- js reader version
- email this article
- view hidden posts
- tags and related articles
by Steven Lindman
Wednesday, Feb. 06, 2013 at 8:14 PM
Unreleased document assembled during Clinton era
WASHINGTON – A report suppressed by the INS provides highly embarrassing and potentially politically explosive reading for current immigration reform advocates because it concludes the 1986 amnesty actually caused an increase in illegal immigration.
That’s because, the report explains, it acted as an incentive to persons who hoped to take advantage of a future amnesty.
Critics fear the current proposals suggested by Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., and others would do the same.
A review of the unreleased Clinton-era Immigration and Naturalization Service report reveals that the 1986 amnesty caused a rise in the number of unauthorized entries into the United States in the years immediately following.
However, the report also concludes that the “public expressions of opposition to immigration,” in particular the California Proposition 187 measure, likely were contributing factors in the decline in the rate of illegal entry after 1990.
In addition to the hope for a second amnesty, the INS drew another conclusion from the data that it collected as to why the rate of illegal entry increased.
It said the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (IRCA) was responsible for the increase in unauthorized entry to the United States in 1988-89 partly because during those years the rate of females entering the United States illegally increased to twice the 1987 rate.
These women entered the United States to join their male partners and family members who had been granted amnesty, in many cases bringing children with them, the report said. The addition of these families increased the strain on limited American resources, the report said.
With the U.S. unemployment still high and the shrinking of the GDP, immigration control advocates are concerned that the Rubio plan will lead to further budgetary hardship. The Rubio plan is consider by some to be Amnesty, Part 2.
The INS report also presents data that shed light on the apparent decrease in illegal entrants to the United States in the early 1990s. According the data, the illegal alien entry rate decreased because the IRCA made it easier for the spouses of Mexican-born residents to obtain immigrant visas.
As a result they did not have to enter the United States illegally, though hundreds of thousands of others continued to illegally enter the United States. The Immigration Act of 1990 – passed under George H.W. Bush – increased the annual number of immigrant visas to the United States by more than 150,000 beginning in 1992.
The increase in visas also reduced the number of unauthorized entries; however it did not decrease the total number of persons entering the United States for those years due to continued illegal immigration. Based on this information it appears that many of the persons who would have attempted to illegally enter the United States were the immigrants who utilized the entry visas.
The INS also credited the American public’s expressions of opposition to mass migration with deterring unauthorized entries, specifically the passage of Proposition 187 in California in November 1994. Proposition 187 removed many of the incentives to illegally enter the United States.
Dr. Steven Camarota, the director of research for the Center for Immigration Studies, concurred with that conclusion.
“Look at the impact of [the] Arizona employer verification legislation; look at the government’s own assessment. In 2008 DHS estimated that the unauthorized population in Arizona was 560,000, in January 2011 there were 360,000 unauthorized residents in Arizona. At the same time, estimates for the country as a whole stayed the same. This is strong indication that Arizona legislation played a role in decreasing the unauthorized population.”
Both the California and Arizona measures were challenged in federal court.
California Gov. Gray Davis, a Democrat, refused to defend Prop 187 in court. The Obama administration sued Arizona; the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to partially block the enforcement of the SB 1070 law.
A national security concern is the Red Dawn scenario. It is unclear how the United States government could verify the identities of millions of unauthorized persons in the country.
Critics say the large unauthorized population provides a hiding place for Mexican and Latin American intelligence agents and terrorists.
An additional danger comes from non-Latin American agents, some of whom included members of Islamic terrorist organizations whose Middle Eastern operatives may attempt to pass for Latin Americans to evade U.S. security measures, the said.
“You are dealing with bureaucratic incapacity; the immigration system is currently overwhelmed,” Camarota said. “There is no one to the verify millions of identities. Do they know what the documents … from Mexico look like? Maybe. But do they know what documents from Guatemala look like? Twenty percent of the unauthorized population is not from Latin America. Would the average immigration agent be able to verify document[s] from Poland? It’s a heads I win, tails you lose scenario because even when they identify fraud they will not go after the people who don’t qualify, those persons will continue to live in the U.S. illegally as they are doing now.”
He said, “Like the legislation in 2007 the new legislation will probably contain exemptions for prior fraud.”
Since 2001 foreign jihadists groups have increased their efforts to infiltrate the United States and avoid detection.
Camarota was also skeptical of measures to include the payment of back taxes and requirements to learn English.
“There is no record to make people pay taxes, or if there is a record the employer would have to provide that. Even in those cases where you have the records the amount most unauthorized workers earn place them below the tax threshold so there no tax to pay back. The requirements to learn English are not meaningful. It’s something that will not happen. All that maybe required is that illegal immigrants sign up for an English class. There is no enforcement.”
Report this post as:
LATEST COMMENTS ABOUT THIS ARTICLE
Listed below are the 10 latest comments of 1 posted about this article.
These comments are anonymously submitted by the website visitors.
|This Is False
||David L. Wilson
||Thursday, Feb. 07, 2013 at 2:56 PM
KPFK is in double trouble, credit cards misused, and...
WW Broad & The War On Public Education In LA
KPFK= more. Tired of the turmoil? we are too.
KPFK Work Reductions ....signs of an ending now, so soon ?
kPFK under threatening duress - even to it's long-established staff by new Gen'l Mgr
Secretive Glonvec weapons manufacturer in town
KPFK in MeltDown.NOW.
KPFK RADIO is essential to Pacifica, who also umbrellas KPFA that may be falling away
More Local News...
Investigate UNRWA spokesperson Chris Gunness for violating UNRWA's Mandate
Ukrainians Overwhelmingly Oppose Junta Rule
Dubious Sponsor Launches Petition to End Gaza Blockade
Eternity Warriors 4 Hack mod apk 2015 [Coins,Diamonds and Energy] cheats Android iOS
Score Hero Hack iOS Android Cheats
Dragon Story Country Picnic Hack iOS Android Cheats
Ski Safari 2 [Hack] telecharger gratuit [Coins] Android iOS
Egypt's War on Press Freedom
Pocket Platoons hack adder unlimited Gold,War Bonds cheats
Eternity Warriors 4 Hack apk cheats ios android
Right-Wing DC Court of Appeals Upholds Unconstitutional Surveillance
Facebook Hack for passwords
Fbi methods are unconscionable
Fashion Diva Hack adder unlimited Coins cheats Android iOS
Black New Orleans 10 Years Post-Katrina
908 Environmentalists Have Been Murdered in Brazil, Many Elsewhere As Well
Wall Street Rally: Hold the Cheers
Shell paid out $15.5 Million over Saro-Wiwa Murder
Washington Intends Breaching Iran Nuclear Deal
Florida State Attorney's Office, Unethical
Phony Reports of Russian Casualties in Ukraine Resurface
The Shortwave Report 08/28/15 Listen Globally!
DEFROST A Virtual Reality Short Movie
Fabricated Pentagon Reports on ISIS
Rabbis Against Peace and Stability
Differing Views on China
Monied Interests Run America
NUCLEAR SHUTDOWN NEWS August 2015
More Breaking News...