|
|
printable version
- email this article
- view hidden posts
- spam score
by By the Editorial Board
Thursday, Aug. 10, 2006 at 10:39 PM
The claim that American and British security forces have thwarted a terrorist plot to blow up commercial flights between Britain and the United States should not be accepted uncritically. It is impossible to determine at this point whether or not such an attack was in the offing, although the mass media have, as usual, reported the assertions of the British and American governments as indisputable fact, without bothering to ask for any specific information that would substantiate the official story.
The British police statement that the alleged plotters aimed to “create mass murder on an unimaginable scale” by blowing up mid-flight an unspecified number of aircraft is chilling. The far-reaching security measures that have been implemented—including the shutdown of London’s Heathrow Airport and an indefinite ban on carry-on luggage—add to the climate of fear and apprehension. At a time such as this—in the midst of spectacular claims from London and Washington, a media barrage supporting them, and a massive disruption of commercial flights resulting from extreme security measures—it is all the more imperative that people not suspend their capacity for critical thought and political judgement. Raids in the early hours of Thursday morning on homes and business premises in London and the West Midlands resulted in 21 arrests. Spokesmen for the US and British governments asserted that those arrested were involved in the most significant terrorist plot since 9/11. Later reports said that 24 people had been arrested in Britain and more had been detained in Pakistan. Among those arrested were a Muslim charity worker and a Heathrow Airport employee with an all-area access pass, according to Britain’s Channel 4 News. Five suspects in the plot are still at large, according to ABC News, which cited US sources. BBC News reported Thursday evening that the arrests were the result of a long-standing investigation coordinated between the US, British and Pakistani governments. British Home Secretary John Reid in a press conference earlier on Thursday said Prime Minister Tony Blair had briefed President George Bush on the impending arrests and security measures over the weekend. Subsequent reports claimed the plotters had planned to target simultaneously up to ten aircraft from three US carriers by smuggling onboard liquid chemical explosives disguised as beverages or electronic devices. US intelligence officials said the plotters hoped to stage a “dry run” today (Friday) and the actual attack would have followed days later. A senior congressional source claimed the plotters planned to mix a sports drink with a peroxide-based paste to make an “explosive cocktail” that could be triggered by an MP3 player or cell phone. President George Bush made a brief statement mid-day Thursday that was calculated to heighten public anxieties and exploit the alleged terror plot to justify the panoply of reactionary policies his administration has pursued since 9/11 in the name of the “war on terror.” Speaking on an airport runway in Green Bay, Wisconsin, he said that the thwarted plot was a “stark reminder that this nation is at war with Islamic fascists who will use any means to destroy those of us who love freedom.” He suggested that the plot vindicated the measures—massive domestic spying, military tribunals, detentions without trial—taken by his administration to “protect the American people,” and went on to warn that “it is a mistake to believe there is no threat to the United States of America.” The World Socialist Web Site has no information that allows us to make a definitive judgement on the existence or non-existence of a terrorist plot on the scale claimed. However, it is the responsibility of the US and British governments to produce the facts that would substantiate their allegations and justify the extreme security measures they have taken, and to present these facts to the public in a clear and concise manner. They have produced no such factual account or substantiation. Neither the White House nor Downing Street has any right to expect people to accept their claims at face value, or place confidence in any of their statements. The war against Iraq was legitimised on the basis of false claims of Iraqi weapons of mass destruction and ties between Saddam Hussein and Al Qaeda. These lies have destroyed forever the credibility of Bush and Blair. If it is true that such a heinous crime was being planned, the responsibility for this ultimately rests with the policies pursued by Washington and London. Ever since 9/11, both Bush and Blair have employed the mantra of the “war on terror” as a cover for their predatory war aims in the Middle East, immensely intensifying anti-American and anti-British sentiment within the Muslim world. At the same time, the “war on terror” has been used domestically as the pretext for an unprecedented assault on democratic rights. Faced with a worsening debacle in Afghanistan and Iraq, and massive international opposition to their support for Israel’s devastation of Lebanon, both governments have an interest in perpetuating an atmosphere of hysteria. Such a climate serves to intimidate their opponents and justify ever more draconian measures at home and abroad. In point of fact, the official accounts in Britain of the alleged terror plot lack any specific or verifiable facts and are remarkably short on detail. The statements by American officials are no better when it comes to serious substantiation. They are, however, more detailed in their claims. US Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff told a televised news conference that the plot was “a very sophisticated plan and operation” and was close to fruition. “It was not a circle with a handful of people sitting around and dreaming,’’ he said. “They had accumulated the capability necessary and they were well on their way.’’ The plot appeared to have been aimed at US carriers flying out of Heathrow, he continued. It was “international in scope” and suggestive of Al Qaeda. He did not give a specific date for the timing of the plan, but said it may have been before the anniversary of the 9/11 attacks. “I can’t tell you they had a particular date in mind,” he said. “Nor can I tell you that they would have waited that long. This was quite close to the execution date.” Chertoff offered no explanation of how security services knew that a terror attack was imminent when they didn’t know the target date for its execution. This is by no means the only question mark hanging over official accounts. Britain’s Home Secretary Reid gave the impression in his press conference that the evidence prompting the arrests came from the UK, and CNN reported that information gathered after recent arrests in Pakistan convinced British investigators they had to act urgently to stop the plot. However, Britain’s Channel 4 reported that UK authorities had acted based on intelligence provided by the CIA. Moreover, if Blair was in discussions with Bush over the weekend about an “imminent” terrorist attack, why did he still leave for his holiday in Barbados on Tuesday? And given that the plot is said to have targeted planes, why did the security services allow him to do so? And if the threat posed by the plot was considered dangerous enough to warrant raising the terror alert in the UK from “severe” to “critical” and to code red in the US, why were no arrests made for five days? And why was the terror alert only raised after the arrests were made and not before? No such questions have been asked by the media. And yet recent months have seen a number of alleged terrorist plots—in the US, Canada and Australia—that were supposedly thwarted by the security services. In each case, mass arrests were made of people who, according to the indictments, had merely discussed terrorist acts. No concrete plans were discovered, no weapons or explosives seized. And in most of these cases, the supposed plots were initiated and encouraged by government informers who acted as agent provocateurs and entrapped the alleged conspirators. In the case of July’s so-called “tunnel bomb” plot in New York, the purported conspirators were foreign nationals who had never set foot in the US. As for the political utility of the current terror scare, it should be noted that only hours before Thursday’s raids, British Home Secretary Reid gave a major speech in London in which he accused opponents of the government’s anti-democratic legislation of undermining the “war on terror.” In the face of what he called “probably the most sustained period of severe threat since the end of the second world war,” Reid decried those who “don’t get it,” blaming them for the fact that “we remain unable to adapt our institutions and legal orthodoxy as fast as we need to.” Making it clear that the required “adaptation” meant the gutting of traditional democratic rights, he added: “Sometimes we may have to modify some of our own freedoms in the short term in order to prevent their misuse and abuse by those who oppose our fundamental values and would destroy all of our freedoms in the modern world.”
-World Socialist Web Site
www.wsws.org
Report this post as:
LATEST COMMENTS ABOUT THIS ARTICLE
Listed below are the 10 latest comments of 1 posted about this article.
These comments are anonymously submitted by the website visitors.
|
|
|
Local News
LAPD's High-Tech "War Room"
F10 7:07AM
OCCUPY PRESS RELEASE: 8 CHALLENGES TO WELLS FARGO (FEB 6, 2012)
F09 4:00PM
8 CHALLENGES TO WELLS FARGO FROM OCCUPY ACTIVISTS
F08 3:11PM
Resolution in Support of Warehouse Workers at Walmart Contractor Schneider Logistics
F07 12:53AM
Construction workers picket new gym in Upland
F06 11:59PM
F29 Double-sided flyer (English and Spanish) in PDF form
F06 4:52PM
STOP A "NAFTA OF THE PACIFIC!" RALLY VS SECRET NEGOTIATIONS HELD IN SOFITEL HOTEL IN LA
F06 10:04AM
Los Angeles participates in national day of action against war in Iran
F06 12:43AM
Protecting Sacred Sites: The Kuruvungna Springs
F05 9:08PM
Press Release for Monday Occupy Meeting with Wells Fargo Execs (3-5:30pm)
F05 9:02AM
What's Left for the Left? Building a Blue-Green Coalition
F05 7:57AM
San Diego Queer Democrats Reject Progressive, Endorse Moderate for Congress
F04 1:03PM
How Mike Kelley Helped Me Paint My Way Out of a Prison Cell
F04 12:41PM
Protest: ELA Police Checkpoint
F03 11:03AM
Cornel West lectures on social justice; PD harasses occupier for flyering
F01 10:12PM
WHY OCCUPY art exhibit
F01 1:16AM
Trans Pacific Free Trade Agreement Action Wed!
J31 5:35PM
Even Local Businesses Support Efforts to Save LAUSD Adult Education
J30 1:46AM
F29 SHUTDOWN THE CORPORATIONS CALL TO ACTION: Occupy Walmart!
J28 11:55PM
Retenes este fin de semana / Weekend checkpoints (26-28/jan/2012)
J26 4:05AM
Occupy Redlands Protests Citizens United Decision
J26 2:06AM
BREAKING: Five Arrested at Protest Outside HLS Office.
J24 2:45PM
RAISETHEFIST.COM MARKS 10 YEAR ANNIVERSARY OF FBI RAID
J24 6:39AM
UCR Occupied in Defense of Education
J23 12:11AM
Homeless persons have no value to the authorities
J19 10:15PM
BREAKING: Students at UCR force regents to adjourn
J19 10:39AM
On MLK Day, Dedicate Ourselves for the Final Struggle for Justice and Equality
J16 8:11AM
L.A. PORT POLICE & L.A. COUNTY SHERIFF CONSPIRE IN KIDNAPPING OF CARPENTER
J12 5:49PM
More Local News...
Other/Breaking News
Contacts and Details on Regional S. CA Post-Secondary Student Conference
F12 11:01AM
Mr.
F12 10:22AM
Live coverage from Greece: Manifestations in Athens, Thessaloniki
F12 9:07AM
Mr.
F12 9:03AM
Mr.
F12 9:00AM
To Get The 1% To Beg Us For Mercy.
F12 6:06AM
BTL: Sierra Club Secretly Took $26 million from Natural Gas Industry for Campaign Against
F12 5:50AM
Iran's Historic Anniversary
F12 1:05AM
Khader Adnan's Heroic Struggle for Justice
F12 12:40AM
Turkish daily: Turkey’s plan to finish off Assad
F11 4:06PM
In new window Print all Turkish daily: Turkey’s plan to finish off Assad
F11 3:55PM
Trump Cards, Fig Leafs and Ludicrous Insinuations
F11 9:23AM
NATO's Secret War on Syria
F11 1:20AM
America's Sham Economic Recovery
F11 12:52AM
Palabras para Agustín
F10 6:07PM
Wall Street Excess and Main Street Distress: the Apple Connection
F10 5:11PM
Sheriff Arpaio and Cronies Exposed in Federal Court
F10 2:45PM
RON PAUL SUPPORTS HR 210, FILVETS
F10 2:27PM
Nazi USA's military displays Nazi Germany's SS flag
F10 7:25AM
Duplicitous Mortgage Settlement Deal
F10 12:50AM
Murdering Khadar Adnan
F10 12:31AM
Factory Place Open Studio Sale
F09 6:22PM
The Shortwave Report 02/10 Listen Globally!
F09 5:30PM
Domestic Violence Is NOT a Gender Issue!
F09 4:06PM
La farce électorale
F09 9:13AM
Dominant Economy Pretends Its Breakdown Was Unforeseeable
F09 8:39AM
Petition to Cal Sec of State to list all Peace & Freedom Candidates
F09 8:33AM
Act Up Against ACTA
F09 1:57AM
More Breaking News...
|