- js reader version
- view hidden posts
- tags and related articles
by Jahna Berry
Thursday, Dec. 07, 2006 at 8:25 AM
At last a judge that knows it is impossible to conspire with yourself!!!!
Judge cites lack of evidence on migrant
Dec. 6, 2006 12:00 AM
A Maricopa County judge dealt a surprise blow to the county attorney's crusade to prosecute immigrants who pay coyotes to smuggle them into Arizona.
Using a rare court procedure, Judge Thomas O'Toole on Tuesday tossed out a jury's guilty verdict and acquitted Aldolfo Guzman-Garcia, an undocumented immigrant who paid 0 to have a coyote bring him to Arizona.
The judge said he did not believe there was sufficient evidence to show that Guzman-Garcia was part of a human-smuggling ring.
The ruling is not precedent setting. Prosecutors say they plan to appeal the case that County Attorney Andrew Thomas recently touted as a key victory in his quest to curb illegal immigration.
Legal experts say the case shows how county judges are struggling to interpret the law that went into effect in August 2005.
The ruling comes as the legal and political battle over Arizona's human-smuggling law intensifies. In November, a group of immigrant advocates filed a federal lawsuit challenging Thomas' interpretation of the law.
Thomas' prosecutions have drawn political fire because the coyote law was initially created to prosecute human smugglers. Thomas, however, also is using the conspiracy law to prosecute undocumented immigrants who pay to be smuggled. His actions have drawn national attention.
On Tuesday, the county attorney called the judge's ruling "extraordinary" but downplayed its impact on other smuggling cases that his office is pursuing. O'Toole has changed his mind on other human-smuggling legal issues, including ones in the Guzman-Garcia case, Thomas said.
"In all due respect to the judge, I don't understand this ruling. This one was a curve ball," said Thomas, noting that his office has a 90 percent conviction rate in human-smuggling cases. Other judges have accepted guilty pleas from migrants charged in smuggling cases, he said.
"This is a long-term battle," he said. "Immigrants typically turn to the judiciary as the last refuge of sympathy."
More than 160 people have been convicted in human-smuggling cases, but the case against 28-year-old Guzman-Garcia was the first time a jury had convicted a person of the crime. Since the Guzman-Garcia case, there has been one other jury conviction in a human-smuggling conspiracy case.
In other human-smuggling prosecutions, Thomas acknowledged that many of the accused migrants pleaded guilty to lesser offenses, got no jail time, aside from their time served, and were put on unsupervised probation.
Lack of evidence
In Tuesday's case, O'Toole acquitted Guzman-Garcia because the prosecution never presented enough independent evidence that he was part of the smuggling business -- prosecutors only proved that he was a paying customer.
"The court finds that there was no substantial evidence to warrant the defendant's conviction for this charge," O'Toole wrote.
"Evidence showed that the defendant was nothing more than a paying passenger. . . . The conspiracy statute does not impose criminal liability on a person merely being transported by an alien smuggler for profit or commercial purpose," the judge concluded.
O'Toole's ruling even surprised the defense attorney, who had come to Tuesday's hearing with his client so that Guzman-Garcia could be sentenced.
Defense attorneys routinely make a last-ditch motion asking the court to acquit their clients after the prosecutors finish presenting their case, and the defense often asks again after the jury's verdict. Judges rarely grant the requests, lawyers say.
It is even more rare for judges to deny the first request and then change their minds and grant the second request after the verdict is in, said Gary Lowenthal who teaches criminal law at Arizona State University. That is what happened in Guzman-Garcia's case.
After O'Toole cleared Guzman-Garcia, "I felt like someone has thrown water on my face," said Guzman-Garcia's lawyer, Jose Antonio Colon.
After the ruling, Guzman-Garcia was taken into custody by immigration officials, Colon said.
Guzman-Garcia can demand a hearing on his immigration case or he can volunteer to go back to Mexico. If Guzman-Garcia agrees to go back, he will be put on a bus to Nogales.
Questions of legality
Guzman-Garcia is from Morelia, Michoacan, but worked as a construction worker in the United States and had lived in Atlanta for several years, his lawyer says. Guzman-Garcia was adamant about fighting the human-smuggling charges and flew back and forth from Arizona to Georgia for court hearings, Colon said.
Colon blamed the jury verdict on the anti-immigration climate in the Valley.
"Most of the people in Arizona feel there is a problem with illegal immigration," Colon said. "They feel something must be done."
One lawyer for immigration advocates renewed his call on Thomas to temporarily suspend the conspiracy prosecutions.
Thomas should wait "while the courts have a chance to decide the legality and constitutionality of the policy," said Peter Schey, president of the Center For Human Rights and Constitutional Law.
Human-smuggling conspiracy cases are a new area of law, said Lowenthal, the ASU professor. Until a Maricopa County smuggling case reaches the state appellate or state Supreme Court level, there won't be a precedent to guide judges. Maricopa County judges will continue to grapple with the cases, Lowenthal said.
"The judge is in uncharted water," he said.
Report this post as:
More Pix: "Families Belong Together," Pasadena
"Families Belong Together" March, Pasadena
Short Report on the Families Belong Together Protest in Los Angeles
Summer 2018 National Immigrant Solidarity Network News Alert!
Watch the Debate: Excluded Candidates for Governor of California
Change Links June 2018 posted
The Montrose Peace Vigil at 12 Years
Unity Archive Project
Dianne Feinstein's Promotion of War, Secret Animal Abuse, Military Profiteering, Censorshi
CA Senate Bill 1303 would require an independent coroner rather than being part of police
Three years after OC snitch scandal, no charges filed against sheriffs deputies
California police agencies violate Brown Act (open meetings)
Insane Company Wants To Send Nuke Plant Waste To New Mexico
Change Links May 2018
Worker-Owned Car Wash on Vermont Closed
GUIDE TO REBEL CITY LOS ANGELES AVAILABLE
lausd whistle blower
Help KCET and UCLA identify 60s-70s Chicano images
UCLA Luskin: Casting Youth Justice in a Different Light
Change Links April 2018
Nuclear Shutdown News March 2018
Join The Protest Rally in Glendale on April 10, 2018!
Spring 2018 National Immigrant Solidarity Network News Alert!
Anti-Eviction Mapping Project Shows Shocking Eviction Trends in L.A.
Steve Mnuchin video at UCLA released
Actress and Philanthropist Tanna Frederick Hosts Project Save Our Surf Beach Clean Ups
After Being Told He's 'Full of Sh*t' at School Event, Mnuchin Demands UCLA Suppress Video
More Local News...
The System Question as a Survival Question
“Animaniacs in Concert!” Starring Voice Legend Rob Paulsen
Nation's Largest Voting Machine Co., ESS, Admits Lying Re Having Installed Remote Control
Du pain et des jeux
Fbi joins with Facebook to remove this report
Paraphysique de martyrologie
Asian Countries:Cambodia, Vietnam, N. Korea do not permit unlawful immigration
Children Incorporated Earns 4-Star Rating on Charity Navigator
Democratic Socialists of America
Leonard Peltier Non Violent Native American Political Prisoner since 1970's
Paraphysique miscellanées de l'aggiornamento
Actress and Philanthropist Tanna Frederick Hosts Project Save Our Surf Beach Cleanup
FBI Investigated LA County Sheriff Baca,Why Not Hank Skinner's Persecution?
Updated Partial List Of Famous Vegetarians, Vegans, & Fruitarians
The Shortwave Report 07136/18 Listen Globally!
Social Policy as Social Infrastructure
Vol I: 84 Varieties Of GOP Election Fraud
Texas Can Call it An Execution,But It is A State Sponsored Murder of Hank Skinner..
June 2018 Honduras coup update
Maria Estrada doubles down on racist support
New York Women in Film & Television Announces 2018 NYWIFT Ha Phuong Scholarship Recipients
Trapps de la domination, trapps de l'aliénation
Please Work For The Defeat Of Brett Kavanaugh And Why
Change Links 2018 July posted
Transinhumanisme ( transe inhumanisme )
Google, World's Biggest Censor, Was Founded By The CIA
For a World Free of Nuclear Risks
Corrupt CDC Ignores Meat Fish Recalls
More Breaking News...