imc sf.indymedia.orgindymedia
About Us Contact Us Subscribe Calendar Publish RSS
white themeblack themered themetheme help
Features
latest news
best of news
syndication
commentary


KILLRADIO

CopWatch LA

ABCF LA





IMC Network: www.indymedia.org africa: ambazonia canarias estrecho / madiaq kenya nigeria south africa canada: hamilton london, ontario maritimes montreal ontario ottawa quebec thunder bay vancouver victoria windsor winnipeg east asia: burma jakarta japan manila qc europe: alacant andorra antwerpen armenia athens austria barcelona belarus belgium belgrade bristol bulgaria calabria croatia cyprus emilia-romagna estrecho / madiaq euskal herria galiza germany grenoble hungary imc patras ireland istanbul italy la plana liege lille lombardia madrid malta marseille nantes napoli netherlands nice norway oost-vlaanderen paris/Île-de-france piemonte poland portugal roma romania russia saint-petersburg scotland sverige switzerland thessaloniki torun toscana toulouse ukraine united kingdom valencia latin america: argentina bolivia brasil chiapas chile chile sur colombia ecuador mexico peru puerto rico qollasuyu rosario santiago tijuana uruguay valparaiso venezuela oceania: adelaide aotearoa brisbane burma darwin jakarta manila melbourne perth qc sydney south asia: india mumbai united states: arizona arkansas asheville atlanta austin baltimore big muddy binghamton boston buffalo charlottesville chicago cleveland colorado columbus dc hampton roads, va hawaii houston hudson mohawk idaho ithaca kansas city la madison maine miami michigan milwaukee minneapolis/st. paul new hampshire new jersey new mexico new orleans north carolina north texas nyc oklahoma omaha philadelphia pittsburgh portland richmond rochester rogue valley saint louis san diego san francisco san francisco bay area santa barbara santa cruz, ca sarasota seattle tallahassee-red hills tampa bay tennessee urbana-champaign vermont western mass worcester west asia: armenia beirut israel palestine process: fbi/legal updates mailing lists process & imc docs tech volunteer projects: print radio satellite tv video regions: oceania united states topics: biotech
printable version - email this article - view hidden posts
link:

Lies spinning to fascism
by Parmenides Monday, Jun. 23, 2003 at 1:37 AM

As the bush cabal hurtles America towards fascism, war is about to be declared on the 'enemy within'...

Now Bush wants to buy the complicity of aid workers

Relief groups have been told they must be an "arm of the US government"

Naomi Klein
Monday June 23, 2003
The Guardian

The Bush administration has found its next target for pre-emptive war, but it's not Iran, Syria or North Korea. Not yet anyway.

Before launching any new foreign adventures, the Bush gang has some homeland housekeeping to take care of: it is going to sweep up those pesky non-governmental organisations that are helping to turn world opinion against US bombs and brands.

The war on NGOs is being fought on two clear fronts. One buys the silence and complicity of mainstream humanitarian and religious groups by offering lucrative reconstruction contracts. The other marginalises and criminalises more independent-minded NGOs by claiming that their work is a threat to democracy. The US Agency for International Development (USaid) is in charge of handing out the carrots, while the American Enterprise Institute, the most powerful think-tank in Washington, is wielding the sticks.

On May 21 in Washington, Andrew Natsios, the head of USaid, gave a speech blasting US NGOs for failing to play a role many of them didn't realise they had been assigned: doing public relations for the US government. According to InterAction, the network of 160 relief and development NGOs, Natsios was "irritated" that starving and sick Iraqi and Afghan children didn't realise that their food and vaccines were coming to them courtesy of George Bush. From now on, NGOs had to do a better job of link ing their humanitarian assistance to US foreign policy and making it clear that they are "an arm of the US government". If they didn't, InterAction reported, "Natsios threatened to personally tear up their contracts and find new partners".

For aid workers, there are even more strings attached to US dollars. USaid told several NGOs that have been awarded humanitarian contracts that they cannot speak to the media - all requests from reporters must go through Washington. Mary McClymont, CEO of InterAction, calls the demands "unprecedented" and says: "It looks like the NGOs aren't independent and can't speak for themselves about what they see and think."

Many humanitarian leaders are shocked to hear their work described as "an arm" of government - most see themselves as independent (that would be the "non-governmental" part of the name). The best NGOs are loyal to their causes, not to countries, and they aren't afraid to blow the whistle on their own governments. Think of Médecins Sans Frontières standing up to the White House and the European Union over Aids drug patents, or Human Rights Watch's campaign against the death penalty in the US.

Natsios embraced this independence in his previous job as vice president of World Vision. During the North Korean famine, Natsios didn't hesitate to blast his own government for withholding food aid, calling the Clinton administration's response "too slow" and its claim that politics was not a factor "total nonsense".

Don't expect candour like that from the aid groups Natsios now oversees in Iraq. These days, NGOs are supposed to do nothing more than quietly pass out care packages with a big "brought to you by the US" logo attached - in public-private partnerships with Bechtel and Halliburton, of course.

That is the message of "NGO Watch", an initiative of the American Enterprise Institute and the Federalist Society for Law and Public Policy Studies that takes aim at the growing political influence of the non-profit sector. The stated purpose of the website, launched on June 11, is to "bring clarity and accountability to the burgeoning world of NGOs". In fact, it is a McCarthyite blacklist, telling tales on any NGO that dares speak against Bush administration policies or in support of international treaties opposed by the White House.

This bizarre initiative takes as its premise the idea that there is something sinister about "unelected" groups of citizens getting together to try to influence their government. "The extraordinary growth of advocacy NGOs in liberal democracies has the potential to undermine the sovereignty of constitutional democracies," the site claims.

Coming from the AEI, this is not without irony. As Raj Patel, policy analyst at the California-based NGO Food First, points out: "The American Enterprise Institute is an NGO itself and it is supported by the most powerful corporations on the planet. They are accountable only to their board, which includes Motorola, American Express and ExxonMobil."

As for influence, few peddle it quite like the AEI, whose looniest of ideas have a habit of becoming Bush administration policy. And no wonder. Richard Perle, member and former chairman of the Pentagon's Defence Policy Board, is an AEI fellow, along with Lynne Cheney, the wife of the vice-president, and the Bush administration is crowded with former AEI fellows. As President Bush said at an AEI dinner in February: "At the American Enterprise Institute, some of the finest minds in our nation are at work on some of the greatest challenges to our nation. You do such good work that my administration has borrowed 20 such minds."

In other words, the AEI is more than a think-tank - it's Bush's outsourced brain. Taken together with Natsios's statements, this attack on the non-profit sector marks the emergence of a new Bush doctrine: NGOs should be nothing more than the charity wing of the mili tary, silently mopping up after wars and famines. Their job is not to ask how these tragedies could have been averted, or to advocate solutions. And it is certainly not to join anti-war and globalisation movements pushing for real political change.

The control freaks in the White House have really outdone themselves this time. First they tried to silence governments critical of their foreign policies by buying them off with aid packages and trade deals. (Last month US trade representative Robert Zoellick said that the US would only enter into new trade agreements with countries that offered "cooperation or better on foreign policy and security issues".)

Next they made sure the press didn't ask hard question during the war by trading journalistic access for editorial control. Now they are attempting to turn relief workers in Iraq and Afghanistan into publicists for Bush's Brand US. The US government is usually described as "unilateralist", but I don't think that's quite accurate. The Bush administration may be willing to go it alone, but what it really wants is legions of self-censoring followers, from foreign governments to national journalists and international NGOs.

This is not a lone wolf we are dealing with; it's a sheep-herder. The question is: which of the NGOs will play the

add your comments


Local News

LA Indymedia Film Night Report Back M17 1:41PM

2 Weeks to Save Rent Control, No on 98-June 3 M17 7:43AM

Hey, Arnold! No Budget Cuts 4 CA Education: Segerstrom Hi Students & Teachers Speak Out M16 10:28PM

Transgender Student Denied Name and Gender Change Sues University Administrators M16 9:15PM

Minute Men plan to protest CSUN Chicana/o Studies Graduation M16 3:43AM

Anti-War San Diego Congressional Candidate Hosts Forum M15 10:06PM

IS CALIFORNIA REALLY BROKE? M15 8:34PM

Santa Ana Labor Rally: HEY, ARNOLD! NO BUDGET CUTS! M15 8:29PM

Gay Marriage Legalized in Cal; A Bright Light in Fascist Times M15 7:22PM

CDIR-USA Condemns ICE Raids in Los Angeles and Iowa M15 8:13AM

This Friday 5pm Echo Park Vigil - No Justice No Peace M13 5:50PM

MP3 AUDIO – Protest at Occidental Petroleum Headquarters M13 10:05AM

ActionLA: URGENT Fund Raising Appeals for the China's Earthquake Victims M13 9:53AM

MP3 AUDIO: Interview with Clara Irazábal, Venezuelan Architect and Urban Planner M12 6:43PM

May Day 2008 International Workers Day and Immigrant Mobilization Report!! M10 6:04PM

A Weekly Vigil is Launched for Haiti and Kidnapped Human Rights Activist M10 12:11PM

May Day revival on three fronts: labor, immigrant, and antiwar M09 2:00AM

Grace Aaron Committee to Strengthen KPFK Run Station Board Shuts Down Web User Forums M09 1:29AM

LA TRASH Fees ROCKETING again M08 2:57PM

cal state LA student sit in M08 12:35PM

Cal state LA students protest budget cuts with sit in M08 12:19PM

Radical Marching Band startig in LA M07 2:04PM

Prop 98 can provoke a city-wide rent strike in San Francisco, LA, and elsewhere.. M07 11:36AM

THE END OF JUSTICE M06 5:25PM

Another So.Cal Police Officer Sentenced In the wake of Rampart corruption scandal M06 12:44PM

Day Laborer Remebered, 1 year after Killed in Rancho Cucamonga during Minutemen Protest M05 7:52PM

The minutemen had a rally and nobody came M05 3:54PM

New Blackwater Controversy on the U.S.-Mexico Border M05 12:39PM

More Local News...

Other/Breaking News

Osama: Palestinian Cause Was 'Main Factor' for 9/11 M18 4:03AM

Senate Candidate Fran Pavley Upsets Supporters with Code Words in Health Care Mailer M18 1:23AM

AST ATTACK - OWNED BY M4NTUS M17 6:09PM

On Independence Day, Israeli Arabs Reminded of Their Place M17 1:33PM

La batalla por la democracia local participativa no es una batalla perdida, sino abortada M17 12:08PM

The fight for Filipino veterans' equity: A struggle against racism M17 11:54AM

“Hunger riots”, it's the struggle of the proletariat! M17 11:02AM

Struggle for Water M17 10:04AM

Hidden Things You Do Not Know! 5/14 M17 10:02AM

AJLPP APPLAUDS SAME SEX MARRIAGE RIGHTS VICTORY IN CALIFORNIA M17 9:47AM

Devilvision: The World's New Wireless Grid M17 7:41AM

How secure in our food supply? M17 6:50AM

Wake-up, America! M17 3:55AM

Warning: Presidential Candidates Not Offering to Repair and Reinstate the US Constitution! M17 1:27AM

Mexican President Rushes more Troops to U.S. Mexican border city Juarez M16 10:02PM

Mission accomplished? PNAC Website Expired M16 7:54PM

Memorias del “Poder Popular” en la economía venezolana M16 6:59PM

British firm 'polishes up' Tsvangirai for presidency M16 5:43PM

Weekend of Peace, love, & Music - Jazz Reggae Festival at UCLA MAY 25-26 M16 3:55PM

Anti-Gypsy sentiments out of control in Italy M16 2:43PM

Grow Them Young, Pay Them Well - anti-Chavistas, That Is M16 1:23PM

Grow Them Young, Pay Them Well - anti-Chavistas, That Is M16 1:23PM

Once a felon, always a felon M16 10:46AM

While Suppresing Voices from UCLA ISSE Students, Jim Lafferty States Their Message Well M16 3:17AM

Icons of Tibetan Enlightenment M15 11:12PM

Swissair,9/11,Israel,Ehud Olmert,ICTS International,Global Technologies,Money Launderers M15 10:48PM

Bio-Jet Fuel M15 7:14PM

The Shortwave Report 5/16 Listen Globally! M15 4:40PM

More Breaking News...


© 2000-2003 Los Angeles Independent Media Center. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by the Los Angeles Independent Media Center. Running sf-active v0.9.4 Disclaimer | Privacy