{"article":{"id":5929,"heading":"FTAA: Why It Is Important To Protest... And Why Protests Are Not Enough","author":"Bill  Fletcher, Jr. \/ The Black World Today","created":"2001-04-17 15:50:29","modified":"2005-08-15 00:31:58","last_modified":"Mon, 15 Aug 2005 08:31:58","article":"<p>FTAA--Why It Is Important To Protest\r\n\r\n\r\n<b>The\r\nBlack World Today<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<\/p><p><b>FTAA: Why It Is Important\r\nTo Protest... And Why Protests Are Not Enough<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<\/p><p><b>By Bill&nbsp; Fletcher, Jr.<\/b>\r\n<br><b>TBWT Columnist<\/b>\r\n<br><b>Article Dated 4\/14\/2001<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<\/p><p><b>On the weekend of April\r\n21-22, thousands of activists are expected to gather in Quebec City (Quebec,\r\nCanada) as a further expression of the anti-globalization movement sweeping\r\nthe world. In this case they will be gathering to protest governmental\r\ndiscussions aimed at expanding the North American Free Trade Agreement\r\n(NAFTA) into a Free Trade Agreement of the Americas (FTAA).<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<\/p><p><b>The irony of having such\r\na discussion in a province, which has been a hotbed of struggles for greater\r\nsovereignty, cannot be lost on anyone. The issue of sovereignty, however,\r\ngoes far and beyond the Quebec national question. It speaks to the potential\r\nrearrangement of politics and economics in the Western Hemisphere.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<\/p><p><b>When the original&#150;pre-NAFTA--free\r\ntrade agreement was signed between the USA and Canada, the Canadian province\r\nof Ontario lost thousands of jobs&#150;to the USA. This was devastating for\r\nthe Ontario working class and economy generally. When NAFTA was signed,\r\nthe USA lost hundreds of thousands of manufacturing jobs. Ironically, and\r\ncontrary to H. Ross Perot&#146;s famous metaphor of a &#145;giant sucking sound&#146;\r\nof jobs going to Mexico, Mexico itself lost jobs and Mexican farmers were\r\nadditionally hit very badly (a major factor in the Zapatista revolt).<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<\/p><p><b>Despite the rampage of\r\nfree trade, and the undermining of communities, ruling elites in the Western\r\nHemisphere have pressed forward, advancing the assumption that only through\r\nfree trade can there be widespread economic development. It is this notion,\r\nand the corresponding undermining of the sovereignty of governments, which\r\nthe anti-globalization movement has risen to challenge.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<\/p><p><b>It is important, therefore,\r\nthat there is a visible opposition to the deliberations in Quebec and their\r\nintended outcome. The ruling elites, often members of otherwise contentious\r\npolitical parties, have developed a consensus in most of this hemisphere\r\nin support of free trade. They are prepared to ignore the negative impact\r\nof free trade on working people, seeing it as a temporary malady. Unless\r\nthousands of people are in the streets making their voices heard, this\r\ncharade will continue.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<\/p><p><b>Yet, as Michael Albert\r\nfrom Z magazine has raised, are these demonstrations enough? Tormenting\r\ntrade ministers is fine popular drama and has a definite and demonstrable\r\nimpact on mass consciousness&#150;witness the polling results, which accompanied\r\nthe &#145;Battle for Seattle&#146;&#150;but it is not enough. Contrary to the fatalist\r\nview which holds that with neo-liberal globalization, action at the national\r\nand local level is irrelevant, it should be argued that such action is\r\nall the more important. And that action must be political and programmatic.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<\/p><p><b>The process of globalization\r\nhas been one supported by technological changes, but has not been the result\r\nof natural economic forces. Governments and multi-national corporations\r\nhave advanced this process through deliberations such as the one about\r\nto occur in Quebec. Treaties and other agreements, knowingly signed by\r\nrepresentatives of governments, have locked not only those governments,\r\nbut more importantly future regimes into an approach toward the economy\r\nwhich is fundamentally anti-people, and fundamentally hazardous to the\r\nhealth of this planet.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<\/p><p><b>Demonstrations in Quebec\r\nmust also be matched by political and legislative strategies at the national\r\nlevel, which place governments into power that have a very different agenda,\r\nindeed an agenda that reflects the needs of the working class. Is this\r\na call for autarchy? Hardly. Counterposing free trade to autarchy is sophistry\r\nat best. Rather, domestic economies must be driven by the needs of their\r\npeoples and not the needs of the multi-national corporations or ruling\r\nelites. In some cases this may mean bi-lateral or multi-lateral agreements,\r\nwhich affect regional economic development. That must be the choice of\r\nthe peoples of those nations, rather than the choices imposed upon them\r\nby the International Monetary Fund, World Bank, multi-national corporations,\r\nor any of the political parties, which do their bidding.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<\/p><p><b>The mobilizations for\r\nQuebec are not only about visible outrage at the impact of neo-liberal\r\nglobalization, but can signal a redefining of the proverbial line, which\r\ndivides friends and foes. Rather than a retreat into protectionism and\r\nnational narrowness, the anti-globalization mobilizations around Quebec\r\ncan help to encourage an internationalist politics defined by the needs\r\nof working people.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<\/p><p>\r\n<\/p><hr width=\"100%\">\r\n<br><b>Republished by permission\r\nof the author.&nbsp; Copyright &copy; 2001&nbsp; The Black World Today.All\r\nRights Reserved.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\n<p><b>This article also appeared\r\non the Black Radical Congress mailing list.&nbsp;&nbsp; To subscribe to\r\nBRC-News: &lt;mailto:majordomo@tao.ca?body=subscribe%20brc-news&gt;<\/b>\r\n<br>&nbsp;\r\n<br>&nbsp;\r\n\r\n\r\n<\/p>\n","contact":"","link":"http:\/\/www.tbwt.com\/content\/article.asp?articleid=443","address":"","phone":"","parent_id":0,"mime_type":"text\/html","summary":"\"The mobilizations for Quebec are not only about visible outrage at the impact of neo-liberal globalization, but can signal a redefining of the proverbial line, which divides friends and foes. Rather than a retreat into protectionism and national narrowness, the anti-globalization mobilizations around Quebec can help to encourage an internationalist politics defined by the needs of working people.\"","numcomment":0,"fileurl":"\/uploads\/2001\/04\/ftaa--why_it_is_important_to_protest....htm","filesize":"7.2 kibibytes","article_url":"\/news\/2001\/04\/5929.php"},"attachments":[],"comments":[]}