{"article":{"id":6170,"heading":"more on the \"pacifist\" left","author":"t.","created":"2001-04-24 19:29:26","modified":"2005-08-15 00:32:38","last_modified":"Mon, 15 Aug 2005 08:32:38","article":"<p>there's  a lot of bashing of san diego organizers going on, so i wanted <br>  <br> to point out a few things: <br><br> 1) \"the organizers\" is a very very broad term.  anyone who went to a san <br>  <br> diego coalition meeting saw that the organizers were not at all unified <br>  <br> on quite a few issues, especially the one of civil disobedience and <br>  <br> direct action.  so to say \"fuck the organizers\" is very shortsighted, <br>  <br> because a lot of the organizers are totally down for the bloc and <br>  <br> direct action. <br><br> 2) i was in the interesting position of both being one of the organizers <br>  <br> and in the bloc... quite a few of the \"harmony keepers\" were black <br>  <br> bloc kids who decided to be harmony keepers since they were so sick <br>  <br> of peackeepers who were anti-bloc... harmony keepers were giving the <br>  <br> bloc all the information we had about police presence, logistics, the <br>  <br> legal situation, the medical situation, etc. we got legal observers and <br>  <br> medics for the march (when it was going to be just the bloc and rcpyb), <br>  <br> and stickers to put on bandanas when the cops were threatening to arrest <br>  <br> people for wearing masks.   on the march back, the cops told the police <br>  <br> liason, \"i like you, stay away from the black bloc\" ... so she came <br>  <br> running over to tell us this, and started telling everyone else to stay <br>  <br> near us.  on the march to the border, the people had one lane and the <br>  <br> cops had the other, and when the police started to try to come into our <br>  <br> lane and push us further south, she went up to the cops and said \"hey, <br>  <br> get back in your own lane!\"  then one of the black bloc kids pushed her <br>  <br> and called her a fucking cop.  this is the same girl who is quoted in <br>  <br> the indymedia article as telling us that we have to wait till 2:30 to <br>  <br> leave... she actually said that we should wait till art and revolution <br>  <br> was ready to come with us (about 1 minute)... and someone in the bloc <br>  <br> yelled \"yeah, there's strength in numbers\" and we left on the march <br>  <br> when art and rev. was ready.  now, i don't know if any of you who were <br>  <br> calling her a cop or a liberal or whatever, and making all sorts of <br>  <br> assumptions about her because she was an organizer noticed this, but <br>  <br> she can't move her neck.  this is 'cuz she got beat up at a16 trying to <br>  <br> block a jail van with her a.g... this is someone who is totally down for  <br>  <br> the bloc and direct action, but was attacked and criticized because she <br>  <br>  was an organizer, and they assumed that automatically means that  <br>  <br> she is a liberal. <br><br> 3) i don't know where the idea that there was a march that was cancelled <br>  <br> came from... the original plan was to drive to border field state park, <br>  <br> but that got cancelled because the road washed out.  there was never a <br>  <br> cancelled march. <br><br>  4) jumping back to the divisions withint he coalition,  the story behind <br>  <br>  the action guidelines is this: <br><br> there's an organization called la red de globalfobicos, which, we found <br>  <br> out later, was formed by global exchange, who came down to tijuana and <br>  <br> handpicked which nice little liberal groups and people they want to <br>  <br> work with.  (global exchange are also the ones who called this action <br>  <br> without talking to anyone from san diego or tijuana first, by the way...) <br>  <br> so anyway... the san diego coalition meetings were 4 hour long fights over <br>  <br> things like consensus vs. voting, spokescouncil vs. stacking meetings, <br>  <br> etc.  the globalfobics are claiming to speak for all of mexico, the <br>  <br> iso is bringing 7-10 members to every meeting and trying to sell papers <br>  <br> afterward, and youth and radicals in the coalition are being yelled at and <br>  <br> disrespected by various older and more \"liberal\" members.  at one meeting, <br>  <br> some americans in the globalfobics show up with the proposed points of <br>  <br> unity, saying \"this is what everyone in mexico wants\".  we fought over <br>  <br> these points of unity for about an hour, with us trying to get rid of the <br>  <br>  4) jumping back to the divisions withint he coalition,  the story behind <br>  <br>  the action guidelines is this: <br><br> there's an organization called la red de globalfobicos, which, we found <br>  <br> out later, was formed by global exchange, who came down to tijuana and <br>  <br> handpicked which nice little liberal groups and people they want to <br>  <br> work with.  (global exchange are also the ones who called this action <br>  <br> without talking to anyone from san diego or tijuana first, by the way...) <br>  <br> so anyway... the san diego coalition meetings were 4 hour long fights over <br>  <br> things like consensus vs. voting, spokescouncil vs. stacking meetings, <br>  <br> etc.  the globalfobics are claiming to speak for all of mexico, the <br>  <br> iso is bringing 7-10 members to every meeting and trying to sell papers <br>  <br> afterward, and youth and radicals in the coalition are being yelled at and <br>  <br> disrespected by various older and more \"liberal\" members.  at one meeting, <br>  <br> some americans in the globalfobics show up with the proposed points of <br>  <br> unity, saying \"this is what everyone in mexico wants\".  we fought over <br>  <br> these points of unity for about an hour, with us trying to get rid of the <br>  <br> no property damage, direct action, or civil disobedience clause, and them <br>  <br> trying to get rid of anyone whose view of social change isn't \"so who do <br>  <br> i write a check out to to solve this problem?\" the compromise that we end <br>  <br> up with is no planned civil disobedience, and us warning the coalition <br>  <br> that if we have the points of unity include these things, the coalition <br>  <br> is being completely unrealistic, and will come back to haunt us later. <br>  <br> <\/p>\n","contact":"","link":"","address":"","phone":"","parent_id":0,"mime_type":"text\/plain","summary":"a defense of san diego organizers","numcomment":4,"fileurl":"\/uploads\/2001\/04\/more_on_th.txt","filesize":"5.3 kibibytes","article_url":"\/news\/2001\/04\/6170.php"},"attachments":[],"comments":[{"id":6173,"heading":"In defense of the bloc","article":"Many misconceptions have come from the FTAA S\/T border action. The individual in the bloc who said \"Whatever bitch.\" was reprimaded, though allegations were blown out of proportion. I only have two complaints against the organizers. One is that one organizer was seen talking to the police, she said:\r\n\r\n\"I'm so sorry things have gone this way (This is after the bloc attacked police at the fence).\" \r\n\r\nPolice officer: \"Don't worry, your doing a good job.\"\r\n\r\nA reliable agent reported this to the other members of the SKAA affinity. If the police who murder us and slaughter the innocent think your doing a great job, then you obviously your doing someting wrong. The other is that the march WAS cancelled, three organizers brought this to the attention of the BB. The BB replied that they were going to march anyway, and they said \"Ok, but I don't think it's a good idea to march by yourselves.\" RCPYB (Revolutionary Communist Party Youth Brigade) reported that the organizers approached them and told them, \"Don't cause any trouble.\" Sounds like the god damn police. After the RCPYB, Black Bloc, Art And Revolution, and several other groups conspired together to march anyway, the organizers got up and said:\r\n\r\n\"Ok we are going to LET you march\"\r\n\r\nThanks god, we needed your permition. We respect the organizers tactics. We DON'T respect the organizers imposing tactics on other groups. Organizers KNEW that the bloc was going to ignore their demands, so they tried intimidation the bloc, telling them that they are surrounded, that immigrants would be shot if we did illegal things (How far will they go?!), that the entire neighborhood around the borderwill be pillaged by the police, and picked on for years (What? Police don't harrass working class neighborhoods right now?). Don't sit around and try to come up with lame far fetched reasons the black bloc shouldn't do things. The fact remains that besides liberal groups who fear that their money from non-violent groups will be pulled if the ruckus comes, the rest of the people at the protest agree with the bloc's tactics (A lot of times they join in). In fact some have come up and thanked the bloc, or have said that they are glad we were there (I don't know why they didn't just throw on some black clothes and join in). Most groups now are making alliances with the bloc at actions. Still the middle class will never approve of us, and we don't care. You organizers who are not like this, this isn't meant towards you. Organizers who were (You know who you are), this is.\r\n\r\n-Agent Pookie of SKAA ","author":"Agent Pookie","parent_id":6170,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2001-04-24 21:36:27","modified":"2001-04-24 21:58:10","fileurl":""},{"id":6202,"heading":"its all about respect and solidarity","article":"its interesting that you write \"middleclass people will never approve of us\" cause it seems to me that most bloc people are white and middleclass. wonder why?\r\nim not going to respect those who dont respect me","author":"anika","parent_id":6170,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2001-04-25 18:03:30","modified":"2001-04-25 19:00:01","fileurl":""},{"id":6204,"heading":"The black bloc and anarchism","article":"Pookie,\r\n\r\nIf the black bloc actually knows what all the people at demos\r\nwant, why aren't there hundreds of people in the black bloc\r\nin southern california?  Why is the black bloc the same size \r\nevery time?\r\n\r\nI think I know the answer - the black bloc needs to seriously\r\nlook at its practice and how it relates to anarchism.\r\n\r\nThe black bloc functions with authoritarian tendencies, both\r\ninternally and externally. As you so often point out, it's \r\nauthoritarian to claim to speak for people who haven't had \r\nany input into what you're saying.\r\n\r\nThis is exactly what you're doing, according to your post.\r\n\r\nWhy don't you try to negotiate with the other \r\nparticipants at events?  Why do you just straight out reject \r\ntheir ideas?  Why even bother going to an demo organized by \r\nother people if you don't plan to accept any input on how \r\nto demonstrate?  Why does solidarity mean only going along with \r\nthe black bloc?\r\n\r\nFrom my experience, the black block does not function democratically\r\neven internally.  It relies on an elite core for leadership. \r\nThe \"consensus\" process is merely a means of rubber-stamping\r\nthe decisions of the elite, with accusations of \"liberal!\" for \r\nthose who disobey.  Unfortunately this elite core doesn't even\r\nhave a head for street fighting tactics.\r\n\r\nThe black bloc often accuses those who oppose its tactics to\r\nbe \"liberals,\" but I would claim that the black bloc has\r\nexhibited liberalism of the worst kind - that kind of rugged\r\nindividualism \"do your own thing and fuck everyone else\" \r\nthat is promoted by capitalism.\r\n\r\nIt's a disgusting insult to the name of anarchism.\r\n\r\nI'm not trying to claim that the organizers of the border event\r\nwere not authoritarian, however, I think it's insane to fight\r\nthis authoritarianism with even more authoritarianism.\r\n","author":"ert","parent_id":6170,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2001-04-25 18:09:57","modified":"2001-04-25 19:00:01","fileurl":""},{"id":6250,"heading":"the black bloc is not middle class","article":"i'm fucking tired of people always accusing the black bloc of being white middle class. how the fuck can you tell if someone is rich or poor by looking at them? especially when they've got on all black and a mask. even those people in black bloc who grew up middle class  reject that privilege. we don't follow the path we're told to, going to college and getting a high-paying job. we're workers, train-hoppers, squatters, thieves. we're not living off our parent's money, we're out there spanging and dumpster diving. and what difference does it make if some of us have white skin. don't you all know that race doesn't exist and that we can't change the color of our skin. does the fact that someone has light skin mean that they don't have the right to fight against this system. anarchists realize that you don't have to count as some official minority (dark skin, immigrant, womyn, queer, etc) to be oppressed. we're all oppressed by this system, everytime we work at a job we hate, every time a cop tells us to get off the street, everytime a forest is cut down or new houses are built. we are all fucked over by those who have control of our lives. it doesn't matter what color our skin is, we're gonna take back our lives.","author":"anonymous","parent_id":6170,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2001-04-26 18:18:23","modified":"2001-04-26 18:31:53","fileurl":""}]}