{"article":{"id":267213,"heading":"I am not Charlie\/Condemnation of the Charlie Hebdo attacks\/No solidarity with racism","author":"Astrid Essed","created":"2015-01-29 17:46:03","modified":"2015-01-29 17:46:03","last_modified":"Fri, 30 Jan 2015 00:46:03","article":"

I AM NOT CHARLIE\/CONDEMNATION OF THE CHARLIE HEBDO ATTACKS\/YES

NO SOLIDARITY WITH RACISM AND ISLAMOPHOBIA



SEE ALSO



http:\/\/www.astridessed.nl\/i-am-not-charliecondemnation-of-the-charlie-hebdo-attacksno-solidarity-with-racism-and-islamophobia\/<\/a>



''DON''T BE AFRAID. I WON'T KILL YOU.

YOU'RE A WOMAN''

Sigolène Vinson, one of the survivors of the Charlie Hebdo massacre, has given an account of how her life was spared

http:\/\/www.theguardian.com\/world\/2015\/jan\/14\/charlie-hebdo-killings-survivor-story<\/a>



Charlie Hebdo, a somewhat obscure magazine, [1] is suddenly is an

international star.

At wednesday 7 january, two masked gunmen killed ten members

of the Charlie Hebdo editorial staff and two police officers, during

an editorial meeting. [2]

Soon international political reactions burst out, from over the whole

world. [3]

The Dutch King Willem Alexander showed ''very shocked'', as the Dutch

prime minister Rutte [4] and the other heads of State.

Leitmotiv was the criminal act and, in various terms ''the attack

against freedom of expression, a precious fundamental freedom which we must continue to defend.\" [5]

One of the few reactions, which looked farther, was the Indonesian,

which expressed, except a concdemnation '' fear that Wednesday's deadly shooting attack on the office of the French magazine, Charlie Hebdo, will harm Muslims around the world and hope the international community will be fair with this incident and not generalize it as part of Islam'' [6]

Iran pointed out, that '' \"making use of freedom of expression... to humiliate the monotheistic religions and their values and symbols is unacceptable.\" [7]

And of course the Dutch extreme-right Europese political gangster,

PVV fuhrer G, Wilders [8], as other European racist scum, uttered

their hatespeech and war language against Islam and muslims. [9]

A ''Charlie Hausse'' was created and millions in Europe

stood and shouted ''I am Charlie''

Cartoonists published more or less sordid cartoons [some

downright hatespeech] [10] and spontaneous ''I am Charlie''

demonstrations were held. [11]

This was only a prelude to the great Paris Charlie Hebdo March.

But there also were otherl sounds:

Morocco's Foreign Minister Salahedinne Mezouar didn't participate

with the Paris Charflie Hebdo March, because cartoons of the

Prophet Mohammed would be carried. [12]

The unity for Charlie Hebdo was not so broad as was

presented in de media:

An investigation of the Journal du Dimanche showed, that

four out of 10 French people think the magazine

Charlie Hebdo should not have published the Prophet

Mohammed cartoons because of the offense to muslims. [13]

A RIGHTFUL ''CHARLIE HAUSSE''?

OR IS THERE SOMETHING ROTTEN AT THE BOTTOM

OF ''CHARLIE''

Of course the killings of 12 people are never to be justified.

Understandable, thjat people want to show their grief and

solidarity.

But there is a big difference between showing your indignation

over a barbarous act and declaring solidarity with a magazine.

Because shouting ''Je suis Charlie'' means identification

with the Charlie Hebd Magazine.

AND THAT'S THE POINT!

Because:

What is Charlie Hebdo and do they deserve solidarity?

A\/FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION

CHARLIE HEBDO, THE MAGAZINE, IS

RACIST AND ISLAMOPHOBE

The Charlie Hebdo Magazine has a leftist tradition [14], but that

engagement is over since long.

What they have focused the last years is filthy and disgusting.

They have ridden with Islamophobia by publishing cartoons,

which are highly insulting to muslims.

Especially their infamous Mohammed cartoons. [15]

They are stigmatising and insulting and the muslims who are depicted

at the cartoons, are stereotyped with the usual big noses.

That is discriminating.

Charlie Hebdo also was the first to publish the notorious Danish

Mohanmmed cartoons [16]

One of the Danish cartoons was the notorious image of the Prophet

Mohammed with a bomb in his turban. [17]

Insulting towards the Islam and therefore muslims, but also

discriminating, since the suggestion is made, that all muslims

are terrorists.

Downright cowardly in a time of virulent Islamophobia.



RACISM

But there is more!

Charlie Hebdo also is racist, since it portrayed the French

minister of Justice AS A MONKEY! [18]

It also dared to depict real or alleged Boko Haram

sex slaves with the usual stereotypes for black people:

fat lips, vampire teeth, rolling eyes and crazy grimaces. [19]

That is no ''freedom of expression'', but Islamophobia and naked

racism, since freedom of expression doesn't mean to limit the rights and freedoms

of other people.

B\/FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION

PARIS CHARLIE HEBDO MARCH OF WORLD LEADERS\/

MARCH OF HYPOICRISY

Shameful was the p;olitical presence of ''world leaders''

at the Paris Charlie Hebdo March. [20]

Not only the Charlie Hebdo rubbish is racist and Islamophobe

and therefore no freedom of expression, those politicians,

who cry crocodile tears, hammering to the ''free speech'',

are no free speech lovers at all.

Examples:

The French president Hollande, who boasts on the

''free speech'' is very selective.

This free speech champion is a warm adherent of the Burqa

ban. [21]

The free speech of pro Palestinian demonstrators is also

of no concern to Hollande. [22]

The British prime minister Cameron, also a ''free speech champion''

except when muslims are concerned, since the the Home Office is now expecting nursery school teachers and child-minders to

to report toddlers at risk of becoming terrorists. [23]

Another free speech ''champion'' was war criminal, the Israeli

prime minister Netanyahu, who still occupies and oppress the Palestinian

territories, with free speech only for the dead. [24]

Turkish prime minister Davutaglu also defended ''free speech'

That was not very visible during the oppression and

intimidation of the Gezi park demonstrations in 2013. [25]

And not to mention the oppression of the Turkish Kurds,

not allowed to speak their own language and enjoy their own culture.

[26]

And not to forget the Spanish prime minister

Rajoy, another ''champion of free speech'', who tries

to crush the right to protest by a suppressive Security

Bill. [27]

FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION

DEMONSTRATIONS AGAINST THE

MOHAMMED CARTOONS IN THE ISLAMIC WORLD

The reaction in the Islamic world was quite opposite, by demonstrations

against the Charle Hebdo Mohammed cartoons. [28]

I think they're right.

The cartoons are insulting and discriminating.

In each case it is their freedom of expression, although I doubt

if in the Western countries an anti Mohammed cartoons

demonstration were allowed, since there is a double standard

concerning 'free speech''

The same France, that now applauds free speech, has prohibited

in 2012 a demonstration against the anti Islam film ''Innocence

of muslims'' [29]

AGAIN AND AGAIN

REPRINTING THE MOHAMMED CARTOONS

One would think, that the remaining editorial staff of Charlie

Hebdo would reflect on its position, look in the mirror

or discuss about the to follow strategies, but not at all.

One of the first reactions was the republishing of the Mohammed

cartoons. [30]

Is it strange than, that the Islamic world is considering this as

a provocation?

I think not.

Since the ''solidarity'' and interest with Charlie Hebdo is risen

to bog heights in the Western world, up to million copies

were printed, way beyond its usual print run of 60,000. [31]

A real ''Charlie'' hysteria.[32]



ANTI MUSLIM ATTACKS



As to be expected in post 11 september time, anti muslim

attacks were very violent, especially in France, where 128 anti

muslim incidents were reported between the Charlie Hebdo killings

and 20 january, compared to 133 last year, variyng from attacks

on Mosques, persons and threats. [33]

Worse still:

A Moroccan man was stabbed to death in front of his wife. [34]

In the Netherlands there also was an increase of attacks

and threats.

Two muslim women were attackedby a man at Amsterdam Central

Station.

Hero was an unknown man from Surinam [Dutch West Indies], who interfered.

[35]

Another hero is to be mentuioned here.

When a kosher supermarket in Paris was attacked by a gunman,

the Malinese born Lassana Bathily,hid people in a cold store room during the assault, so rescuing their lives. [36]

Therefore he was rewarded with the French nationality.[37]

Mr Bathily said about his act of bravery:

''\"I helped Jews. We're all brothers,\"

''It's not a question of Jews, Christians or Muslims, we're all in the same boat,\" [38]

Mr Bathily is muslim.

I emphasize this especially towards those who, in their Islamophobia,

are prejudiced against muslims, calling them all ''terrorists''

SAME STORY AGAIN

NEW ANTI TERROR MEASURES

As to be expected, the Eurpean politician have used the

Charlie Hebdo attacks as a pretext for strengthening anti

terror measures. [39]

During a meeting in Paris at 11 januari, the EU ministers of

Foreign Affairs have announced new anti terror measures.

In a joint statement the EU ministers are ''concerned'' about the use

of Internet ''to fuel hatred and violence'' [40]

It concerns ''hatespeech material'', which in reality means the stalking

of muslims and leftist activists, who are critical towards Western imperialism,

military intervention and capitalism.

Anti terrorist measures also imply the confiscation of travel documents of people considered dangerous, to speeding up agreements for the exchange of traffic data of passengers, [41].which is an assault to freedom of movement and

privacy.

Those anti terror measures only feed repression and already existing

terror hysteria.

TERROR HYSTERIA

AT GUNPOINT

To give an impression of the post Charlie Hebdo terror hysteria,

a report of Mr Dyab Abu Jahjah [42],leftist political activist and

former leader of the anti zionist Arab European League [AEL] [43].

It is all about his arrest before his home, because ''he looked

suspicious'', guns were pointed at him and a friend. [44]

Being a Libanese is a police target in those times of terror hysteria.

EPILOGUE

Free speech.

Since 11 september 2001, that is the pretext for utterings of

racism, right wing populism and Islamophobia.

Revealing that racism and Islamophobia, as criticism of

Western military interventions in the Middle East, is often seen

as ''extremism''

After the murders [which were, of course, not to be justified]

of Dutch anti immigration politician P Fortuyn and cineast T van Gogh,

it was all ''free speech'' which was attacked.

Although Fortuyn was a racist and Islamophobe and T van Gogh

an Islamophobe and antisemite. [45]

Charlie Hebdo is no exception, since it is an Islamophobe

and racist garbage paper, with yearlong purfposedly

provocation under the pretext of ''satire''

And after this assault no reflection, but again and again,

the reprinting of the same Mohammed cartoons. [46]

The same provocation continues.

The racist character is all too obvious.

Because the depiction of a black woman as a MONKEY

is diehard racism. [47]

Some people defend Charlie Hebdo by stating, that the paper

also published progressive cartoons. [48]

That may be true, but the Islamophobe and

racist character is evident and that makes the paper

to garbage, not worth reading.

In those times of amounted racism and Islamophobia

Charlie Hebdo's contribution is:

Hatespeech and provocation.

Therefore it's important to condemn the Charlie Hebdo

attacks, but say no to solidarity

with the paper Charlie Hebdo.



Je ne suis pas Charlie.

I am not Charlie.



Astrid Essed

Amsterdam

The Netherlands





NOTES





[1]



WIKIPEDIA

CHARLIE HEBDO

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Charlie_Hebdo<\/a>

[2]



BBC

GUN ATTACK ON FRENCH MAGAZINE KILLS 12

7 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.bbc.com\/news\/world-europe-30710883<\/a>



WIKIPEDIA

CHARLIE HEBDO SHOOTING

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Charlie_Hebdo_shooting<\/a>



[3]



WIKIPEDIA

INTERNATIONAL REACTIONS TO THE CHARLIE

HEBDO SHOOTING

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/International_reactions_to_the_Charlie_Hebdo_shooting<\/a>

[4]

WIKIPEDIA

INTERNATIONAL REACTIONS TO THE CHARLIE

HEBDO SHOOTING\/NETHERLANDS

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/International_reactions_to_the_Charlie_Hebdo_shooting#Netherlands<\/a>



[5]

WIKIPEDIA

INTERNATIONAL REACTIONS TO THE CHARLIE

HEBDO SHOOTING\/BELGIUM



http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/International_reactions_to_the_Charlie_Hebdo_shooting#Belgium<\/a>



[6]

WIKIPEDIA

INTERNATIONAL REACTIONS TO THE CHARLIE

HEBDO SHOOTING\/INDONESIA



http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/International_reactions_to_the_Charlie_Hebdo_shooting#Indonesia<\/a>



[7]



WIKIPEDIA

INTERNATIONAL REACTIONS TO THE CHARLIE

HEBDO SHOOTING\/IRAN

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/International_reactions_to_the_Charlie_Hebdo_shooting#Iran<\/a>



[8]



RACISM IN THE NETHERLANDS\/PARTY FOR FREEDOM\/PVV,

WILDERS AND THE POISON OF RACISM

ASTRID ESSED

http:\/\/www.indymedia.org.uk\/en\/2014\/03\/515705.html<\/a>



OR

RACISM IN THE NETHERLANDS\/PARTY FOR FREEDOM\/PVV,

WILDERS AND THE POISON OF RACISM

ASTRID ESSED

http:\/\/www.astridessed.nl\/party-for-freedom-pvv-wilders-and-the-poison-of-racism\/<\/a>

A TSUNAMI OF RACISM\/

THE POLITICAL VIEWS OF MR WILDERS

ASTRID ESSED

http:\/\/la.indymedia.org\/news\/2007\/04\/197333.php<\/a>



OR



A TSUNAMI OF RACISM\/

THE POLITICAL VIEWS OF MR WILDERS

ASTRID ESSED



http:\/\/www.astridessed.nl\/2007a-tsunami-of-racismthe-political-views-of-mr-wilders\/<\/a>



[9]



HOW THE FAR-RIGHT AND CONSERVATIVES OF EUROPE

REACTED TO THE CHARLIE HEBDO MASSACRE

8 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.vice.com\/en_uk\/read\/how-europes-conservatives-reacted-to-the-charlie-hebdo-massacre<\/a>



[10]



DAILY MAIL

THE PEN IS MIGHTIER THAN THE SWORD: CARTOONISTS ACROSS

THE WORLD DELIVER A DEFIANT RIPOSTE TO CHARLIE HEBDO

GUNMEN

8 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.dailymail.co.uk\/news\/article-2901459\/jesuisCharlie-world-s-cartoonists-react-Paris-massacre-poignant-drawings.html<\/a>



EURONEWS

THE POWER OF THE PEN: CARTOONISTS WORLDWIDE

REACT TO THE CHARLIE HEBDO ATTACK

8 JANUARY 2015



http:\/\/www.euronews.com\/2015\/01\/08\/cartoonists-respond-to-paris-killings\/<\/a>



[11]



THE TELEGRAPH

PARIS CHARLIE HEBDO ATTACK: SPONTANEOUS RALLIES

OF DEFIANCE SWEEP FRANCE

7 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.telegraph.co.uk\/news\/worldnews\/europe\/france\/11331726\/Paris-Charlie-Hebdo-Attack-Spontaneous-rallies-of-defiance-sweep-France.html<\/a>



[12]

DAILY STAR

MOROCCO SNUBS PARIS MARCH DUE TO PRESENCE

OF PROPHET CARTOONS

11 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.dailystar.com.lb\/News\/Middle-East\/2015\/Jan-11\/283733-morocco-snubs-paris-march-due-to-presence-of-prophet-cartoons.ashx<\/a>



[13]



THE TELEGRAPH

''WE'RE NOT CHARLIE'': FRANCE DIVIDED OVER CHARLIE HEBDO

PROPHET MOHAMMED CARTOONS

18 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.telegraph.co.uk\/news\/worldnews\/europe\/france\/11353689\/Were-not-Charlie-France-divided-over-Charlie-Hebdo-Prophet-Mohammed-cartoons.html<\/a>



[14]

WIKIPEDIA

CHARLIE HEBDO

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Charlie_Hebdo<\/a>



[15]



SEE SOME MOHAMMED CARTOONS

NOS

WAT IS CHARLIE HEBDO

7 JANUARI 2015

TRANSLATION

PRESS SERVICE ''NOS''

WHAT IS CHARLIE HEBDO''

7 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/nos.nl\/artikel\/2012111-wat-is-charlie-hebdo.html<\/a>

IK BEN CHARLIE NIET\/VEROORDELING AANSLAG\/GEEN

SOLIDARITEIT MET RACISTISCH EN ISLAMOFOOB CHARLIE HEBDO

ASTRID ESSED

TRANSLATION

I AM NOT CHARLIE\/CONDEMNATION CHARLIE HEBDO ATTACKS\/NO

SOLIDARITY WITH RACIST AND ISLAMOPHOBE CHARLIE HEBDO

ASTRID ESSED

http:\/\/www.astridessed.nl\/ik-ben-charlie-nietveroordeling-aanslaggeen-solidariteit-met-racistisch-en-islamofoob-charlie-hebdobrief-aan-emile-roemer-sp-fractievoorzitter\/<\/a>



[16]



''The French satirical weekly newspaper Charlie Hebdo was taken to court for publishing the cartoons; it was acquitted of charges that it incited hatred.[109] The incident marked the beginning of a number of violent incidents related the cartoons of Muhammad at the newspaper''

WIKIPEDIA

CHARLIE HEBDO CONTROVERSIES

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Jyllands-Posten_Muhammad_cartoons_controversy#Charlie_Hebdo_controversies<\/a>

BRON

WIKIPEDIA

JYLLANDS POSTEN MOHAMMAD CARTOONS CONTROVERSY

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Jyllands-Posten_Muhammad_cartoons_controversy<\/a>



DANISH CARTOONS: FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION OR LICENCE

TO INSULT

ASTRID ESSED

11 FEBRUARY 2006

http:\/\/www.indymedia.org.uk\/en\/2006\/02\/333450.html<\/a>



[17]

WIKIPEDIA

CHARLIE HEBDO CONTROVERSIES

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Jyllands-Posten_Muhammad_cartoons_controversy#Charlie_Hebdo_controversies<\/a>



DANISH CARTOONS: FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION OR LICENCE

TO INSULT

ASTRID ESSED

11 FEBRUARY 2006

http:\/\/www.indymedia.org.uk\/en\/2006\/02\/333450.html<\/a>



[18]

SEE FOR PORTRAYING THE FRENCH MINISTER OF JUSTICE

AS A MONKEY

MY ARTICLE

IK BEN CHARLIE NIET\/VEROORDELING AANSLAG\/GEEN

SOLIDARITEIT MET RACISTISCH EN ISLAMOFOOB CHARLIE HEBDO

ASTRID ESSED

TRANSLATION

I AM NOT CHARLIE\/CONDEMNATION CHARLIE HEBDO ATTACKS\/NO

SOLIDARITY WITH RACIST AND ISLAMOPHOBE CHARLIE HEBDO

ASTRID ESSED

http:\/\/www.astridessed.nl\/ik-ben-charlie-nietveroordeling-aanslaggeen-solidariteit-met-racistisch-en-islamofoob-charlie-hebdobrief-aan-emile-roemer-sp-fractievoorzitter\/<\/a>



THE MAROON COLONY

JE NE SUIS PAS CHARLIE\/

I AM NOT CHARLIE



http:\/\/themarooncolony.com\/2015\/01\/08\/jenesuispascharlie\/<\/a>



[19]



SEE FOR PORTRAYING THE BOKO HARAM SEX SLAVES WITH

THE RACIST STEREOTYPES:

MY ARTICLE

IK BEN CHARLIE NIET\/VEROORDELING AANSLAG\/GEEN

SOLIDARITEIT MET RACISTISCH EN ISLAMOFOOB CHARLIE HEBDO

ASTRID ESSED

TRANSLATION

I AM NOT CHARLIE\/CONDEMNATION CHARLIE HEBDO ATTACKS\/NO

SOLIDARITY WITH RACIST AND ISLAMOPHOBE CHARLIE HEBDO

ASTRID ESSED

http:\/\/www.astridessed.nl\/ik-ben-charlie-nietveroordeling-aanslaggeen-solidariteit-met-racistisch-en-islamofoob-charlie-hebdobrief-aan-emile-roemer-sp-fractievoorzitter\/<\/a>



[20]

CNN

ARRAY OF WORLD LEADERS JOINS 3,7 MILLION

IN FRANCE TO DEFY TERRORISM

12 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/edition.cnn.com\/2015\/01\/11\/world\/charlie-hebdo-paris-march\/<\/a>

THE TELEGRAPH

UNITY RALLY FOR PARIS SHOOTING: LIVE

11 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.telegraph.co.uk\/news\/worldnews\/europe\/france\/11329976\/Paris-Charlie-Hebdo-attack-live.html<\/a>



[21]

THE GUARDIAN

FRANCE’S BURQA BAN UPHELD BY HUMAN RIGHTS

COURT

1 JULY 2014

http:\/\/www.theguardian.com\/world\/2014\/jul\/01\/france-burqa-ban-upheld-human-rights-court<\/a>



AUSTRALIA NEWS.NET

PARIS CHARLIE HEBDO MARCH: LIVE REPORT

11 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/australia.news.net\/article\/2633012\/paris-charlie-hebdo-march-live-report<\/a>



[22]



PARIS POLICE BAN PRO GAZA DEMONSTRATION

18 JULY 2014

http:\/\/www.english.rfi.fr\/france\/20140718-paris-police-ban-pro-gaza-demonstration<\/a>



[23]

THE HUFFINGTON POST

TODDLER TERROR TRENDS AS TEACHERS FORCED

TO SPY ON MUSLIM CHILDREN

5 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.huffingtonpost.co.uk\/dilly-hussain\/toddlerterror_b_6414000.html<\/a>



[24]

REPORTS: 20 ''NAQBA'' PROTESTERS KILLED

AS ISTRAELI TROOPS ATTACK

15 MAY 2011

http:\/\/news.antiwar.com\/2011\/05\/15\/reports-20-nakba-protesters-killed-as-israeli-troops-attack\/<\/a>



[25]

AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL

TURKEY: DEMONSTRATORS IN TRIAL, POLICE

UNPUNISHED

10 JUNE 2014

http:\/\/www.amnesty.org\/en\/news\/turkey-demonstrators-trial-police-unpunished-2014-06-10<\/a>



[26]



''Due to the large number of Turkish Kurds, successive governments have viewed the expression of a Kurdish identity as a potential threat to Turkish unity, a feeling that has been compounded since the armed rebellion initiated by the PKK in 1984. One of the main accusations of cultural assimilation relates to the state's historic suppression of the Kurdish language. Kurdish publications created throughout the 1960s and 1970s were shut down under various legal pretexts.[5] Following the military coup of 1980, the Kurdish language was officially prohibited in government institutions''

WIKIPEDIA

HUMAN RIGHTS OF KURDISH PEOPLE IN TURKEY

MULTICULTURALISM, ASSIMILATION

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Human_rights_of_Kurdish_people_in_Turkey#Multiculturalism.2C_Assimilation<\/a>



SOURCE

WIKIPEDIA

HUMAN RIGHTS OF KURDISH PEOPLE IN TURKEY

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Human_rights_of_Kurdish_people_in_Turkey<\/a>



[27]

HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH

SPAIN: FLAWED PUBLIC SECURITY BILL

24 NOVEMBER 2014

http:\/\/www.hrw.org\/news\/2014\/11\/24\/spain-flawed-public-security-bill<\/a>



[28]

DAILY MAIL

THOUSANDS MARCH IN CITIES ACROSS PAKISTAN IN

PROTEST AGAINST CHARLIE HEBDO FOR PUBLISHING

CARTOONS OF PROPHET MOHAMMED

25 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.dailymail.co.uk\/news\/article-2925796\/Thousands-march-cities-Parkistan-protest-against-Charlie-Hebdo-publishing-cartoons-Prophet-Mohammed.html<\/a>



THE GUARDIAN

CHECHENS PROTEST AGAINST CHARLIE HEBDO CARTOONS

http:\/\/www.theguardian.com\/world\/2015\/jan\/19\/chechens-protest-charlie-hebdo-cartoons-grozny<\/a>



REUTERS

THOUSANDS OF PALESTINIANS PROTEST

CHARLIE HEBDO CARTOON

24 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.reuters.com\/article\/2015\/01\/24\/us-france-shooting-palestinians-idUSKBN0KX0M920150124<\/a>



[29]

HURRIYET DAILY NEWS.COM

PARIS POLICE BAN ANTI ISLAM FILM DEMO

NEAR GRAND MOSQUE

http:\/\/www.hurriyetdailynews.com\/paris-police-ban-anti-islam-film-demo-near-grand-mosque.aspx?pageID=238&nID=30573&NewsCatID=351<\/a>



[30]



THE TELEGRAPH

CHARLIE HEBDO'S WEDNESDAY EDITION TO INCLUDE

PROPHET MOHAMMED CARTOONS

13 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.telegraph.co.uk\/news\/worldnews\/europe\/france\/11340358\/Charlie-Hebdos-Wednesday-edition-to-include-Prophet-Mohammed-cartoons.html<\/a>

''January 14

Charlie Hebdo publishes 3 million copies of new edition showing Prophet Mohammed holding 'Je Suis Charlie' sign''

THE TELEGRAPH

PROPHET MOHAMMED CARTOONS CONTROVERSY:

TIMELINE

http:\/\/www.telegraph.co.uk\/news\/worldnews\/europe\/france\/11341599\/Prophet-Muhammad-cartoons-controversy-timeline.html<\/a>

''The day after the attack, the remaining staff of Charlie Hebdo announced that publication would continue, with the following week's edition of the newspaper to be published according to the usual schedule with a print run of one million copies, up significantly from its usual 60,000''

WIKIPEDIA

CHARLIE HEBDO

THE ''SURVIVORS'' ISSUE

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Charlie_Hebdo#The_.22survivors.27_issue.22<\/a>

SOURCE

WIKIPEDIA

CHARLIE HEBDO

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Charlie_Hebdo<\/a>

[31]

THE TELEGRAPH

CHARLIE HEBDO'S WEDNESDAY EDITION TO INCLUDE

PROPHET MOHAMMED CARTOONS

13 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.telegraph.co.uk\/news\/worldnews\/europe\/france\/11340358\/Charlie-Hebdos-Wednesday-edition-to-include-Prophet-Mohammed-cartoons.html<\/a>



[32]



THE DAILY MAIL

COPIES OF NEW CHARLIE HEBDO MAGAZINE CHANGE HANDS FOR HUNDREDS OF

POUNDS AS IT SELLS OUT IN PARIS WIITHIN AN HOUR\/AND PUBLISHERS

INCREASE ITS PRINT RUN TO FIVE MIILLION

http:\/\/www.dailymail.co.uk\/news\/article-2909537\/Charlie-Hebdo-sells-shops-France-hour-latest-edition-featuring-cover-weeping-Mohammed-going-sale.html<\/a>



[33]

THE DAILY BEAST

AFTER CHARLIE HEBDO ATTACKS, FRENCH MUSLIMS

FACE INCREASED THREATS

25 JANUARY 2015



http:\/\/www.thedailybeast.com\/articles\/2015\/01\/25\/after-charlie-hebdo-attacks-french-muslims-face-increased-threats.html<\/a>

LE PARISIEN

INTERACTIF: 116 ACTES ANTIMUSULMANS EN FRANCE

DEPUIS L’ATTENTAT CONTRE CHARLIE HEBDO

19 JANVIER 2015

http:\/\/www.leparisien.fr\/faits-divers\/116-actes-antimusulmans-en-france-depuis-l-attentat-contre-charlie-hebdo-19-01-2015-4460047.php#xtref=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.parool.nl%2Fparool%2Fnl%2F225%2FBUITENLAND%2Farticle%2Fdetail%2F3833026%2F2015%2F01%2F19%2FZeker-honderd-antimoslimacties-in-Frankrijk-na-aanslagen.dhtml<\/a>

[34]

THE INDEPENDENT

MOROCCAN MAN IN FRANCE KILLED AT HOME IN FRANCE IN

''HORRIBLE ISLAMOPHOBIC ATTACK''

http:\/\/www.independent.co.uk\/news\/world\/europe\/moroccan-man-in-france-killed-at-home-in-front-of-wife-by-intruder-shouting-about-islam-9985072.html<\/a>



[35]

WIKIPEDIA

SURINAME

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Suriname<\/a>

[36]

TIME

MUSLIM HERO OF JEWISH SUPERMARKET

WILL BE GIVEN FRENCH CITIZENSHIP

15 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/time.com\/3669230\/paris-terror-attack-charlie-hebdo-lassana-bathily\/<\/a>



''Communiqué de presse de Bernard Cazeneuve du jeudi 15 janvier 2015

Au lendemain de l’acte de bravoure de M. Lassana BATHILY, né en 1990 à Bamako (Mali), lors de la prise d’otage du magasin « Hyper Casher » le 9 janvier dernier, le Ministre de l’Intérieur a demandé l’instruction en urgence de la demande de naturalisation qu’il avait déposée le 7 juillet 2014.

M. Bernard CAZENEUVE présidera en son honneur une cérémonie d’accueil dans la citoyenneté française mardi 20 janvier à 18h30, Place Beauvau.''

MINISTERE DE L'INTERIEUR

DEMANDE DE NATURALISATION DE LASSANA

BATHILY

15 JANVIER 2015

http:\/\/www.interieur.gouv.fr\/Presse\/Les-communiques\/Demande-de-naturalisation-de-Lassana-Bathily<\/a>

[37]

BBC NEWS

FRANCE ATTACKS: ''HERO'' LASSANA GETS CITIZENSHIP

20 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.bbc.com\/news\/world-europe-30905262<\/a>



[38]



REUTERS.COM

MALIAN WHO SAVES LIVES IN JEWISH DELI

ATTACKS GETS FRENCH NATIONALITY

15 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.reuters.com\/article\/2015\/01\/15\/us-france-shooting-mali-idUSKBN0KO1WQ20150115<\/a>



[39]



LATVIAN PRESIDENCY

OF THE COUNCIL OF THE

EUROPEAN UNION

KOZLOVSKIS:

FIGHTING TERRORISM REQUIRES IMMEDIATE

ACTION

MEDIA RELEASE

11 JANUARY 2015

https:\/\/eu2015.lv\/news\/media-releases\/237-kozlovskis-fighting-terrorism-requires-immediate-action<\/a>



JOINT STATEMENT OF MINISTERS FOR INTERIOR

https:\/\/eu2015.lv\/images\/news\/2015_01_11_Joint_statement_of_ministers_for_interrior.pdf<\/a>

[40]

LATVIAN PRESIDENCY

OF THE COUNCIL OF THE

EUROPEAN UNION

KOZLOVSKIS:

FIGHTING TERRORISM REQUIRES IMMEDIATE

ACTION

MEDIA RELEASE

11 JANUARY 2015

https:\/\/eu2015.lv\/news\/media-releases\/237-kozlovskis-fighting-terrorism-requires-immediate-action<\/a>



JOINT STATEMENT OF MINISTERS FOR INTERIOR

https:\/\/eu2015.lv\/images\/news\/2015_01_11_Joint_statement_of_ministers_for_interrior.pdf<\/a>



[41]



ANTI-TERRORIST MEASURES IN EU GO IN ALL DIRECTIONS

16 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.euractiv.com\/sections\/global-europe\/national-anti-terrorist-measures-eu-go-all-directions-311343<\/a>



[42]



WIKIPEDIA

DYAB ABU JAHJAH

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Dyab_Abou_Jahjah<\/a>



[43]



WIKIPEDIA

ARAB EUROPEAN LEAGUE

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Arab_European_League<\/a>



[44]



LETTERS FROM BRUSSELS

AT GUNPOINT

UNDER MY OWN WINDOW

DYAB ABOU JAHJAH

11 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.aboujahjah.org\/articles-and-blog\/fri-jan-16-2015<\/a>



[45]



THE NETHERLANDS MARKS THEO VAN GOGH MURDER\/

AN ISLAMOPHOBE AND ANTISEMITE IS NOT A SAINT

ASTRID ESSED

http:\/\/www.astridessed.nl\/the-netherlands-marks-theo-van-gogh-murderan-islamophobe-and-antisemite-is-not-a-saint\/<\/a>



DE FABEL VAN DE ILLEGAAL

VAN GOGH WAS AN IRRITATING REACTIONARY LITTLE MAN

ERIC KREBBERS

JANUARY\/FEBRUARY 2005

http:\/\/www.doorbraak.eu\/gebladerte\/30097v01.htm<\/a>

WIKIPEDIA

PIM FORTUYN

VIEWS ON ISLAM AND IMMIGRATION

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Pim_Fortuyn#Views_on_Islam_and_immigration<\/a>



Source

WIKIPEDIA

PIM FORTUYN

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Pim_Fortuyn<\/a>



´´He called Islam “a backward culture”, and said that if it were legally possible he would close the borders for Muslim immigrants.[2]´´



WIKIPEDIA

PIM FORTUYN

http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Pim_Fortuyn<\/a>





THE GUARDIAN

PIM FORTUYN-OBITUARY

7 MAY 2002

http:\/\/www.theguardian.com\/news\/2002\/may\/07\/guardianobituaries.thefarright<\/a>



[46]

THE TELEGRAPH

CHARLIE HEBDO'S WEDNESDAY EDITION TO INCLUDE

PROPHET MOHAMMED CARTOONS

13 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.telegraph.co.uk\/news\/worldnews\/europe\/france\/11340358\/Charlie-Hebdos-Wednesday-edition-to-include-Prophet-Mohammed-cartoons.html<\/a>





[47]



SEE FOR PORTRAYING THE FRENCH MINISTER OF JUSTICE

AS A MONKEY

MY ARTICLE

IK BEN CHARLIE NIET\/VEROORDELING AANSLAG\/GEEN

SOLIDARITEIT MET RACISTISCH EN ISLAMOFOOB CHARLIE HEBDO

ASTRID ESSED

TRANSLATION

I AM NOT CHARLIE\/CONDEMNATION CHARLIE HEBDO ATTACKS\/NO

SOLIDARITY WITH RACIST AND ISLAMOPHOBE CHARLIE HEBDO

ASTRID ESSED

http:\/\/www.astridessed.nl\/ik-ben-charlie-nietveroordeling-aanslaggeen-solidariteit-met-racistisch-en-islamofoob-charlie-hebdobrief-aan-emile-roemer-sp-fractievoorzitter\/<\/a>



THE MAROON COLONY

JE NE SUIS PAS CHARLIE\/

I AM NOT CHARLIE



http:\/\/themarooncolony.com\/2015\/01\/08\/jenesuispascharlie\/<\/a>



[48]



DAILYKOS.COM

THE CHARLIE HEBDO CARTOONS NO ONE IS SHOWING YOU

11 JANUARY 2015

http:\/\/www.dailykos.com\/story\/2015\/01\/11\/1357057\/-The-Charlie-Hebdo-cartoons-no-one-is-showing-you?detail=email#<\/a>\n","contact":"","link":"","address":"","phone":"","parent_id":0,"mime_type":"text\/plain","summary":"Of course there is no justification for the attacks on Charlie Hebdo, which \r\ncosted the lives of twelve people. However, there is no reason at all to show\r\nsolidarity with Charlie Hebdo, being racist and Islamophobe. \r\nYes to condemnation of the attacks, no to Charlie Hebdo hate speech.\r\nI am not Charlie","numcomment":0,"fileurl":"\/uploads\/","filesize":null,"article_url":"\/news\/2015\/01\/267213.php"},"attachments":[],"comments":[]}