{"article":{"id":5896,"heading":"College Prankster Exposed: David Horowitz's Hollow Arguments and Racist Subtext","author":"Paul H. Rosenberg","created":"2001-04-14 13:06:09","modified":"2005-08-15 00:31:54","last_modified":"Mon, 15 Aug 2005 08:31:54","article":"<p>Contra_Horowitz\r\r\n\r\r\n\r\r\n\r\r\n<b>College Prankster Exposed:<\/b>\r\r\n<br><b>The Hollow Arguments and Racist Subtext<\/b>\r\r\n<br><b>Of David Horowitz&#146;s Anti-Reparations Campaign<\/b>\r\r\n\r\r\n<\/p><p><br>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Rightwing provocateur\r\r\nDavid Horowitz has gotten himself quite a bit of notice lately by trying\r\r\nto place an ad in college newspapers attacking the idea of reparations\r\r\nfor slavery as &#147;a Bad Idea for Blacks - and Racist Too.&#148;&nbsp; The whole\r\r\npoint of this exercise was precisely what ensued: to bait campus newspapers\r\r\nand activists into intemperate responses, which would serve to obscure\r\r\nthe underlying issues and cast them in the role of un-American enemies\r\r\nof free speech and free thought.&nbsp; The last thing he really wanted\r\r\nwas for anyone to take his arguments seriously, because, as we&#146;ll see in\r\r\na moment, his arguments range from laughably foolish to laughably racist.&nbsp;\r\r\nNone can withstand serious scrutiny.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Of course, Horowitz himself\r\r\nis an old hand at silencing people he disagrees with.&nbsp; In the late\r\r\n1980s he spearheaded the campaign to shut down the news program &#147;South\r\r\nAfrica Now,&#148; carried on many PBS stations.&nbsp; His rationale?&nbsp; It\r\r\nwas &#147;communist propaganda,&#148; because its producers worked with members of\r\r\nNelson Mandela&#146;s African National Congress, which included communists in\r\r\nits ranks.&nbsp; (Southern segregationists in the 50s and 60s used the\r\r\nsame tactics against Martin Luther King.)<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Horowitz then made no\r\r\nattempt to counter speech he didn&#146;t like with speech of his own.&nbsp;\r\r\nHe went for censorship instead.&nbsp; In doing so&#151;stifling news, awareness\r\r\nand discussion of South Africa, rather than expanding it&#151;he made himself\r\r\na direct de facto ally of&nbsp; the racist South African government.&nbsp;\r\r\nSouth Africa&#146;s expulsion of foreign media in the mid-1980s was intended\r\r\nto remove the anti-Apartheid struggle from global consciousness and thus\r\r\ngive them a free hand to crush it with unlimited brutality and terror.&nbsp;\r\r\nThis strategy proved remarkably effective with the US media, creating a\r\r\nnews vacuum which &#147;South Africa Now&#148; was created specifically to fill.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Then, as now, Horowitz\r\r\nwas opposed to a movement of black people which he attacked as &#147;left-wing.&#148;&nbsp;\r\r\nThen, as now, the pre-eminent African-American leader involved was Randall\r\r\nRobinson.&nbsp; Then, as now, Horowitz was trying to prevent an informed\r\r\ndebate.&nbsp; Then he went on the offensive, working to silence the only\r\r\nnational TV program covering South Africa.&nbsp; Now he has gone on the\r\r\noffensive by baiting others to attack him intemperately, diverting attention\r\r\nfrom the actual issues involved.&nbsp; Then he claimed to want &#147;balanced&#148;\r\r\ncoverage, but what he actually worked for was silencing and censorship.&nbsp;\r\r\nNow he claims to want an open dialogue on college campuses where he ran\r\r\nhis ad, but what he&#146;s actually worked for is the circus sideshow he&#146;s created\r\r\nin the national media in order to stifle discussion of the actual issues\r\r\ninvolved and to paint advocates of reparations as intolerant extremists,\r\r\nwhose ideas can be dismissed without a hearing&#151;and without this dismissal\r\r\nbeing called censorship.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>That wasn&#146;t the only time\r\r\nHorowitz sought to silence those he disagrees with, it&#146;s just the most\r\r\nrelevant to the current controversy. But one other example shows how thoroughly\r\r\npetty his censorship streak can be.&nbsp; Last year, Horowitz got upset\r\r\nby some reader reviews of his books on Amazon.com, and he launched a campaign\r\r\nto get Amazon to remove the offending reviews.&nbsp; Just about every writer\r\r\nwhose ever been reviewed has been upset by some reviewer.&nbsp; But Horowitz\r\r\nwas convinced it was a plot against him, and his response was censorship.&nbsp;\r\r\nRemember, this is the champion of free speech in this little drama he&#146;s\r\r\nmanufactured.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>One more point deserves\r\r\nmention before turning to look at Horowitz&#146;s &#147;reasons&#148; for opposing reparations.&nbsp;\r\r\nThis concerns the issue of censorship on campus.&nbsp; You don&#146;t have to\r\r\nsupport any action taken in opposition to Horowitz&#151;even the simple editorial\r\r\ndecision not to accept his ad&#151;to note how wildly this incident has been\r\r\nblown out of proportion.&nbsp; Any retail transgressions against free expression\r\r\nthat Horowitz may have provoked pale before the wholesale sellout involved\r\r\nin the corporate takeover of academia.&nbsp; The billions of dollars of\r\r\ncorporate-sponsored research with non-disclosure clauses and patent rights\r\r\non all discoveries represent a wholesale subversion of free speech, free\r\r\ninquiry and the essence of both the liberal arts and the scientific tradition.&nbsp;\r\r\nBut that&#146;s business as usual, standard operation procedure.&nbsp; Nothing\r\r\nto get upset about, and certainly not news.&nbsp; Such is the unspoken\r\r\nbackground logic to this story.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Horowitz&#146;s ad is titled\r\r\n&#147;Ten Reasons Why Reparations for Blacks is a Bad Idea for Blacks - and\r\r\nRacist Too,&#148; and the first thing worth noting is the title is a lie.&nbsp;\r\r\nEight of the ten &#147;reasons&#148; given don&#146;t even <i>pretend<\/i> to show why\r\r\nreparations are bad for blacks. All they even pretend to show is that reparations\r\r\nshouldn&#146;t be given.&nbsp;&nbsp; What&#146;s more, there is <i>no <\/i>reason\r\r\ngiven why reparations are supposedly racist, it&#146;s just an unsupported claim\r\r\nHorowitz makes along the way.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Framing the title as he\r\r\ndoes, Horowitz poses as the compassionate conservative friend of black\r\r\nAmericans out to save them from the evil leaders who are leading them astray&#151;an\r\r\nargument white conservatives have been making ever since since the slave\r\r\nrebellions lead by Nat Turner, Gabriel Prosser and Denmark Vessey.&nbsp;\r\r\nIt&#146;s not enough to argue that reparations for slavery are a bad idea&#151;that\r\r\ncould too easily be countered, &#147;bad for you, perhaps, fat white boy.&#148;&nbsp;\r\r\nThe new racism of today (the third such &#147;new racism&#148; since the American\r\r\nRevolution) requires the appearance of greater concern for the welfare\r\r\nof blacks than they (or their white allies) have for themselves.&nbsp;&nbsp;\r\r\nThis is purely for white consumption, of course.&nbsp; And for white consumption,\r\r\nit&#146;s enough to simply <i>claim<\/i> that the reasons are offered on behalf\r\r\nof black self-interest (&#147;a Bad Idea for Blacks&#148;) and against black racism\r\r\n(&#147;and Racist Too&#148;).<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>With this in mind, let&#146;s\r\r\nturn to each of the reasons in turn.&nbsp; Each reason is followed by a\r\r\nparagraph (in one case 3 paragraphs) of explanation.&nbsp; In most cases\r\r\nthe reason can be considered alone, since it constitutes a fallacious argument.&nbsp;\r\r\nThe explanations could be criticized as well, of course, but I will only\r\r\ndo that where it is necessary to show what&#146;s wrong with the purported reason\r\r\nitself.&nbsp;&nbsp; Let us being.<\/b>\r\r\n<br><b><\/b>&nbsp;<b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Reason\r\r\nOne: There Is No Single Group Clearly Responsible For The Crime Of Slavery<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Response:&nbsp; Irrelevant.&nbsp;\r\r\n(This is what&#146;s known as a &#145;red herring&#146; argument.)&nbsp; Reparation claims\r\r\nare made against responsible governments, not against groups or their descendents.<\/b>\r\r\n<br><b><\/b>&nbsp;<b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Reason\r\r\nTwo: There Is No One Group That Benefited Exclusively From Its Fruits<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Response: Irrelevant.&nbsp;\r\r\n(Another red herring.) Reparations for the Holocaust weren&#146;t made on the\r\r\nbasis of group benefit for the non-Jewish German people.&nbsp; Nor were\r\r\nreparations for the WWII internment of Japanese-Americans made on the basis\r\r\nof group benefit to any other subgoups of Americans.<\/b>\r\r\n<br><b><\/b>&nbsp;<b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Reason\r\r\nThree: Only A Tiny Minority Of White Americans Ever Owned Slaves, And Others\r\r\nGave Their Lives To Free Them<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Response: Irrelevant.\r\r\n(Red herring, again.) Only a tiny minority of Germans directly killed Jews\r\r\nin the Holocaust, and some gave their lives to protect them.&nbsp; A far\r\r\nsmaller minority of Americans were directly involved in putting Japanese-Americans\r\r\ninto concentration camps.&nbsp; (Taking or sacrificing lives wasn&#146;t necessary\r\r\nto end this grave injustice, however white Americans were involved in vigorously\r\r\nopposing it.)&nbsp; The number of perpetrators has no bearing on the matter.&nbsp;&nbsp;\r\r\nNeither does the existence of a resistance within the dominant group.<\/b>\r\r\n<br><b><\/b>&nbsp;<b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Reason\r\r\nFour: America Today Is A Multi-Ethnic Nation and Most Americans Have No\r\r\nConnection&nbsp; (Direct Or Indirect) To Slavery<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Response: Irrelevant.&nbsp;\r\r\n(Yes, Virginia, there is a whole school of red herring here.) Again, this\r\r\nis not a matter of inter-group justice, much less individual justice.&nbsp;\r\r\nIt&#146;s a matter of historical justice and institutional government responsibility.<\/b>\r\r\n<br><b><\/b>&nbsp;<b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Reason\r\r\nFive: The Historical Precedents Used To Justify The Reparations Claim Do\r\r\nNot Apply, And The Claim Itself Is Based On Race Not Injury<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Response: Factually incorrect.&nbsp;\r\r\nIn explaining this point, Horowitz writes, &#147;The historical precedents generally\r\r\ninvoked to justify the reparations claim are payments to Jewish&nbsp; survivors\r\r\nof the Holocaust, Japanese-Americans and African- American victims of racial&nbsp;\r\r\nexperiments in Tuskegee, or racial outrages in Rosewood and Oklahoma City.\r\r\nBut in each case,&nbsp; the recipients of reparations were the direct victims\r\r\nof the injustice or their immediate families. This would be the only case\r\r\nof reparations to people who were not immediately affected and whose sole\r\r\nqualification to receive reparations would be racial.&#148;<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>But Holocaust reparations\r\r\nincluded payments by the German government to the State of Israel, payments\r\r\nwhich were clearly not to individuals, but to the collectivity of those\r\r\nharmed&#151;the &#147;Jewish race.&#148;&nbsp; Similarly, redress of treaty violations\r\r\nagainst American Indian tribes have also been done on a racial basis.&nbsp;\r\r\nThus there is clear precedent for reparations based on race&#151;even though\r\r\nthis is not what Randall Robinson and many (though not all) others are\r\r\narguing for.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Even if Horowitz had been\r\r\nfactually correct, this would be irrelevant.&nbsp; Legal precedents are\r\r\nconstantly expanded, and have been since the birth of Anglo-American common\r\r\nlaw, if not before.&nbsp; If the harm persists through generations, and\r\r\nbeyond immediate victims, then there is good grounds to expand the scope\r\r\nof the precedent accordingly&#151;particularly when the original injury was\r\r\nfollowed by another 100 years of laws imposing new injuries aggravating\r\r\nthe old.&nbsp; There&#146;s no good reason in law why a son can inherit the\r\r\nright to reparations, but his son cannot if he is never paid.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Horowitz goes on to argue,\r\r\n&#147;As has already been pointed out, during&nbsp; the slavery era, many blacks\r\r\nwere free men or slave-owners themselves, yet the reparations claimants\r\r\nmake no distinction between the roles blacks actually played in the injustice\r\r\nitself.&#148;&nbsp; Some blacks were freed before others, but all were slaves\r\r\nor the descendants of slaves.&nbsp; Being &#147;free men&#148; hardly meant immunity\r\r\nfrom further racial harm.&nbsp; Horowitz is simply arguing that slavery\r\r\nhurt some people worse than others.&nbsp; So did the Holocaust.&nbsp; If\r\r\nHorowitz&#146;s argument has any validity against the case for reparations,\r\r\nit has equal validity against the case for Holocaust reparations as well.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Horowitz continues:&nbsp;\r\r\n&#147;Randall Robinson's book on reparations, <i>The Debt<\/i>, which is the\r\r\nmanifesto of the reparations movement is pointedly sub-titled \"What America\r\r\nOwes To Blacks.\" If this is not racism, what is?&#148;&nbsp; This is the whole\r\r\nextent of Horowitz&#146;s &#147;reasons&#148; why reparations are racist.&nbsp; Of course,\r\r\nthis is laughably absurd.&nbsp; But&#151;like most attempts to paint blacks\r\r\nas racist&#151;it&#146;s also an example of white racism projected onto blacks, as\r\r\ncan easily be seen.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>To begin with, there&#146;s\r\r\nnothing racist about saying that slavery harmed blacks as a group, which\r\r\nis the basis of Robinson&#146;s argument.&nbsp; It&#146;s a simple statement of historical\r\r\nfact.&nbsp; Nor is there anything racist about saying that that harm inflicted\r\r\ncreates a debt to the victim&#151;this is the basis of civil tort law.&nbsp;\r\r\nAnyone who disputes these facts&#151;as Horowitz does&#151;bears an enormous burden\r\r\nof proof&#151;not to prove his points, but to prove that he himself is not a\r\r\nracist.&nbsp;&nbsp; Why else would someone make such an absurd claim?&nbsp;\r\r\nThere may be other, non-racist arguments why the debt should not be paid,\r\r\nbut simply denying its very existence cannot be done on any non-racist\r\r\ngrounds.&nbsp; One must either deny the historical reality, or one must\r\r\nclaim that blacks are different, that they can be harmed without creating\r\r\na debt.&nbsp; Either of these alternatives is racist.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Of course, it&#146;s possible\r\r\nto pick up racist arguments and repeat them without consciously knowing\r\r\nwhat you&#146;re doing.&nbsp; That&#146;s why I say Horowitze bears a burden proof,\r\r\nnot that he&#146;s guilty.&nbsp; But since this is the entirety of his vaunted\r\r\nclaim that reparations are &#147;Racist Too,&#148; the burden is heavy indeed.&nbsp;\r\r\nThe burden is made even heavier by Horowitz&#146;s use below of the racist discourse\r\r\nequating welfare with race, which he takes even farther than traditional\r\r\nracists did.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Finally, just suppose,\r\r\nfor the sake of argument, that we accept Horowitz&#146;s claim that Robinson&#146;s\r\r\nmanifesto is racist.&nbsp; Then, by his own logic, Horowitz is still a\r\r\nracist, since his own reason 9 reads &#147;What About The Debt Blacks Owe To\r\r\nAmerica?&#148;<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Reason\r\r\nSix:&nbsp; The Reparations Argument Is Based On The Unfounded Claim That\r\r\nAll African-American Descendants of Slaves Suffer From The Economic Consequences\r\r\nOf Slavery And Discrimination<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Response: Factually incorrect.&nbsp;\r\r\nIn Randall Robinson&#146;s <i>The Debt<\/i>, the most prominent statement of\r\r\nthe case for reparations, Robinson explicitly states that the consequences\r\r\nare far more than economic, and that reparations should not be paid to\r\r\nthose like himself, who have been able to overcome the worst consequences\r\r\nof slavery and its aftermath with the help of existing remedies.<\/b>\r\r\n<br><b><\/b>&nbsp;<b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Reason&nbsp;\r\r\nSeven: The Reparations Claim Is One More Attempt To Turn African-Americans\r\r\nInto Victims. It Sends A Damaging Message To The African-American Community.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>(Note:&nbsp; This is one\r\r\nof only two reasons that actually argues reparations are bad for blacks.)<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Response: Factually incorrect.&nbsp;\r\r\nBlack Americans already are victims, the only question is what to do about\r\r\nit.&nbsp; Compensating victims is one of the ways we undo victimhood.&nbsp;\r\r\nNot compensating victims, even denying their victimhood (as Horowitz does)\r\r\nis way of victimizing them all over again&#151;as rape victims felt all the\r\r\ntime in the bad old days when police routinely assumed they &#145;had asked\r\r\nfor it.&#146;&nbsp; Thus, it&#146;s the knee-jerk refusal to even consider reparations\r\r\nthat is &#147;One More Attempt To Turn African-Americans Into Victims.&#148; According\r\r\nto Horowitz&#146;s looking-glass logic, the German payment of reparations to\r\r\nJews would be turning them into victims as well.&nbsp; That&#146;s patently\r\r\nabsurd on its face.&nbsp;&nbsp; So why are black Americans any different?\r\r\nThe fact that Horowitz would even make this argument is yet another indication\r\r\nthat he&#146;s <i>at least<\/i> subconsciously racist, that he consistently applies\r\r\ndifferent, <i>harsher<\/i> standards to black Americans than he does to\r\r\nothers.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Reason\r\r\nEight: Reparations To African Americans Have Already Been Paid<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>(Note:&nbsp; This is only\r\r\nan argument that reparations are bad for <i>blacks <\/i>if one assumes it&#146;s\r\r\nbad for a person to be overpaid.&nbsp; Slaveowners traditionally took this\r\r\nposition, of course.)<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Response: The big lie\r\r\n-- Goebbles would be so proud!&nbsp; We don&#146;t owe anything because we&#146;ve\r\r\nalready paid (what you don&#146;t deserve) without even being asked!&nbsp; We&#146;re\r\r\nsuch great guys!<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Horowitz points to &#147;trillions\r\r\nof&nbsp; dollars in transfer payments in the form of welfare benefits and\r\r\nracial preferences&#133; under the&nbsp; rationale of redressing historic racial\r\r\ngrievances,&#148; but welfare benefits aren&#146;t racially based at all, much less\r\r\nintended to redress &#145;historic racial grievances.&#146;&nbsp; This false assumption\r\r\ndoesn&#146;t just echoes traditional racist discourse equating blacks and welfare&#151;it\r\r\ntakes this racist discourse to a whole new level.&nbsp; No Southern segregationist\r\r\never went this far in equating the two absolutely and categorically.&nbsp;\r\r\nBlacks have never been even a majority of welfare beneficiaries, while\r\r\nthe size of the benefits they have received is dwarfed by the size of those\r\r\nthey&#146;ve been denied&#151;for example, when agricultural and domestic workers\r\r\nwere excluded from Social Security and minimum wage laws in the 1930s,\r\r\nor when they were denied the full benefits of VHA and VA loans and mortgage\r\r\ndeductions that subsidized massive white flight to segregated suburbs after\r\r\nWWII.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>So-called &#145;racial preferences&#146;\r\r\naren&#146;t even transfer payments at all.&nbsp; They are simply attempts to\r\r\nlevel the playing field&#151;attempts that have yet to fully succeed.&nbsp;\r\r\nNumerous studies testing treatment of equally-qualified whites and blacks\r\r\nseeking employment, housing, financial services, etc. have repeatedly shown\r\r\nthat even today whites are routinely given preferrential treatment in every\r\r\naspect of financial life.&nbsp; These are not &#145;historical racial grievances&#146;\r\r\nwe&#146;re talking about.&nbsp; They are brand new ones being created every\r\r\nday.<\/b>\r\r\n<br><b><\/b>&nbsp;<b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Reason&nbsp;\r\r\nNine: What About The Debt Blacks Owe To America?<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Response: Forget Goebbles.&nbsp;\r\r\nHitler would be so proud!&nbsp; According to Horowitz, Blacks owe America\r\r\nfirst for freeing them from slavery (a necessary, but originally unintended\r\r\nside-effect of the Civil War), and second for &#147;the highest standard of\r\r\nliving of blacks anywhere in the world.&#148;&nbsp; Never mind that America\r\r\nenslaved them in the first place&#151;they&#146;re owed nothing for that.&nbsp; Instead\r\r\n<i>they<\/i> owe America for freeing them.&nbsp; This is the same logic\r\r\nthat sentences an innocent man to death, and then asks for his thanks when\r\r\nhe&#146;s freed at the last minute 20 years later despite every attempt to fry\r\r\nhim and forget about it.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>As for bringing up black\r\r\nliving standards, Horowitz is comparing apples and oranges.&nbsp; Slavery\r\r\nwas a state-sanctioned evil imposed on blacks.&nbsp; Black living standards\r\r\nweren&#146;t the result of compensatory state action, which is the only sense\r\r\nin which blacks could be said to owe it to America. Those living standards\r\r\nwere <i>earned<\/i> by blacks, the same way that everyone else has earned\r\r\ntheir living standards, except for the many additonal burdens faced by\r\r\nblacks, including burdens added by state action&#151;such as discrimination,\r\r\nthe exclusion of agricultural and domestic work from minimum wage laws\r\r\nand Social Security insurance, etc.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>But it gets worse. The\r\r\nvery premise of Horowitz&#146;s comparison is racist.&nbsp;&nbsp; Horowitz doesn&#146;t\r\r\ncompare black American living standards to white American living standards.&nbsp;\r\r\nHe compares black American living standards to black living standards elsewhere\r\r\nin the world.&nbsp;&nbsp; But he would never argue that a tenth generation\r\r\nAnglo-American should be greatful to America for how much better off he\r\r\nis than blacks in Sub-Saharan Africa.&nbsp; Such an argument would be laughable.&nbsp;\r\r\nApplied to black Americans, it&#146;s laughably racist.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>But even if it weren&#146;t,\r\r\nthe colonial rape of black Africa hardly justifies the fact that African-American\r\r\nmedian family incomes are less than 60% of white incomes, while their median\r\r\nnet worth is less than 15% of white net worth and their infant mortality\r\r\nrate (widely regarded as a prime indicator of general well-being) is over\r\r\ntwice that of whites and almost exactly equal to that of Trinidad and Tobago,\r\r\nwhich ranks number 56 in the world.&nbsp;&nbsp; In essence, Horowitz is\r\r\nsaying, &#147;Be thankful you were robbed you at knifepoint&#151;your brother was\r\r\nrobbed with a gun, and he ended up dead.&#148;<\/b>\r\r\n<br><b><\/b>&nbsp;<b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Reason\r\r\nTen: The Reparations Claim Is A Separatist Idea That Sets African-Americans\r\r\nAgainst The Nation That Gave Them Freedom<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>(Note:&nbsp; This is one\r\r\nof only two reasons that actually argues reparations are bad for blacks.)<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Response: The just rule\r\r\nof law binds people together.&nbsp; Paying debts and redressing grievances\r\r\nbinds people together.&nbsp; Refusing to deal with existing grievances,\r\r\ndebts and separations is what&#146;s truly separtatist.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>In expanding this point,\r\r\nHorowitz repeatedly tries to equate the demand for reparations with &#147;separatists,\r\r\nnationalists and the political left, who want&nbsp; African-Americans to\r\r\nbe no part of America's social contract.&#148;&nbsp; The inherent claim that\r\r\n&#147;the political left&#133; want[s] African-Americans to be no part of America's\r\r\nsocial contract&#148; would surely come as news to Dr. Martin Luther King, arguably\r\r\nthe most prominent figure on America&#146;s political left in our history.&nbsp;\r\r\nFocusing specifically on the issue of reparations, Randall Robinson&#146;s book<i>\r\r\nThe Debt: What America Owes To Blacks <\/i>makes it quite clear that his\r\r\nintent is exactly the opposite of the exclusion that Horowitz falsely attributes\r\r\nto him.&nbsp;&nbsp; Robinson begins with a description of the Capitol dome\r\r\nand surrounding official artistic representations in which African Americans\r\r\nare systematically excluded from their rightful place in American history.&nbsp;\r\r\nThe point of reparations is precisely to undo this legacy of separation,\r\r\nexploitation and victimization that was imposed on blacks against their\r\r\nwill.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Horowitz also says, &#147;For\r\r\nall America's faults, African-Americans have an enormous stake in their\r\r\ncountry and its heritage. It is this heritage that is really under attack\r\r\nby the reparations movement. The reparations claim is one more assault\r\r\non America, conducted by racial separatists and the political left.&#148;&nbsp;\r\r\nApparently Horowitz thinks that paying your debts is un-American.&nbsp;\r\r\nBut he is right about one thing: slavery is a part of &#147;American heritage,&#148;\r\r\nand the reparations movement is an attack on it.&nbsp; This attack upsets\r\r\nHorowitz so much that he equates it with an attack on America itself.&nbsp;\r\r\nForget Hitler.&nbsp; Jefferson Davis would be so proud.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>*&nbsp;&nbsp; *&nbsp;&nbsp;\r\r\n*<\/b>\r\r\n<b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>Having reviewed Horowitz&#146;s\r\r\nreasons, it should be obvious why some students reacted as they did.&nbsp;\r\r\nThe &#147;reasons&#148; are so ridiculous on their face that they constitute an insult&#151;like\r\r\nspitting in someone&#146;s face.&nbsp; It&#146;s one of the traditional prerogatives\r\r\nof power not to need any justification, and one of the traditional displays\r\r\nof power to flaunt this freedom from any need of justification.&nbsp; All\r\r\nthis applies in spades to the prerogatives of racist white power, just\r\r\nas it does to sexist male power.&nbsp; The more absurd the reason given,\r\r\nthe more it serves to underscore the arbitrary power it does nothing to\r\r\njustify.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>The greatest absurdity&#151;and\r\r\ngreatest insult&#151;of all is to stand reality on its head, which happens when\r\r\nthose possessed of arbitrary power pose as the true friend of those without\r\r\nit, or when they accuse the powerless of being the true oppressors.&nbsp;\r\r\nHorowitz does both of these&#151;he poses as the true friend of blacks, warning\r\r\nthem against &#147;separatists, nationalists and the political left&#148; as if the\r\r\ncall for reparations hadn&#146;t lived for generations among the humblest black\r\r\nsharecroppers and domestics and he accuses those who argue for reparations\r\r\nof being racists, simply for pointing out historical truths.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>In effect, Horowitz was\r\r\nout to tell people about their mama.&nbsp; And he got exactly what he was\r\r\nlooking for.&nbsp; Now pundits all across the land can wring their hands\r\r\nabout these terrible, intolerant students.&nbsp; Well, I&#146;ve got a problem\r\r\nwith those students, too.&nbsp; They fell for a cheap trick, and they fell\r\r\nfor it largely because they&#146;re so powerless.&nbsp; As I mentioned before,\r\r\ntheir actions are nothing compared to the institutionalized corruption\r\r\nof free inquiry on the corporatized campus of today, and they&#146;re also nothing\r\r\ncompared to the mass media echo chamber that was Horowitz&#146;s real target\r\r\naudience all along.<\/b><b><\/b>\r\r\n<\/p><p><b>It&#146;s easy to provoke people\r\r\nwho don&#146;t have much power.&nbsp; Like every bully, Horowitz knows this\r\r\nvery well.&nbsp; But students even more powerless than these have changed\r\r\nthe course of history on more than one occasion.&nbsp; And those students,\r\r\ntoo, made their fair share of mistakes.&nbsp; That&#146;s what being a student\r\r\nis all about&#151;making mistakes and learning from them.&nbsp; But you can\r\r\nalso learn from the mistakes of others.&nbsp; And that&#146;s where David Horowitz\r\r\ncomes in.<\/b>\r\r\n<br><b><\/b>&nbsp;\r\r\n<br><b><\/b>&nbsp;\r\r\n<br><b><\/b>&nbsp;\r\r\n\r\r\n\r\r\n<\/p>\n","contact":"rad@gte.net","link":"","address":"","phone":"","parent_id":0,"mime_type":"text\/html","summary":"Rightwing provocateur David Horowitz got a lot of notice with an ad in college newspapers attacking the idea of reparations for slavery as \"a Bad Idea for Blacks - and Racist Too.\"  He succeeded in baiting campus newspapers and activists into intemperate responses, casting them in the role of un-American enemies of free speech and free thought & obscuring the underlying issue.  The last thing he really wanted was for anyone to take his arguments seriously, since his arguments range from laughably foolish to laughably racist.  None can withstand serious scrutiny.","numcomment":1,"fileurl":"\/uploads\/2001\/04\/contra_horowitz.htm","filesize":"32.2 kibibytes","article_url":"\/news\/2001\/04\/5896.php"},"attachments":[],"comments":[{"id":106812,"heading":"Reparations repartee","article":"The Atlantic is getting wider by the minute - is it merely due to the size of the USA and the facility supplied by the internet that all the obsessives can join forces and appear as if they constitute a body of normal people?  I am impressed by the amount of specious arguments: non-answers to non-questions.  Good money for lawyers and ax-grinders, if you ask me.\r\nGet a life!  Meanwhile, I feel like suing the overwhelmingly Norman aristocracy for the ills brought about by their 1000 year Reich in England - ever wondered why the English names for types of meat are actually bastardised forms of the French name for the relevant animal?  The Anglo-Saxon peasants raised the animal, and the Norman lord ate the meat.  Marx was wrong in his analysis of class conflict in England - it was economic relations inextricably linked with a sneering alien elite that caused a level of bitterness unparalleled in its length anywhere in the world.   Spencers, Churchills - you'd better watch out!","author":"David Stephenson","parent_id":5896,"mime_type":"text\/plain","created":"2004-04-02 10:50:23","modified":"2004-04-02 10:50:23","fileurl":""}]}