|
|
printable version
- email this article
- view hidden posts
The Real Heroes of Gulf War II: Conscientious Objectors
by fresca
Wednesday, Apr. 16, 2003 at 9:52 AM
Thousands of troops have blindly followed the Bush-Blair-Sharon sanctioned mass-murder of the Iraqi people. Unnamed re the hundreds, possibly thousands, of U.S. personnel in the armed forces have applied for conscientious objector status since January. Though few have gone public, they emerge the true heroes of the armed forces, in refusing to participate in an illegal war of aggression on Iraq.
IRAQ: Hundreds of U.S. Soldiers Emerge as Conscientious Objectors
Gabriel Packard
NEW YORK, Apr 15 (IPS) - Although only a handful of them have gone public, at least several hundred U.S. soldiers have applied for conscientious objector (CO) status since January, says a rights group.
The Center on Conscience and War (CCW), which advises military personnel on CO discharges, reports that since the start of 2003 - when many soldiers realised they might have to fight in the Iraq war - there has been a massive increase in the number of enlisted soldiers who have applied for CO status.
”The bare minimum is several hundred, and this number only includes the ones that have come to my group and to groups we're associated with,” CCW official J.E. McNeil told IPS.
”There will be others who will have gone through different channels, and some people do it on their own,” she added.
Generally, COs possess a sincere conviction that forbids them from taking part in organised killing. This objection may apply to all or to only particular aspects of war.
Only a small percentage of people who apply receive a CO discharge. But military statistics lag about one year behind, and the decisions on CO applications take on average six months to one year - sometimes as long as two years - so the exact number of COs in the present war will not be known for some time.
Also, military figures do not count applications from servicemen who are absent without leave, so they will not include Stephen Funk, a marine reserve who was on unauthorised leave before he publicly declared himself a conscientious objector and reported back to his military base in San Jose, California, Apr. 1.
Funk, 20, realised that he was against all war during his training, which including having to bayonet human-shaped dummies while shouting, ”kill, kill”.
Since publicly declaring his opposition to war, he has become a symbol of resistance both in the United States and around the world.
”Since Stephen went public,” says Aimee Allison, a CO from the first Gulf War who has been supporting Funk, ”some people from Yesh Gvul (a group of Israeli soldiers who have refused to fight in the occupied territories in Palestine) have contacted me to pledge their support for Stephen and to show solidarity and to thank him for making a stand.”
”People in other countries are proud that an American can stand up to the hegemony and the violence of the war in Iraq,” she adds.
Soldiers in other countries, including Turkey, have refused to fight in the current war sparked by last month's U.S.-led attack. Three British servicemen were sent home from the Persian Gulf after objecting to the conduct of the invasion and a U.K. member of parliament, George Galloway, says he ”is calling on British forces to refuse to obey the illegal orders” involved in the war.
As it is in the British army, CO discharge is a long-established practice in the U.S. armed forces and always peaks in wartime. CCW says there were an estimated 200,000 COs in the Vietnam War, 4,300 in the Korean War, 37,000 in World War II and 3,500 in World War I.
The military granted 111 COs from the army in the first Gulf War before putting a stop to the practice, resulting in 2,500 soldiers being sent to prison, says Bill Gavlin from the Center on Conscience and War, quoting a report from the 'Boston Globe' newspaper.
During that war, a number of U.S. COs in Camp LeJeune in North Carolina state were ”beaten, harassed and treated horribly”, Gavlin says. In some cases, COs were put on planes bound for Kuwait, told that they could not apply for CO status or that they could only apply after they'd already gone to war.
As far as Gavlin knows, that type of treatment has not happened this time. But he has counselled service members who were harassed. For example, one woman was told that if she applied for CO status she would be court marshalled. It is not an offence to apply, and her superiors did it, Gavlin says, ”to intimidate her.”
Funk is being treated ''with kid gloves'' in his home camp, where he is on restricted duty, according to Allison. But he is poised to be transferred to a ''remote'' camp, a standard procedure for COs, says Gavlin.
Allison says she was both supported and condemned when she became a CO. ”Privately I received overwhelming personal support from the other members of my unit,” she says. ”But publicly I was isolated by my unit.”
”I was a senior at Stanford at the time, and again, in private I got lots of support - for example anti-war groups on campus asked me to speak at events,” she adds. ”But there were also detractors on campus and in the broader community.”
Even though conscientious objection is well established, Funk - like many others - found it difficult to find information about it within the military system. ”It took him six or seven months,” says Allison. ”And eventually he was searching the Internet .... and found the G.I. Rights website.”
G.I. Rights is a network of nongovernmental organisations (NGOs) that give advice and information to service members about military discharges and about complaint procedures. CCW belongs to this network.
The NGOs advise soldiers on whether they meet the criteria for CO status, and help them complete a CO application. The process involves filling in a 22-question form, being interviewed by a military chaplain, a psychologist and an investigating officer. To succeed in getting CO status, soldiers must demonstrate that their beliefs about war have changed since they enlisted.
Soldiers that have this change of heart fall into three main groups, says McNeil.
The first group contains ”those who go into the military understanding war and are willing to accept it”, she says. ”But then something happens during their service and they are no longer OK with war.”
The second group contains people who have ”sought out spiritual growth and have come to believe that God doesn't want them to participate in war.”
The third, and biggest, group, she says, is made up of young, often naive, people who join the military in their late teens. They are often poor whites, blacks or Hispanics, who either have limited employment opportunities, or are looking for a way to fund their college education.
Because military recruiters target poor youth in urban centres - the so-called ”poverty draft” - this is probably the fastest-growing group of COs as well as the biggest, added McNeil. (END/2003)
ipsnews.net/interna.asp?idnews=17584
Report this post as:
LATEST COMMENTS ABOUT THIS ARTICLE
Listed below are the 10 latest comments of 11 posted about this article.
These comments are anonymously submitted by the website visitors.
| TITLE |
AUTHOR |
DATE |
| We Support You Completely |
ANP |
Wednesday, Apr. 16, 2003 at 10:19 AM |
| ^ |
Bush Admirer |
Wednesday, Apr. 16, 2003 at 11:05 AM |
| Simple |
Simple Simon |
Wednesday, Apr. 16, 2003 at 11:25 AM |
| Gee... |
daveman |
Thursday, Apr. 17, 2003 at 4:56 AM |
| war no war |
thomaston |
Thursday, Apr. 17, 2003 at 6:39 AM |
| We do dumb things... |
daveman |
Thursday, Apr. 17, 2003 at 7:58 AM |
| daveman |
Eric |
Thursday, Apr. 17, 2003 at 9:04 AM |
| Truth in advertising |
systemfailure |
Friday, Apr. 18, 2003 at 3:09 AM |
| Are you saying... |
daveman |
Friday, Apr. 18, 2003 at 3:26 AM |
| Eric |
daveman |
Friday, Apr. 18, 2003 at 3:29 AM |
| Been there, done that shit |
systemfailure |
Friday, Apr. 18, 2003 at 3:40 AM |
|
|
|
Local News
Queremos justicia: Pueblo rechazó presencia del alguacil Arpaio en Condado de Orange
N06 9:13AM
Sit-in at Chancellor Yang's office to protest closure of Ventura Campus
N05 10:49AM
Settlement Puts an End to Controversial Elephant Hill Development in Los Angeles
N05 7:33AM
BREAKING: Wednesday, Nov 4, 7:45pm - Hundreds Marching in Silverlake for right to marry
N04 7:46PM
Calling Long Beach Area Anarchists!
N04 7:54AM
JFAV ACTION WEEK, NOVEMBER 8-14, 2009
N02 3:47PM
Checkpoints this weeked: Retenes este fin de semana (30-31/oct)
O29 9:51PM
Fred Phelps Brings Road Show of Hate to San Diego; 500 Protest Against Him
O29 7:10PM
Pension fund probe into possible bribery of former LA deputy mayor
O29 6:02PM
Dr. Helen Caldicott Speaks in San Diego
O29 5:50PM
Queer Democrats Endorse Alvarez, Wayne for City Council
O29 5:41PM
Béla Dornon: Queer Photographer Seeks to Document California’s Same-Sex Marriages
O29 5:30PM
Physician and Six Activists Are Arrested At CIGNA's Glendale, CA Offices
O28 8:08PM
Physician and Six Activists Are Arrested At CIGNA's Glendale, CA Offices/ Video
O28 7:35PM
BREAKING: 1pm - 10/28/09 - Healthcare Activists Stage Sit-in at Cigna offices, 7 Arrested
O28 12:55PM
First in state Holistic Mom’s Network chapter celebrates 5th birthday
O27 11:02PM
More footage of the Anti-Nazi protest
O27 1:46AM
Sit-in at CIGNA insurance, 10am Wednesday, 10/28
O26 7:36PM
International Day of Climate Action in Eagle Rock (part 1)
O26 7:09PM
International Day of Climate Action in Eagle Rock part 2
O26 6:30PM
Inland Empire Against Racial Hate (1-13)
O26 1:44PM
Video footage of the Anti-Nazi protest
O26 11:28AM
Immigrants Are Welcome Here. Nazis Are Not. (Photo set 3)
O26 10:47AM
Immigrants Are Welcome Here. Nazis Are Not. (Photo set 2)
O26 10:22AM
Immigrants Are Welcome Here. Nazis Are Not.
O26 10:06AM
Indymedia Los Angeles 10th Anniversary Event!
O26 9:55AM
NAZIS GO HOME! Spit and Swastikas Clash in Riverside
O26 8:40AM
Nazis in Riverside
O25 7:46PM
More Local News...
Other/Breaking News
GLOBAL TURN AROUND!
N07 2:27PM
JFAV/ FIL-AMS ALL SET FOR VETERANS DAY PROTEST MARCH ON NOVEMBER 11 IN LA
N07 12:26PM
NDF -EV URGES PEOPLE TO ACT ON UTILITIES CRISIS
N07 11:58AM
PHILIPPINES; A CAPITALIST CALAMITY
N07 10:25AM
~ BIGDADDYJAZZANDMAYA.COM ~ THE ATTEMPT TO DESTROY ONE LOCAL POORER AMERICAN FAMILY~!
N07 9:13AM
~ BIGDADDYJAZZANDMAYA.COM ~ THE ATTEMPT TO DESTROY ONE LOCAL POORER AMERICAN FAMILY~!
N07 9:05AM
BTL:Former Religious Right Activist Warns Against Incitement to Violence
N07 4:00AM
Nov. 20-22 Mass Mobilization to Close the SOA
N06 1:59PM
Honduran Accord Solidifies Coup E'Etat Rule
N06 1:15PM
Democraticamente. FERNANDO LUGO, CONTINUADA DESHONRA PARA LA INVESTIDURA PRESIDENCIAL
N06 11:42AM
National Resistance Against the Coup d’Etat Announces Boycott of Elections
N06 10:35AM
Don't go
N06 8:59AM
BTL:Civil Disobedience Actions Launched to Stop Mountain Top Removal
N06 5:29AM
Diario Siglo XXI. FERNANDO LUGO, CONTINUADA DESHONRA PARA LA INVESTIDURA PRESIDENCIAL
N06 12:44AM
Rivers Casino Supervisor Physically Assaults Casino Security Officer during Union Campaign
N05 9:05PM
Obama is Absolutely Right to Re-evaluate Afghanistan Strategy
N05 6:49PM
The Shortwave Report 11/06 Listen Globally!
N05 5:02PM
The latest trend in eco-tourism is completely out of this world ... and right around the c
N05 2:18PM
Comments from an Inmate
N05 11:56AM
The High Risk Business of Banks
N05 5:40AM
BTL:Karzai Government Corruption Hobbles Obama Afghan War Strategy
N05 5:11AM
War Criminals and their agent control 344 Members of Congress.
N05 1:29AM
EEUU SOBORNA CON ARMAS A FERNANDO LUGO
N05 12:45AM
Reject Corporate Option for Health Care
N04 7:55PM
Blog en solidaridad con el SME. México
N04 1:58PM
House Resolution Designates Venezuela a State Sponsor of Terrorism
N04 1:08PM
Pirates attack ship in eastern mediterranean
N04 7:23AM
Profits=Investments=Jobs?
N04 5:49AM
More Breaking News...
|