{"article":{"id":66943,"heading":"In the midst of Imperialist oppression-Irag","author":"Roberto Sarti","created":"2003-06-25 17:18:47","modified":"2013-11-11 00:23:19","last_modified":"Mon, 11 Nov 2013 07:23:19","article":"

In Defense of Marxism-http:\/\/www.marxist.com<\/a>

Workers International League-http:\/\/www.socialistappeal.org<\/a>

In the midst of imperialist oppression

The Iraqi Communist tradition is still alive



As the US discusses the future of Iraq with its friends and allies from all over the world, the opposition movement to US occupation is growing and within this the old Communist traditions are once again beginning to take root. It is not just Islamic fundamentalism that is growing in post-war Iraq.

By Roberto Sarti



Over the weekend more than 1,000 businessmen and political leaders from all over the world gathered in Jordan for a meeting of the World Economic Forum to discuss the situation after the latest Gulf War. Every speech was full of plenty of promises as usual of a brighter future for the Iraqi people and the entire Middle East.

However when the US governor of Iraq Paul Bremer stood up and began to explain the US's plans for the reconstruction of post-war Iraq, probably most of the Arab rulers presented started shivering in their boots at the prospect of what is to come.

The changes, according to Bremer, will include introducing new property rights and anti-trust laws, cutting subsidies, opening up the country to trade and foreign investment and privatising government run businesses.

\"I want to say to them (the businessmen) that I am optimistic that the coalition will succeed in transforming the Iraqi economy from a closed, dead-end system to an open vibrant place to do business,\" said Bremer. \"Without the discipline of the market, state-owned enterprises not only failed to create value, they destroyed it,\" he added. (Source: http:\/\/ipsnews.net<\/a>). In this \"free market\", as we have already commented, those who will take the whole of the cake will be \"the best competitors\", i.e. US companies.

Of course, Bremer does not ignore the fact that there will be some problems \"The negative impact of the transition on workers and pensioners, who may be affected by the closure of certain state-owned firms, will be cushioned by Iraq's oil revenues\", he added.

But how will Iraqis be able to benefit from these revenues, if even the state run oil company is going to be privatised? Probably what Bremer really means (but doesn't say openly) is that only some of crumbs will go to them. It is clear that after the military war, the Americans are preparing an economic war, a class war that will affect millions of Iraqis for many years to come.

That is why the Arab rulers are very worried. This is not because these bourgeois have a more \"humanitarian\" approach. What they fear are the consequences of the opening up of the class struggle and of a war of national liberation in Iraq that could spread to their own bordering countries. They also fear that the methods being applied by the US in Iraq could be used against them if they dare to break the rules dictated by Washington.

Demonstrations and guerrilla attacks are growing

Despite the US administration's desires it is becoming ever clearer that reconstruction is not going according to plan. Not only are the basic services still seriously damaged, the delays are now also affecting the oil trade.

Iraq in fact resumed limited oil sales on Sunday from storage tanks at the port of Ceyhan in Turkey - the first Iraqi oil exports since the US-led invasion began on March 20. But on Monday morning an explosion hit a fuel pipeline near Iraq's border with Syria. There was another blast at a pipeline in the northern town of Hit on Saturday. The US have already classified it as an \"act of sabotage\".

The result of this bomb attacks is that now Iraqi officials are saying they will not be able to start pumping oil from the northern fields of Kirkuk to Ceyhan because the pipeline remains damaged. The interesting point is that the population is not coming out against these attacks. A common refrain among ordinary Iraqis is, \"if they want to steal our oil, it is better to destroy it.\"

So the guerrilla attacks have not been stopped after last week's clampdown of the US armed forces. On the contrary, they have grown in intensity and now for the first time organised groups are appearing on the scene, such as the previously unknown group, calling itself the Iraqi National Front of Fedayeen. In a video only released last Saturday, this organisation vowed to intensify its assaults on US troops until they leave Iraq. And on Friday in Baghdad 20,000 people gathered in front of US Forces central command protesting against the lack of water and electricity.

Despite the fact that in Iraq there are more than 200,000 \"allied\" troops what we see emerging is a clear vacuum of power. The US have destroyed the old Saddam state apparatus but they have not yet found anything to replace it with. In some areas Shiite militias are filling the vacuum, but in some cities the situation is not so favourable to the fundamentalists.

Nassiryia is a town of more than 1,200,000 people, mostly Shiite. This is where one of the most bitter battles in the Iraq war took place. But it is also a town of great militant traditions. Here the Iraqi Communist Party in 1958 got more than 60% of the votes (see our previous article). Under Saddam Hussein, many left and religious leaders paid for their opposition to the regime with their lives

A high-ranking city dignitary recently explained something that reveal the potential for the left in Iraq. Talking to a journalist from the Italian left wing daily \"il Manifesto\" he said that, \" The Communist Party should take the situation into its own hands, take the arms and stop all the thieves. Instead they are all sitting in their Party headquarters, what are they waiting for?\"

The Italian journalist reveals all her reformist prejudices, when she points out to the same official, \" but if all the political parties were armed, there would be a civil war!\" The official reproaches her by explaining that, \" I am not talking about all the parties, I am talking about the Communist Party, and here if they launched a demand everybody would follow. Here nobody follows the Islamists. This is the city of Fahed al-Khaled, the founder of the Communist Party\"(\"il Manifesto\", 22\/06\/2003)

Unfortunately the Iraqi Communist party leaders have no intention of follow this advice. The Communist Party Secretary, Said Sahib el Hossuna, only recently returned from a long exile in Syria, explained in the same article that, \"Everyone is against the occupation, but the occupation is a fact. When we will have a government, then it will be the time when we can negotiate peacefully their [the US's] departure\".

This is a completely legalistic attitude! \"When we will have a government!\" He ignores the fact that any government that the US will allow to exist will only be a puppet government. The only real people's government that could exist is one where the American will have been forced out of the country, and only the masses can fulfill this task.

So now the immediate task is to build workers' and people's councils with the immediate aim of driving the US out of Iraq and allowing the working people of Iraq to rule their own country for themselves.

The fact that this is entirely possible in today's Iraq is shown in another part of the article. All the political parties in Nassiryia have established a joint coordinating committee and have appointed a candidate for the post of Governor, Taklif Mohammed al-Manshaad. He is a secular leader, just returned from London. In the same article he is quoted as saying that, \"If the coalition forces ask us to set up a force to guarantee security, we could do it within seven days, and this would guarantee peace and security throughout the entire province, even for the future\" (\"il Manifesto\", 22\/06\/2003) In other words, ‘we could take power, but we don't want to'! We wait for the US's kind permission.

The attitude of these leaders reminds us of the attitude of the Communist and the Socialist Party leaders in Italy at the end of the Second World War. They had enormous forces at their disposal. There were 300,000 armed partisans, mainly in Northern Italy. The bourgeoise state had collapsed. Instead of taking this historical opportunity to drive on and snuff out capitalism, they waited and collaborated with the US and UK armed forces (they entered a government of national unity with the Christian Democrats) to re-establish bourgeois power, an Army and a police force. Eventually the Christian Democrats, backed and advised by US imperialism, thanked the left parties for their \"help\" by kicking them out of government once they were no longer of any need and the mass movement had calmed down! That was followed by years of repression and retreats for the Italian working class that lasted throughout the 1950s and a large part of the 1960s and only really came to an end with the workers' movement of the late 1960s.

If the present Iraqi Communist Party leaders do not change course they could contribute to a similar fate for the workers of Iraq today. The workers and youth of Iraq are thirsting for radical change. Saddam has gone, but that is not enough for them. They now want genuine control over their lives, and in particular they want to see the backs of the US imperialists.

As we can see the imperialist intervention in Iraq, far from solving any problem, has set the whole region on fire, as is clear from the latest events in neighbouring Iran. Iran is not the only country where such mass protests have been taking place. The potential for such movements exists right across the whole of the Middle East and beyond. Huge opportunities are opening up for the masses in this part of the world.

However, the potential fort such movements is not enough to change society in a fundamental way. The lessons of the past must be absorbed by today's worker and student activists. This is the first task for today's revolutionaries.

June 23, 2003.

<\/p>\n","contact":"","link":"www.marxist.com","address":"","phone":"","parent_id":0,"mime_type":"text\/plain","summary":"Irag","numcomment":27,"fileurl":"\/uploads\/","filesize":null,"article_url":"\/news\/2003\/06\/66943.php"},"attachments":[],"comments":[{"id":66966,"heading":"Saddam and the Communists","article":" One ironic thing is that some of the ultra anti-communists who "contribute" to this board with their expressions of hatred for Saddam don't seem to realize that he shares their anti-communist views and spent much of his career locking up Marxists of all types. The ultimate irony would be if, after the US is finally driven out by a politically unacceptable casualty rate, a communist government quickly replaced the US puppet regime, as happened in South Vietnam. As they used to say on that 1950's television show, "you asked for it."","author":"Meyer London","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-25 20:40:47","modified":"2003-06-25 20:40:47","fileurl":""},{"id":66969,"heading":"Well, gosh...","article":"...if Saddam is anti-commie, we shouldn't have got rid of him!\r\n\r\nWait a minute...if he's anti-Communist, Meyer, why do you support him so much?\r\n\r\n"Workers International League...This Time, It'll Work! Really! We Swear!"","author":"daveman","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-25 20:47:16","modified":"2003-06-25 20:47:16","fileurl":""},{"id":66983,"heading":"Did you all see fox news on the Blix report?","article":"They said it looks like Saddam was telling the Truth after all.....","author":"daveman","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-25 22:01:18","modified":"2003-06-25 22:01:18","fileurl":""},{"id":67044,"heading":"gutless coward","article":"Post under your own name, child.","author":"daveman","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 08:24:47","modified":"2003-06-26 08:24:47","fileurl":""},{"id":67051,"heading":"George Bush said it best:","article":""(A)ll the decades of deceit and cruelty have now reached an end." \r\n\r\nHe said there would be "no more wars of aggression against your neighbors, no more poison factories, no more executions of dissidents, no more torture chambers and rape rooms. \r\n\r\nThe tyrant will soon be gone. The day of your liberation is near." \r\n\r\nForesight that is 20-20.\r\n","author":"Eric","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 10:39:32","modified":"2003-06-26 10:39:32","fileurl":""},{"id":67077,"heading":"Eric","article":"Thanks for licking my boots, Eric. I'll send some of that CIA nosecandy your way.","author":"George W. Bush","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 12:26:48","modified":"2003-06-26 12:26:48","fileurl":""},{"id":67084,"heading":"Defending Anything","article":" Sometimes I think that if George Bush broke into the homes of Daveman and Eric, assaulted their families, and stole their most prized possessions, they would still find some grounds upon which to defend him. If only Willie Horton was a white guy who happened to be a Republican President. He would have had it made.","author":"Meyer London","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 12:57:31","modified":"2003-06-26 12:57:31","fileurl":""},{"id":67086,"heading":"This country","article":"This country was deprived of leadership for 8 long years. We're starved for it. Now we've got it. Thank the good Lord.","author":"Eric","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 13:02:49","modified":"2003-06-26 13:02:49","fileurl":""},{"id":67099,"heading":"Thank the Good Lord for Bush","article":" Now really, Eric. The Good Lord has aready been blamed for permitting slavery, the Holocaust, AIDS, World Wars I and II, and earthquakes. Now you are going to blame the poor guy for Bush, too?","author":"Meyer London","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 13:59:20","modified":"2003-06-26 13:59:20","fileurl":""},{"id":67110,"heading":"Deprived?","article":"By 'deprived of leadership', do you mean not recklessly endandering the safety of the entire global community in order to 'lead' his buddies to oil?","author":"Brian OConnor","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 14:31:19","modified":"2003-06-26 14:31:19","fileurl":""},{"id":67113,"heading":"No by deprived I mean...","article":"8 years of womanizing, pandering, and misanthropic behaviour, instead of paying attention to American interests. \r\n\r\n8 years of locking this country up in one scandal after the next, culminating in impeachment and censureship.\r\n\r\n8 years of slick willy clinton. \r\n\r\nYou wanna know why GWB is so popular?\r\n\r\nIt's because YOU leftists are soooo unpopular.","author":"Eric","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 14:40:28","modified":"2003-06-26 14:40:28","fileurl":""},{"id":67115,"heading":"Twisted view of things","article":"How is Iraqi oil an 'American' interest?\r\n\r\nIt was the US Senate, led by the GOP, that blockaded the passage of significant legislation. Remember when Clinton shut down D.C.?\r\n\r\nCare to spin any more lies?","author":"Brian OConnor","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 14:44:48","modified":"2003-06-26 14:44:48","fileurl":""},{"id":67117,"heading":""significant legislation"","article":"What are you talking about. Clinton shut down the government. Period. \r\n\r\nhttp:\/\/www.empoweramerica.org\/stories\/storyReader$280?print-friendly=true\r\n\r\n"Remember back in 1995 when the president used his veto to close down the government in a fit of pique because Congress would not give him all the new spending he demanded? That was another form of extortion. Not only did he hold the entire capital city hostage during a blizzard (few other people in the country outside the Washington, D.C., area even knew the government had shut down), but he blatantly distorted the truth about who really caused the shutdown. I paraphrase the president: "I did not shut down this government, not a single time, never. Congress did, and I need to go back to work." Since Bill Clinton is so masterful with words, and most of the country wasn't paying much attention anyway, most people believed him that Congress, not he, had shut down the government. "\r\n\r\nYou liberals function entirely in your own realm of logical fallacy.\r\n\r\n","author":"Eric","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 14:54:44","modified":"2003-06-26 14:54:44","fileurl":""},{"id":67118,"heading":"Let's clarify things.","article":"Clinton = Corrupt WOMANIZING scumbag.\r\n\r\nBush = Corrupt MURDERING scumbag.\r\n\r\nI just love my caps key - it really helps bring things into perspective.\r\n\r\nYa wanna' know why the NeoCONs rarely bring up Kosovo? It was almost as big a war crime as Iraq since again it was to protect the Drug Trade in which the Bush-Clinton people are involved in up to their NOSES. And as well it was to gain control of the Trepka Mining Complex - worth at a minimum 1.5 TRILLION Dollars (possiby 3 times that depending upon whose estimates you use).\r\n\r\nWhether Clinton or Bush is worse is really a moot point. They were both CRIMINALLY CORRUPT. \r\n\r\nA little observed fact is that Clinton was Governor of Arkansas when Oliver North was running Drugs and Guns through Mena Airport in ARKANSAS.\r\n\r\nClinton twice went up to visit Godfather George in his Kennebunkport Compound during his run for the pResidency.\r\n\r\nClinton and Bush are tied together back into Clinton's Arkansas Days.\r\n\r\nAs well a lot of people around Billy Bob had strange and unfortunate "accidents". They even termed it "Arkicide".\r\n\r\nThe Bush people are little better at Whacking their opposition but they have had inconvienient people go to an early Grave as well.\r\n\r\nWake up people. Both Major Parties are currently run by criminals.","author":"Diogenes","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 14:57:15","modified":"2003-06-26 14:57:15","fileurl":""},{"id":67120,"heading":"Let\u2019s clarify things.","article":"I\u2019m NOT a NEOCON. \r\n\r\nNeocons are liberals in conservative clothing. Neocons are libertarians. Neocons are YOU, Diogenes.\r\n\r\nI\u2019m a conservative. Sort of a social conservative I suppose. But definitely 100% pure unadulterated conservatism. That\u2019s me.\r\n\r\nAs far as the parties being run by criminals, I\u2019d agree that there are criminals in BOTH parties. But we\u2019ve got to choose and I choose the lesser of two evils. Don\u2019t give me that crap about your ill-fated third party libertarianist aspirations. You\u2019re kidding yourself. I want to SEE leadership when I watch my Fox News at night. I wanna see the Chief with a bullhorn down at ground zero. I wanna see the prez landing his fighter jet on an aircraft carrier.\r\n\r\nI do not wanna see some puffed up bloated scowl grimacing out about not having sexual relations and what\u2019s your defining of \u201csex\u201d.\r\n","author":"Eric","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 15:05:17","modified":"2013-11-11 00:23:20","fileurl":""},{"id":67123,"heading":"Let's call a spade a spade","article":""I\u2019m NOT a NEOCON"\r\nWe know, you are a paid government phyops damage control\r\nword chipper. You would serve any master.","author":"Sheepdog","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 15:16:14","modified":"2013-11-11 00:23:20","fileurl":""},{"id":67126,"heading":"Do you honestly believe","article":"that you can BUY passion like mine??\r\n\r\nIf you could buy me, you'd be broke. The gov't doesn't have enough of YOUR tax dollars to pay me to do what I do, and say what I say. The govt has as much to fear from me as do fifth columnists. Because should I EVER believe the system is lost, I will be lost to the system. And I'd RAIL against it ever day until the legs came out from under.\r\n\r\nI don't say what I say because I'm paid. YOU may be paid, but I am not.\r\n\r\nI say what I say, because I believe in America. The concept of neighbors enjoying a free and endowed life. In a clean town in the burbs. Where people have choices.\r\n\r\nNot one where lives and choices are dictated.\r\n\r\nFreedom is a powerful word for me.","author":"Eric","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 15:27:20","modified":"2003-06-26 15:27:20","fileurl":""},{"id":67147,"heading":"REgurgitation","article":"I find it comical that Eric defends Shrub and attacks Clinton. While I believe that the majority of politicos are corrupt, at least Clinton could maintain the IMAGE of being peace-loving. Shrub couldn't sell drinking water in a drought. Clinton at least put up the appearance of protecting civil rights, while Ashcroft and the Lynch Mob don't even pretend!\r\n\r\nThe only politicos who obviously were not corrupt, Paul Wellstone, JFK, Jr. and Mel Shanahan, were all assassinated in small plane crashes. Guidance beacons in MN were found to have been altered in the Wellstone crash. The calibration had been recently changed before the crash. This is how the killed JFK, Jr. and the Senator from MO.","author":"Brian OConnor","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 16:17:54","modified":"2003-06-26 16:17:54","fileurl":""},{"id":67149,"heading":"blah","article":"Clinton maintained his image of being peace loving by mainting his image of being incompetent.\r\n\r\nAnd "Shrub" has sold us something entirely more precious: "Competent Leadership"\r\n\r\nThat's something we'll probably never see again in our lifetimes from a leftist.","author":"Eric","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 16:26:02","modified":"2003-06-26 16:26:02","fileurl":""},{"id":67189,"heading":"landing his fighter on a carrier","article":" Bush did not land a fighter on a carrier; he was a passenger in the back seat of a plane that was eating up thousands of dollars worth of taxpayer-bought fuel on a publicity stunt. And what was he doing with the bullhorn? Trying to raise the dead? Calling the cameramen so they could get another publicity shot?","author":"Meyer London","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 19:22:17","modified":"2003-06-26 19:22:17","fileurl":""},{"id":67231,"heading":"If you're having a cow...","article":"...over a few hundred gallons of jet fuel, wait 'til you find out what an aircraft carrier costs per hour to run.\r\n\r\nAvoid caffeine first, though...you're liable to have a stroke.","author":"daveman","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 22:56:09","modified":"2003-06-26 22:56:09","fileurl":""},{"id":67233,"heading":"many farthings","article":"I bet it would fully pay for about 15 modern hospitals\r\nand staff. ","author":"parent with children","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-26 23:16:45","modified":"2003-06-26 23:16:45","fileurl":""},{"id":67292,"heading":"Meyer's just pissed.","article":"Because there's not a candidate on the left that can even compare to our incumbent President, not to mention depose him. These liberals hate to hear us sing our praises for GWB; it's like blowing a dog whistle at the SPCA. And all I hear are howls!!","author":"Eric","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-27 09:29:05","modified":"2003-06-27 09:29:05","fileurl":""},{"id":67312,"heading":"Logical Fallacy","article":""...there's not a candidate on the left that can even compare to our incumbent President, not to mention depose him."\r\n\r\nUnsubstantiated Allegation\r\nFor more on logic at your level, try reading "Logic for Dummies."","author":"debate coach","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-27 10:55:17","modified":"2003-06-27 10:55:17","fileurl":""},{"id":67404,"heading":"What Shrub has accomplished","article":"Daveman\/Eric's idea of 'leadership':","author":"Brian OConnor","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"image\/jpeg","created":"2003-06-27 14:21:21","modified":"2005-08-15 01:33:46","fileurl":"\/usr\/local\/www-domains\/la.indymedia.org\/public\/uploads\/2003\/06\/bloodman.jpgi5dfev.jpg","image":{"original":"\/usr\/local\/www-domains\/la.indymedia.org\/public\/uploads\/2003\/06\/bloodman.jpgi5dfev.jpg"}},{"id":67410,"heading":"They cops should arrest that freak","article":"in the green cammies for pouring fake blood all over the sidewalk like that and littering the streets that my tax dollars go towards building.","author":"Eric","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-27 14:25:55","modified":"2003-06-27 14:25:55","fileurl":""},{"id":67457,"heading":"iraq to the iraqis","article":"nothing against privatisation - as long as it's iraqi firms who get all the recontruction + oil deals...","author":"iraq to the iraqis","parent_id":66943,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2003-06-27 16:31:08","modified":"2003-06-27 16:31:08","fileurl":""}]}