imc indymedia
white themeblack themered themetheme help
About Us Contact Us Subscribe Calendar Publish RSS
Features
latest news
best of news
syndication
commentary


KILLRADIO

CopWatch LA

ABCF LA

Activist Video

Dope-X-Resistance-LA List

LAAMN List





IMC Network: www.indymedia.org africa: ambazonia canarias estrecho / madiaq kenya nigeria south africa canada: hamilton london, ontario maritimes montreal ontario ottawa quebec thunder bay vancouver victoria windsor winnipeg east asia: burma jakarta japan korea manila qc europe: abruzzo alacant andorra antwerpen armenia athens austria barcelona belarus belgium belgrade bristol brussels bulgaria calabria croatia cyprus emilia-romagna estrecho / madiaq euskal herria galiza germany grenoble hungary ireland istanbul italy la plana liege liguria lille linksunten lombardia london madrid malta marseille nantes napoli netherlands nice northern england norway oost-vlaanderen paris/Île-de-france patras piemonte poland portugal roma romania russia saint-petersburg scotland sverige switzerland thessaloniki torun toscana toulouse ukraine united kingdom valencia latin america: argentina bolivia chiapas chile chile sur cmi brasil colombia ecuador mexico peru puerto rico qollasuyu rosario santiago tijuana uruguay valparaiso venezuela venezuela oceania: adelaide aotearoa brisbane burma darwin jakarta manila melbourne perth qc sydney south asia: india mumbai united states: arizona arkansas asheville atlanta austin baltimore big muddy binghamton boston buffalo charlottesville chicago cleveland colorado columbus dc hawaii houston hudson mohawk kansas city la madison maine miami michigan milwaukee minneapolis/st. paul new hampshire new jersey new mexico new orleans north carolina north texas nyc oklahoma philadelphia pittsburgh portland richmond rochester rogue valley saint louis san diego san francisco san francisco bay area santa barbara santa cruz, ca sarasota seattle tampa bay tennessee urbana-champaign vermont western mass worcester west asia: armenia beirut israel palestine process: fbi/legal updates mailing lists process & imc docs tech volunteer projects: print radio satellite tv video regions: oceania united states topics: biotech
printable version - email this article - view hidden posts - spam score
link:

Riverside Council Member disses community police commission

by Mary Shelton Thursday, Apr. 21, 2005 at 9:48 AM
chicalocaside@yahoo.com

A Riverside City Council member calls the Police Commission a piece of trash, yet no one will put his comment in the written record... Why?

By Mary Shelton

The Community Police Review Commission presented its annual report to the Riverside City Council on April 12, one week after a councilman derided the commission, calling it a piece of trash.

At the earlier meeting, Councilman Art Gage had spoken against the commission, also calling it junk and saying that he would like to see it gone. After he spoke, Councilmen Dom Betro and Ameal Moore took Gage to task for his words, and reaffirmed their support for the beleaguered commission. Over 30 people in the audience also expressed their support by applauding after Betro and Moore finished speaking.

A more subdued city council listened to CPRC Chair Michael Gardner as he outlined both progress made, and problems encountered by the CPRC, including a "deteriorating" relationship with the police department. Gardner said that communications between the CPRC and the department had become a "paper war" and that more face to face discussions were needed.

The report also stated that the quality of complaint investigations done by field sergeants had decreased during the past year. The department currently assigns over half of complaints to the field division for investigation.

According to Gardner, the department continues to assign citizen complaints to field sergeants who witnessed the incident under investigation. Most seriously, the department continued to assign sergeants to investigate incidents they witnessed, and incidents where they directed the officer to commit an action which was complained about. The agency even continued to assign sergeants to investigate incidents where their own actions were the subject of a complaint. Five years ago, the CPRC submitted a policy recommendation, stating that the department should not engage in the practice of assigning sergeants to investigate alleged misconduct committed either by them or officers they supervised, yet the department still willfully engaged in this practice and appears reluctant to drop this practice.

The problems with assigning involved field sergeants to investigate complaints manifested itself further through biased interrogation tactics used by these sergeants during their investigations. In some cases, according to the report, sergeants fail to interview all the witnesses, which is mandated by departmental policy. Sergeants also fail to ask questions which elicited facts, but were instead biased in favor of the officer, such as saying "you did this for safety reasons, right" rather than asking an officer, why did you do that?

Gardner said that it appeared that the field sergeants believed it was "their job to protect the ranks". A conclusion which is no surprise to community members who have long argued that a department can not fairly investigate its own employees. In 2001, State Attorney General Bill Lockyer agreed, when he alleged that the department's complaint process had violated state law, according to court records. The ongoing problems with the department's complaint investigations also fly in the face of critics of the CPRC who have said that they believed Internal Affairs did an adequate job investigating citizen complaints.

To combat this ongoing problem, the CPRC will put together an investigation evaluation mechanism this year, the report stated.

Problems with how the Internal Affairs division investigates officer-involved shootings also continued to frustrate the CPRC. After reviewing the 2003 shooting of Anastacio Munoz, the CPRC recommended that the Internal Affairs division either conduct its own independent investigation as required by policy, or amend its policy to match its current practice of simply reviewing the department's criminal investigation. This policy recommendation was put on hold by the city manager's office upon resolution of a law suit filed by the Riverside Police Officers' Association against the city. In its law suit, the RPOA said the department violated the policy, governing the investigation of officer-involved shootings. According to court records, both parties settled the law suit last week.

The cases submitted to the CPRC continue to decrease, but it remained unclear whether this was due to increased training and supervision of officers or disillusionment by city residents towards the complaint process. The downtown area continues to generate the highest number of personnel complaints, followed by both the La Sierra and Eastside neighborhoods. Casa Blanca, the center of several controversial use of force incidents last year generated only four complaints even though community members held several meetings with the police department and protested near City Hall, against several police officers assigned to their area who they alleged engaged in excessive force against community members.

According to the report, the CPRC received 90 cases, a sharp reduction from last year. It sustained 10 percent of all allegations, including one allegation of excessive force and 29 percent of the allegations, received a not sustained finding. Last year, the CPRC sustained 11 percent of all allegations, with 27 percent receiving a not sustained finding. The report attributed the decline in filed cases to officers becoming increasingly cognizant of how their words, actions and demeanors are interpreted by people they encounter.

Two policy recommendations were rejected by the department last year.

A policy recommendation that addressed officers searching suspects of the opposite gender, was met with a statement from the department that the current policy in place, was effective. Another policy recommendation that the complaint form be changed so that complainant personal information including address and telephone numbers was not accessible to the officer who was the subject of the complaint. The department rejected this recommendation, stating that there was no compelling reason to implement it.

There was not much discussion of the report by the city council, although both Betro and Nancy Hart spoke in favor of the CPRC, saying that it provided a vital service to the city's residents.

However, the CPRC continues to draw opposition from the city council, even after being included in the city's charter.

Gage's comments about the CPRC at the April 7 meeting were only his latest coming about a month after he said he wished he could disband the CPRC at a Finance Committee meeting. Gage is one of four council members who were heavily funded by the RPOA, which strongly opposes the CPRC, during their past elections. When he first ran for office in 2003, Gage received $14,000 in financial contributions from the RROA. In September 2004, he received another $2,500 from the RPOA, according to his year-end campaign disclosure statements. Last year, he proposed motions to severely reduce the CPRC's operating budget, but failed to receive any support from the rest of the council. When Gage made his latest controversial comments, fellow councilmen Steve Adams, Frank Schiavone and Ed Adkison remained silent on the issue. Combined, the three men received over $25,000 in contributions from the RPOA during their past elections, with Schiavone receiving another $3,000 on Nov. 1, 2004 according to campaign disclosure statements.

Gage has said publicly he will abide by the will of the voters and not try to cut its funding. It remains to be seen of which words he has spoken, he will remain true.

One commissioner said last week that this was not good enough.

"Art Gage owes the commission an apology," Sheri Corral, a ward 3 resident, said.
Report this post as:

add your comments


Local News

LAPD's High-Tech "War Room" F10 7:07AM

OCCUPY PRESS RELEASE: 8 CHALLENGES TO WELLS FARGO (FEB 6, 2012) F09 4:00PM

8 CHALLENGES TO WELLS FARGO FROM OCCUPY ACTIVISTS F08 3:11PM

Resolution in Support of Warehouse Workers at Walmart Contractor Schneider Logistics F07 12:53AM

Construction workers picket new gym in Upland F06 11:59PM

F29 Double-sided flyer (English and Spanish) in PDF form F06 4:52PM

STOP A "NAFTA OF THE PACIFIC!" RALLY VS SECRET NEGOTIATIONS HELD IN SOFITEL HOTEL IN LA F06 10:04AM

Los Angeles participates in national day of action against war in Iran F06 12:43AM

Protecting Sacred Sites: The Kuruvungna Springs F05 9:08PM

Press Release for Monday Occupy Meeting with Wells Fargo Execs (3-5:30pm) F05 9:02AM

What's Left for the Left? Building a Blue-Green Coalition F05 7:57AM

San Diego Queer Democrats Reject Progressive, Endorse Moderate for Congress F04 1:03PM

How Mike Kelley Helped Me Paint My Way Out of a Prison Cell F04 12:41PM

Protest: ELA Police Checkpoint F03 11:03AM

Cornel West lectures on social justice; PD harasses occupier for flyering F01 10:12PM

WHY OCCUPY art exhibit F01 1:16AM

Trans Pacific Free Trade Agreement Action Wed! J31 5:35PM

Even Local Businesses Support Efforts to Save LAUSD Adult Education J30 1:46AM

F29 SHUTDOWN THE CORPORATIONS CALL TO ACTION: Occupy Walmart! J28 11:55PM

Retenes este fin de semana / Weekend checkpoints (26-28/jan/2012) J26 4:05AM

Occupy Redlands Protests Citizens United Decision J26 2:06AM

BREAKING: Five Arrested at Protest Outside HLS Office. J24 2:45PM

RAISETHEFIST.COM MARKS 10 YEAR ANNIVERSARY OF FBI RAID J24 6:39AM

UCR Occupied in Defense of Education J23 12:11AM

Homeless persons have no value to the authorities J19 10:15PM

BREAKING: Students at UCR force regents to adjourn J19 10:39AM

On MLK Day, Dedicate Ourselves for the Final Struggle for Justice and Equality J16 8:11AM

L.A. PORT POLICE & L.A. COUNTY SHERIFF CONSPIRE IN KIDNAPPING OF CARPENTER J12 5:49PM

More Local News...

Other/Breaking News

Iran's Historic Anniversary F12 1:05AM

Khader Adnan's Heroic Struggle for Justice F12 12:40AM

Turkish daily: Turkey’s plan to finish off Assad F11 4:06PM

In new window Print all Turkish daily: Turkey’s plan to finish off Assad F11 3:55PM

Trump Cards, Fig Leafs and Ludicrous Insinuations F11 9:23AM

NATO's Secret War on Syria F11 1:20AM

America's Sham Economic Recovery F11 12:52AM

Palabras para Agustín F10 6:07PM

Wall Street Excess and Main Street Distress: the Apple Connection F10 5:11PM

Sheriff Arpaio and Cronies Exposed in Federal Court F10 2:45PM

RON PAUL SUPPORTS HR 210, FILVETS F10 2:27PM

Nazi USA's military displays Nazi Germany's SS flag F10 7:25AM

Duplicitous Mortgage Settlement Deal F10 12:50AM

Murdering Khadar Adnan F10 12:31AM

Factory Place Open Studio Sale F09 6:22PM

The Shortwave Report 02/10 Listen Globally! F09 5:30PM

Domestic Violence Is NOT a Gender Issue! F09 4:06PM

La farce électorale F09 9:13AM

Dominant Economy Pretends Its Breakdown Was Unforeseeable F09 8:39AM

Petition to Cal Sec of State to list all Peace & Freedom Candidates F09 8:33AM

Act Up Against ACTA F09 1:57AM

Gaza: Isolated Under Siege F09 12:42AM

SECRETARY OF STATE LIST OF PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATES CALLED "UNLAWFUL" F08 2:03PM

Democrats Defeated Single Payer; Vote P&F & Green F08 8:25AM

From Protest Camp to General Strike F08 8:24AM

Prop 8 Struck Down by Federal Court F08 1:49AM

Targeting Syria and Iran F08 12:39AM

Economic Recovery? What Recovery? F08 12:36AM

More Breaking News...
© 2000-2003 Los Angeles Independent Media Center. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by the Los Angeles Independent Media Center. Running sf-active v0.9.4 Disclaimer | Privacy