http://hardnewscafe.usu.edu/?p=7687

Should Mormons be vegetarians? Yes, says guest speaker

April 14th, 2012

Story and photo by Sean O'Sullivan

LOGAN – A logic and religious history-based argument may leave Mormons

questioning whether or not they should be eating meat.

Chris Foster, professor of philosophy and logic at Utah Valley University, came

to Utah State University Thursday to explain his reasoning behind becoming a

vegetarian, and why he feels it is clear that other people, focusing on Mormons,

should as well.

Being a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints isn't what led

Foster to becoming a vegetarian; he was one before he was baptized.

"If something is being killed, I shouldn't have anything to do with it," Foster

said.

But now, he is able to communicate his decision to more people, and has expanded

on his reasoning.

From a logical perspective, Foster explained that killing animals causes them

harm, and it is morally wrong to cause something harm unless the benefits

outweigh the harm caused. But he feels that raising animals for food causes more

harm than benefits, and therefore killing and eating animals is morally wrong.

However, Foster knows changing peoples' minds is going to be tougher than laying

out a series of logical arguments. "We need to be willing to listen to the other

side," he said.

The main argument against vegetarianism is that animals are less important than

humans, Foster said, and he explained that people would be forced to say this.

If animals were allowed to be on the same level as humans, then killing animals

would be akin to killing humans. We as a society deem killing humans to be

terrible, so in order to continue eating meat we have to keep animals on a level

below humans. However, Foster said that animals should be considered equal to

humans.

Then, Foster went in to the religious side of his argument. He was able to find

multiple instances of LDS prophets saying not to kill and eat animals. However,

all the prophets agreed that eating animals was acceptable when no other means

of acquiring food were available.

Prophets such as Joseph Smith, Joseph Smith Jr., Lorenzo Smith and Brigham Young

have all voiced their disapproval of eating animals. However, apostle and member

of the First Presidency George Q. Cannon may have been the most vocal.

"I'd go so far as to say George Q. Cannon was an activist," Foster said.

Foster also showed quotes from scriptures that say killing animals harms them,

and he was able to bring back his logical argument that harming something

shouldn't be tolerated.

"I like that he showed the logic side and then tying it to the LDS Doctrine at

the end," said Quinton Cannon, who is an active LDS member and a vegetarian.

At the end, Foster showed a 12-minute movie about animal conditions in

slaughterhouses. The animals in the video were routinely beaten and mistreated.

Foster said the video was hard for him to watch.

"You don't need philosophy; you don't need religion," said Foster. "It's obvious

that it's abuse; it's obvious that it's unethical."

After the movie, there was a question and answer portion where students brought

up the fact that the LDS church owns ranches for animal raising. These questions

brought about a discussion that had to be cut short so Foster could drive back

to UVU to teach a class.

"I liked the question and answer thing at the end," said Crystal Larsen. "I've

seen the video before, but I liked the questions brought up at the end."

Foster's presentation can be found on the Mormons for Animals homepage, a group

he helped to start.

NW

************************************

A seven year US government study

was done on nonsmoking nondrinking

Mormons and 7th Day Adventists.

The vegan Adventists had 7 to 8

years longer life expectancy

than nonvegetarian Mormons.

The uric acid in animal flesh, also known as

pre-urine or trioxypurine,

is stronger than the caffein

or dioxypurine that observant

Mormons avoid.

*

Scott Smith, editor of the former periodical Vegetarian World, is

one of several who have written

books on Mormon vegetarians.



*



Over 13,500 messages on Mormon Veg forum

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/MormonVeg/messages/13667

http://ldsveg.org

http://bycommonconsent.com/2009/03/28/good-news-for-vegans/

http://pcrm.org an organization of vegan physicians and other health

professionals

http://hardnewscafe.usu.edu/?p=7687