration officials.
Tenet argued personally to White House officials, including deputy national security adviser Stephen Hadley, that the allegation should not be used because it came from only a single source, according to one senior official. Another senior official with knowledge of the intelligence said the CIA had doubts about the accuracy of the documents underlying the allegation, which months later turned out to be forged.
The new disclosure suggests how eager the White House was in January to make Iraq's nuclear program a part of its case against Saddam Hussein even in the face of earlier objections by its own CIA director. It also appears to raise questions about the administration's explanation of how the faulty allegations were included in the State of the Union speech.
It is unclear why Tenet failed to intervene in January to prevent the questionable intelligence from appearing in the president's address to Congress when Tenet had intervened three months earlier in a much less symbolic speech. That failure may underlie his action Friday in taking responsibility for not stepping in again to question the reference. "I am responsible for the approval process in my agency," he said in Friday's statement.
As Bush left Africa yesterday to return to Washington from a five-day trip overshadowed by the intelligence blunder, he was asked whether he considered the matter over. "I do," he replied. White House press secretary Ari Fleischer told reporters yesterday that "the president has moved on. And I think, frankly, much of the country has moved on, as well."
But it is clear from the new disclosure about Tenet's intervention last October that the controversy continues to boil, and as new facts emerge a different picture is being presented than the administration has given to date.
Details about the alleged attempt by Iraq to buy as much as 500 tons of uranium oxide were contained in a national intelligence estimate (NIE) that was concluded in late September 2002. It was that same reference that the White House wanted to use in Bush's Oct. 7 speech that Tenet blocked, the sources said. That same intelligence report was the basis for the 16-word sentence about Iraq attempting to buy uranium in Africa that was contained in the January State of the Union address that has drawn recent attention.
Administration sources said White House officials, particularly those in the office of Vice President Cheney, insisted on including Hussein's quest for a nuclear weapon as a prominent part of their public case for war in Iraq. Cheney had made the potential threat of Hussein having a nuclear weapon a central theme of his August 2002 speeches that began the public buildup toward war with Baghdad.
In the Oct. 7 Cincinnati speech, the president for the first time outlined in detail the threat Hussein posed to the United States on the eve of a congressional vote authorizing war. Bush talked in part about "evidence" indicating that Iraq was reconstituting its nuclear weapons program. The president listed Hussein's "numerous meetings with Iraqi nuclear scientists," satellite photographs showing former nuclear facilities were being rebuilt, and Iraq's attempts to purchase high-strength aluminum tubes for use in enriching uranium for nuclear weapons.
There was, however, no mention of Niger or even attempts to purchase uranium from other African countries, which was contained in the NIE and also included in a British intelligence dossier that had been published a month earlier.
By January, when conversations took place with CIA personnel over what could be in the president's State of the Union speech, White House officials again sought to use the Niger reference since it still was in the NIE.
"We followed the NIE and hoped there was more intelligence to support it," a senior administration official said yesterday. When told there was nothing new, White House officials backed off, and as a result "seeking uranium from Niger was never in drafts," he said.
Tenet raised no personal objection to the ultimate inclusion of the sentence, attributed to Britain, about Iraqi attempts to buy uranium in Africa. His statement on Friday said he should have. "These 16 words should never have been included in the text written for the president," the CIA director said.
Bush said in Abuja, Nigeria, yesterday that he continues to have faith in Tenet. "I do, absolutely," he said. "I've got confidence in George Tenet; I've got confidence in the men and women who work at the CIA."
There is still much that remains unclear about who specifically wanted the information inserted in the State of the Union speech, or why repeated concerns about the allegations were ignored.
"The information was available within the system that should have caught this kind of big mistake," a former Bush administration official said. "The question is how the management of the system, and the process that supported it, allowed this kind of misinformation to be used and embarrass the president."
Senior Bush aides said they do not believe they have a communication problem within the White House that prevented them from acting on any of the misgivings about the information that were being expressed at lower levels of the government.
"I'm sure there will have to be some retracing of steps, and that's what's happening," White House communications director Dan Bartlett said. "The mechanical process, we think is fine. Will more people now give more, tighter scrutiny going forward? Of course."
A senior administration official said Bush's chief speechwriter, Michael J. Gerson, does not remember who wrote the line that has wound up causing the White House so much grief.
Officials said three speechwriters were at the core of the State of the Union team, and that they worked from evidence against Iraq provided by the National Security Council. NSC officials dealt with the CIA both in gathering material for the speech and later in vetting the drafts.
Officials involved in preparing the speech said there was much more internal debate over the next line of the speech, when Bush said in reference to Hussein, "Our intelligence sources tell us that he has attempted to purchase high-strength aluminum tubes suitable for nuclear weapons production."
Secretary of State Colin L. Powell, in his Feb. 5 presentation to the United Nations, noted a disagreement about Iraq's intentions for the tubes, which can be used in centrifuges to enrich uranium. The U.N.'s International Atomic Energy Agency had raised those questions two weeks before the State of the Union address, saying Hussein claimed nonnuclear intentions for the tubes. In March, the IAEA said it found Hussein's claim credible, and could all but rule out the use of the tubes in a nuclear program.
Staff writer Dana Milbank contributed to this report from Nigeria.
© 2003 The Washington Post Company
Report this post as:
LATEST COMMENTS ABOUT THIS ARTICLE
Listed below are the 10 latest comments of 1 posted about this article.
These comments are anonymously submitted by the website visitors.
| TITLE |
AUTHOR |
DATE |
| Let me see... |
Diogenes |
Saturday, Jul. 12, 2003 at 9:57 PM |
|
|
|
Local News
Queremos justicia: Pueblo rechazó presencia del alguacil Arpaio en Condado de Orange
N06 9:13AM
Sit-in at Chancellor Yang's office to protest closure of Ventura Campus
N05 10:49AM
Settlement Puts an End to Controversial Elephant Hill Development in Los Angeles
N05 7:33AM
BREAKING: Wednesday, Nov 4, 7:45pm - Hundreds Marching in Silverlake for right to marry
N04 7:46PM
Calling Long Beach Area Anarchists!
N04 7:54AM
JFAV ACTION WEEK, NOVEMBER 8-14, 2009
N02 3:47PM
Checkpoints this weeked: Retenes este fin de semana (30-31/oct)
O29 9:51PM
Fred Phelps Brings Road Show of Hate to San Diego; 500 Protest Against Him
O29 7:10PM
Pension fund probe into possible bribery of former LA deputy mayor
O29 6:02PM
Dr. Helen Caldicott Speaks in San Diego
O29 5:50PM
Queer Democrats Endorse Alvarez, Wayne for City Council
O29 5:41PM
Béla Dornon: Queer Photographer Seeks to Document California’s Same-Sex Marriages
O29 5:30PM
Physician and Six Activists Are Arrested At CIGNA's Glendale, CA Offices
O28 8:08PM
Physician and Six Activists Are Arrested At CIGNA's Glendale, CA Offices/ Video
O28 7:35PM
BREAKING: 1pm - 10/28/09 - Healthcare Activists Stage Sit-in at Cigna offices, 7 Arrested
O28 12:55PM
First in state Holistic Mom’s Network chapter celebrates 5th birthday
O27 11:02PM
More footage of the Anti-Nazi protest
O27 1:46AM
Sit-in at CIGNA insurance, 10am Wednesday, 10/28
O26 7:36PM
International Day of Climate Action in Eagle Rock (part 1)
O26 7:09PM
International Day of Climate Action in Eagle Rock part 2
O26 6:30PM
Inland Empire Against Racial Hate (1-13)
O26 1:44PM
Video footage of the Anti-Nazi protest
O26 11:28AM
Immigrants Are Welcome Here. Nazis Are Not. (Photo set 3)
O26 10:47AM
Immigrants Are Welcome Here. Nazis Are Not. (Photo set 2)
O26 10:22AM
Immigrants Are Welcome Here. Nazis Are Not.
O26 10:06AM
Indymedia Los Angeles 10th Anniversary Event!
O26 9:55AM
NAZIS GO HOME! Spit and Swastikas Clash in Riverside
O26 8:40AM
Nazis in Riverside
O25 7:46PM
More Local News...
Other/Breaking News
GLOBAL TURN AROUND!
N07 2:27PM
JFAV/ FIL-AMS ALL SET FOR VETERANS DAY PROTEST MARCH ON NOVEMBER 11 IN LA
N07 12:26PM
NDF -EV URGES PEOPLE TO ACT ON UTILITIES CRISIS
N07 11:58AM
PHILIPPINES; A CAPITALIST CALAMITY
N07 10:25AM
~ BIGDADDYJAZZANDMAYA.COM ~ THE ATTEMPT TO DESTROY ONE LOCAL POORER AMERICAN FAMILY~!
N07 9:13AM
~ BIGDADDYJAZZANDMAYA.COM ~ THE ATTEMPT TO DESTROY ONE LOCAL POORER AMERICAN FAMILY~!
N07 9:05AM
BTL:Former Religious Right Activist Warns Against Incitement to Violence
N07 4:00AM
Nov. 20-22 Mass Mobilization to Close the SOA
N06 1:59PM
Honduran Accord Solidifies Coup E'Etat Rule
N06 1:15PM
Democraticamente. FERNANDO LUGO, CONTINUADA DESHONRA PARA LA INVESTIDURA PRESIDENCIAL
N06 11:42AM
National Resistance Against the Coup d’Etat Announces Boycott of Elections
N06 10:35AM
Don't go
N06 8:59AM
BTL:Civil Disobedience Actions Launched to Stop Mountain Top Removal
N06 5:29AM
Diario Siglo XXI. FERNANDO LUGO, CONTINUADA DESHONRA PARA LA INVESTIDURA PRESIDENCIAL
N06 12:44AM
Rivers Casino Supervisor Physically Assaults Casino Security Officer during Union Campaign
N05 9:05PM
Obama is Absolutely Right to Re-evaluate Afghanistan Strategy
N05 6:49PM
The Shortwave Report 11/06 Listen Globally!
N05 5:02PM
The latest trend in eco-tourism is completely out of this world ... and right around the c
N05 2:18PM
Comments from an Inmate
N05 11:56AM
The High Risk Business of Banks
N05 5:40AM
BTL:Karzai Government Corruption Hobbles Obama Afghan War Strategy
N05 5:11AM
War Criminals and their agent control 344 Members of Congress.
N05 1:29AM
EEUU SOBORNA CON ARMAS A FERNANDO LUGO
N05 12:45AM
Reject Corporate Option for Health Care
N04 7:55PM
Blog en solidaridad con el SME. México
N04 1:58PM
House Resolution Designates Venezuela a State Sponsor of Terrorism
N04 1:08PM
Pirates attack ship in eastern mediterranean
N04 7:23AM
Profits=Investments=Jobs?
N04 5:49AM
More Breaking News...
|