ACLU Criticizes Police Officials FOR IMMEDIATE

RELEASE

By BethX

OR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Monday, August 7, 2000

PHILADELPHIA, PA -- The American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania is extremely critical

of how Police Commissioner John Timoney and District Attorney Lynne Abraham are

overreacting to the disruptions and vandalism that occurred in Philadelphia on August 1, 2000.

While the ACLU does not condone the unlawful actions that occurred last week, we are greatly

disturbed by the Commissioner's call for a federal investigation. We are also troubled by the

District Attorney's seeking the court's permission to seal critical legal documents while throwing

the book at those who were arrested.

These official actions are particularly unsettling in light of the additional stories of abuse and

brutality that have been brought to our attention over the weekend.

The ACLU believes that vandalizing property, turning over trash cans, assaulting persons and

shutting down the city by blocking traffic are not activities protected by the First Amendment.

However, they are not the kind of crimes that justify treating the defendants as if they were

dangerous urban terrorists.

The ACLU is very worried that a federal investigation, as suggested by the Police

Commissioner, could discourage many Americans from exercising their First Amendment

rights. Calling for the federal government to prosecute those who engage in nonviolent civil

disobedience could intimidate many people from participating in protests. Many Americans will

be afraid that they will get caught up in a federal investigation.

The ACLU is also concerned that bail is being set at artificially high levels to keep protest

leaders in detention until their date of trial, which will be after the Democratic Convention in

Los Angeles. The purpose of bail is to insure that a defendant will appear at trial. It is not

intended to prevent a person from expressing his or her dissenting views.

Over the weekend, credible stories concerning serious injuries inflicted upon those who were

arrested last week have been reported to the ACLU. We intend to review those incidents to

determine whether, in fact, excessive force was used in the streets or prisons. We will also

advise people to file complaints of police misconduct with the Police Advisory Commission.

Finally, we continue to believe that the seizure of the warehouse in West Philadelphia and the

arrest of 70 individuals who were at that warehouse raise many questions. Last Friday's

orchestrated display of evidence did not resolve our doubts as to the legality of police actions

against that warehouse. We still suspect that the seizure in West Philadelphia was an

overbroad sweep of many individuals who had no intention of engaging in violent protest.