- js reader version
- email this article
- view hidden posts
- tags and related articles
by Chancellor Gene Block
Sunday, May. 18, 2014 at 4:28 PM
Chancellor Gene Block has released a statement to the UCLA community regarding the ethics statement, and the intimidation of pro-Israel and Jewish students on campus
To the Campus Community:
Over the past week, many of our students, as well as friends off campus, have communicated their concerns over a pledge that candidates for our student government were asked to sign prior to last week’s elections. Heated exchanges have occurred over the issue and have unfortunately left some feeling disrespected or targeted because of their views or affiliations. Certain news reports and other communications through social media have also mischaracterized aspects of the situation, fueling an unhealthy discourse that is harmful to our campus climate. Robust debate is vital to democratic learning, but it can never exclude common sense, civility and tolerance for those who disagree.
First, let me set the record straight on the facts, as we understand them: Students active in student government, who have varying views on Israel–Palestine issues, have participated in the recent past in free trips to the Middle East organized by Jewish groups. Prior to the recent student elections, some student groups asked candidates to sign a pledge promising not to go on such trips. The pledge was not sanctioned, proposed or required by our current student government or the university administration. No one was barred from running for office, participating in the election or serving on the council as a result of not signing the pledge. Some students signed, others did not. Both signatories and non-signatories won offices. The decision to circulate this pledge and the choice to sign it or not fall squarely within the realm of free speech, and free speech is sacrosanct to any university campus.
Second, just because speech is constitutionally protected doesn’t mean that it is wise, fair or productive. I am troubled that the pledge sought to delegitimize educational trips offered by some organizations but not others. I am troubled that the pledge can reasonably be seen as trying to eliminate selected viewpoints from the discussion. I condemn any remarks on social media or elsewhere that are disrespectful or hurtful.
Political speech that stigmatizes or casts aspersions on individuals or particular groups does not promote healthy debate but debases it by trying to intimidate individuals and groups. It does not strengthen the bonds of mutual respect and engagement that sustain a diverse community able to manage differences; it weakens them. If we shut out perspectives, if we silence voices, if we allow innuendo to substitute for reasoned exchange of ideas, if we listen only to those who already share our assumptions, truth gets lost, our intellectual climate is impoverished and our community is diminished.
Passionate debate is to be expected in a civil society, especially in a heated election season, but I am personally concerned any time people feel disrespected, intimidated or unfairly singled out because of their beliefs. Important issues will generate passions, even discomfort — that cannot be avoided. But if the political debate on campus gets more shrill and less nuanced, if hostility replaces empathy, if we see each other as enemies rather than as colleagues trying to figure out how to do the right thing in difficult circumstances, we will all be the lesser for it. It is possible to express strong opinions without belittling others.
Today I am calling on our Vice Chancellor for Student Affairs to explore how to better foster political dialogue that is respectful, productive and focused on understanding rather than division. UCLA faculty, students and staff deserve an open environment that encourages vigorous debate without disparagement.
Gene D. Block
Report this post as:
Families Protest Abusive Foreclosure Practices of Wells Fargo Bank
How is CCSA's Ref Rodriguez hiding his billionaire and ideologue contributors?
What drives charter profiteer Ref Rodriguez?
Los Angeles Artist Threatens 40 Million Dollar Law Suit for Public Storage Illegal Auction
RAC-LA Community Center Grand Opening
KPFK and Pacifica- woes unrelenting...
RAC-LA Community Center Badly Needs Your Support
Meet Green elected school board members, Sunday, March 29 in LA - 4pm
Californians Shame Regulators For Teaching Big Oil How To Skirt Law and Pollute Our Water
Next "Star Wars" to score in Los Angeles for First Time in Franchise History
More Local News...
The Battle for Jobs
Sham Yemen Peace Conference Postponed
Trapps de la domination, trapps de l'aliénation
USA, fbi, et al Crimes Against Humanity
Netanyahu Appoints Right-Wing Extremist to Head Israel's Diplomatic Corps
Venezuelan/Palestinian Relations: Based on Brotherhood, Solidarity and Mutual Support
Propaganda Accompanies Kiev's Buildup for Escalated Aggression
Washington Created the Islamic State (ISIS)
Paraphysique de la naissance
Netanyahu: Hate-Mongering Racist, Mass Murderer, Serial Liar
US-Supported Islamic State Terrorists Seize Palmyra
Grand Theft Poroshenko
Hillary Clinton Endorses GMOs
Margaret Sommers - Public Storage's "CUNT OF THE YEAR"
Memorial Day Dishonor and Disgrace
Russians Traveling Abroad Risk Lawless US Abduction
Obama Supports Nuclear Proliferation, Opposes Disarmament
Global March Against Monsanto Day
Jail torture trick
Obama's War on Yemen Rages
Heading Toward Financial Maidan in Ukraine?
The Shortwave Report 05/22/15 Listen Globally!
Mad men of government driving good men to distraction
Ukraine Provoking Confrontation with Russia
Saudi Arabia: Headed Toward Becoming Nuclear Armed and Dangerous?
Foreclosure Victims Occupy Senate Stump Speech of Kamala Harris
More Breaking News...